Fourth West Virginia Infantry

In the early recruitment of "Virginia" Union troops in western Virginia a number of the regiments were composed of Ohioans and Pennsylvanians, whose own state recruitment had been filled and thus were welcomed by the Wheeling government as "Virginians".

 

According to Whitelaw Reid, in Vol. 2 of his work, "Ohio in the War", pg. 919, he wrote:

"This regiment, although mustered into the service as a Virginia organization, was recruited mainly in Ohio. Seven full companies of it were recruited in the counties of Meigs, Gallia, Lawrence, and Athens. These numbered some six hundred men. Portions of the remaining companies were also interspersed with Ohioans."

On page 918 he lists the officers by date of service and adds remarks. Of the 39 officers listed as to place, 27 are from Ohio and 2 from Maryland, only 10 are from West Virginia.

Last year I was told, by a source I usually trust, that the Fourth WV Infantry was composed mostly of West Virginians. According to my source-

"We show that about 9% of the regiment (total of 104 soldiers) enlisted within the State of Ohio -- which, roughly, would amount to one company -- if they were all in the same company.  This, of course, is certainly far short of seven companies.  The specific breakdown by companies is:   Athens Co. -- 45 soldiers; Gallia Co. -- 25 soldiers; Meigs Co. -- 8 soldiers; Lawrence Co. -- 2 soldiers; Morgan, Jackson, Richland & Hamilton -- 1 soldier each;  Ohio, but county not designated -- 20 soldiers."

 

Personally, I cannot credit this assessment. First of all, I find it hard to believe that Ohioans seem to have forgotten where their men were. Secondly, we have the reminiscences of an Ohioan of the 4th WV Infanty, Thomas H. Barton, and this is what he says in his autobiography, pages 74-75:

"About the first of July, Judge P. B. Stansberry and William Brown, of Pomeroy, and Ephraim Carson, of Racine, began recruiting for the fourth regiment of West Virginia infantry. They were assisted by Britton Cook, of Syracuse, and myself. A company was soon made up. I joined this organization and became a member of Company E.

In taking this step, I was actuated by motives of patriotism.I shouldered my musket in defence of the Union; but I had no idea of abandoning my profession, and intended, if spared, to resume the practice of medicine at the expiration of my term of service. My wife was patriotic, and readily gave her consent to my enlistment. But it was hard to part with the loved ones, not knowing whether or not I would ever return; and when I was about to bid farewell to those who were near and dear to me, my little daughter said. "Doc, you must not go to war, for you will get shot."

Company E. was mustered into the United States service, July 22d, 1861, and went into camp at Mason City, West Virginia. I was advised by some of the comrades to be a candidate for the office of Second Lieutenant, but held back till near the hour of election. I then wrote a number of ballots, and went to the place of election, when the loud hurrah of the company was heard cheering the newly elected officers. William Brown was chosen Captain; P. B. Stansberry, First Lieutenant; and Ephraim Carson, Second Lieutenant. These gentlemen are all well known in Meigs county, and were men of integrity and ability, and made able and efficient officers.

Company E. was recruited mainly at Pomeroy, Racine and Syracuse, with a few recruits from Mason county, West Virginia. Companies H. and K. were recruited in West Virginia, the former from the counties along the Kanawha River, and the latter at or near Grafton. The other companies were recruited in Meigs, Gallia, and Athens counties, Ohio, and Mason county, West Virginia. The regimental officers were : J. A. J. Lightburn, Colonel; William H. H. Russell, Lieutenant Colonel; and John P. Hall, Major. George K. Ackley, of Racine, was appointed Surgeon of the regiment."

