The Miami Dolphins have been a completely frustrating team to watch over the last couple of seasons. They have a roster with plenty of talent and speed, a likable head coach, tremendous facilities, and yet all they have given us is complete mediocrity. Entering the 2025 season, both Mike McDaniel and general manager Chris Grier find their jobs on the hot seat. Either they finally live up to their potential and establish themselves as a respected playoff contender or nothing changes and the entire team might get blown up as a result.


Tua Tagovailoa is always the biggest X factor on this football team. When he is on the field, he has proven to be a solid starting quarterback. Yet the problem is that he has had serious injury concerns throughout his career, and when he is out, the entire team plummets. It should not be this way because this offense is the fastest in all of football. When you have De’Von Achane as the lead back, along with Tyreek Hill and Jaylen Waddle as your top two receiving options, that should be a recipe for success. Heck, Jonnu Smith had a breakout season with the team last year and his athleticism should never be taken for granted. Miami also signed Nick Westbrook-Ikhine to give this offense more verticality, so Tua will have an extra weapon if nobody else is open. The only real liability on Miami’s offense is their front five. Terron Armstead retired, their interior line is alarming, and Austin Jackson is the only player that has put in consistent production. I have hopes for their second round pick Jonah Savaiinaea, but this line needs to keep Tua standing in the pocket at all costs. If Larry Borom and Andrew Brewer are starting at key positions, that is a problem. Against inferior opponents, the Dolphins look like a perennial Super Bowl contender. Yet any time they play teams on their level, they mainly shrink. This group is going to be under more pressure than ever before, especially with how shaky that defense looks entering the season.


If Jalen Ramsey gets traded before the season begins, then Miami’s defense is going to be on its heels almost every single week. Bradley Chubb and Jaelan Phillips have been injury prone, several members of their secondary were either cut or they departed in free agency, and it is rushing their younger guys in the developmental process. The silver lining is that defensive coordinator Anthony Weaver Jr. has promising pieces like Chop Robinson, Zach Sieler and Tyrel Dodson to take charge of this group. Rookie Kenneth Grant will hope to make an instant impact at the nose tackle. The front office kept veteran pieces like Jordyn Brooks and Willie Gay to stabilize the linebacking corps as their run defense did not disappoint last year. Kader Kohou is a rising nickel corner, but you need guys on the outside to make a great first impression. 


I think that even if Tua plays in all seventeen games, this team is going to be mediocrity personified. Their track record has proven over the last couple of years that whenever adversity on the field hits them, they crumble under the pressure. It does not matter who they add or subtract on the roster if they do not have the mental toughness to overcome any obstacles they might have to face. If that is the case, then the McDaniel-Grier era will have to come to an end.