ANALOGY

Simone Weil reminded us that Greek science begins with Thales’ formulation of the concept of similarity between triangles. And she wrote that “here science would seem to be only a more attentive perception.” But science changes: following Simone Weil, Greek science was about numbers, figures and machines, whereas now science seems to consist only of pure relations (Sur la science). But we are interested exactly in this greater attentiveness, i.e. in actions of paying closer attention to something: from the ancient Greeks to Douglas Hofstadter’s cognition-core hypothesis, and beyond. Constructing ever more accurate, ever subtler analogies is still a method of refining our knowledge. Hence we propose an introduction to this approach to analogy and its applications, which encompasses its history but also new perspectives. We present selected and basic issues related to various concepts of analogy. We put a strong focus on their special and delightful flexibility: using analogies not only opens new areas and values within the metaphysical universe, but also teaches us attention in Simone Weil’s sense, and humility in a dialogical meeting with the Other.

1. The meaning of the term "analogy" and standard approach

  • analogia attributionis

  • analogia proportionalitatis

  • analogia proportionalitatis propria

  • analogia proportionalitatis metaphorica

2. Selected trends in research on analogy: from the history of Polish logic

  • Salamucha’s discussion on the formalization of analogical notions

  • Bocheński’s sixteen relations between semantic complexes

  • applications of analogical reasoning in the history of art

3. The flexibility of analogy: extraordinary implementations

  • Strawson’s therapeutic and grammatical analogies

  • Ryle’s analogy of a map or charting, i.e. the logical geography of concepts

  • idealizations as methods for constructing an appropriate image and a correct caricature

  • analogy-making in action: logical triangles, squares, hexagons, octagons of love, gratefulness, responsibility, and compassion