 

Above is the roster of officers from Whitelaw Reid's "Ohio in the War", vol. 2, pg. 918. As you read in Mr. Barton's narrative, the men voted for the officers of the company: Captain, 1st Lieutenant and 2nd Lieutenant. From Mr. Reid's roster, the officers for the 10 companies and their home towns for the 1861 organization are as follows:

A-Mason City, WV; Pomeroy, OH; Mason City, WV

B-Gallipolis, OH; Gallipolis, OH; Middleport, OH

C-Pomeroy, OH; Letart, WV; Pomeroy, OH

D-Athens, OH; Athens, OH; Athens, OH

E-Pomeroy, OH Pomeroy, OH; Pomeroy, OH

F-Pomeroy, OH; Murraysville, WV; Murraysville, WV

G-Gallipolis, OH; Gallipolis, OH; Gallipolis, OH

H-Pomeroy, OH; Pomeroy, OH; Pomeroy, OH

I-Gallipolis, OH; Gallipolis, OH; Gallipolis, OH

K-New Creek, WV; Cumberland, MD; Frostburg, MD

Company K actually was recruited from Mineral County, WV and in Maryland. If you look at the officers elected for that company they are from that area. Mr. Barton said that Company H was recruited along the Kanawha, but the officers are all from Pomeroy, OH. It is possible that he meant Company A or F. Of the 10 companies, 6 have officers entirely from Ohio. If, as my usually trustworthy source said, only 9% of this regiment was from Ohio, it makes me wonder why Ohioans are taking 73% of the officer positions.

 

Another item which supports the traditional view of the 4th WV as a basically Ohio unit is this short article from the Gallipolis [Ohio] Journal, April 10, 1862.

 

 

It would seem that Ohioans had a rather prurient interest in the regiment's income if, as some suppose, this regiment had been composed mostly of West Virginians. However, it would not be so prurient if in fact most of the men came from southern Ohio, in which case they would have a legitimate interest in the money the regiment earned.

 

 

This is from Hardesty's "History of Gallia County", Publ: 1882 - H. H. Hardesty & Co., Publishers, Chicago & Toledo:

 

"During May, 1861, application was made to Governor Dennison for authority to raise another company, but the one [from Gallia County] making the application was told by the governor that applications were already on file, tendering more men than the State could ever expect to sue in crushing the rebellion. At the suggestion of the Governor, who gave a strong letter upon the subject, an interview was had with General George B. McClellan, then stationed at Cincinnati. General McClellan, after listening to the representations made, gave authority for the organization of loyal Virginians. Under this authority the enlistment of men for three years was begun, with headquarters at Mason City, Virginia. Gallia county supplied many men for this service before Ohio began organizing three years' regiments. Three hundred of them were probably mustered into the 4th Virginia Infantry, under command of officers from Gallia county. During the spring and summer of 1861, an equal number entered other than Ohio regiments."

 

 

The Gallipolis Journal [Gallia County], October 3, 1861 

 

 The mustering points for the 4th West Virginia Infantry were in Mason County, WV. As I have viewed the 1890 Census of Union Veterans and Widows for Mason County I found only approximately 90 names belonging to the 4th out of 66 pages of names. You can view those census pages HERE.

 

One final indication that most of the men were not from West Virginia is the vote returns on the Willey Amendment to the new state constitution held on March 26, 1863. Wheeling was determined to get as many votes for the amendment as possible and arranged for voting to be held for all regiments. The Fourth Infantry had been given orders in mid-December, 1862, to take transport down the Ohio River to Vicksburg, MS. They arrived on January 20, 1863, and were given the task of constructing earth works, they were not placed in combat until May. The regiment had lost about 142 men to death, discharge and desertion up to the day of the vote. Returns printed in the Wheeling Daily Intelligencer on April 1, 1863, show a vote from the Fourth Infantry as 193 for the amendment and 13 against, only 206 men out of 961 soldiers.

  

While all of this information I've gathered is circumstantial, it is also, I believe, a stong justification of my doubts that the 4th West Virginia Infantry is other than what Whitelaw Reid and Thomas Barton claim it to be, an Ohio regiment in West Virginia clothing. Anyone visiting the battlefield at Vicksburg may see a small monument to the 4th West Virginia Infantry on top of which is a bust of Major Azra B. Goodspeed, of Athens, Ohio.

Gallipolis (Ohio) Journal, April 3, 1862