From a football perspective, I seriously do not understand why the Indianapolis Colts have not decided to blow it up. They have not been in a Super Bowl since Peyton Manning was in town, their last conference championship appearance was with Andrew Luck, and their last time in the playoffs had Philip Rivers under center. Since then, every season has gotten more frustrating and depressing. Carson Wentz choked in the final two weeks of the 2021 season, then Matt Ryan proved to be cooked the following year, Gardner Minshew nearly got this team into the playoffs, and a quarterback carousel cost them a chance of redemption just last year. General manager Chris Ballard and head coach Shane Steichen have to turn things around in 2025 or else both of them might not be with the team anymore.

The biggest reason why I am not so high on the Colts this season is very simple: their starting quarterback. I had a lot of hopes for Anthony Richardson, but he did not do himself any favors last year. He was highly inaccurate, he literally tapped out during a must-win game against the Texans in the middle of the season, and there were times when Joe Flacco led the offense significantly better. So what does Indianapolis do to give him competition? Sign Daniel Jones! Because they saw how he performed after the Giants panicked into giving him a contract extension, the tumultuous events leading to release and said “We need him!” Who knows? If both of them implode, Riley Leonard is going to be the one to take them home. The Colts should not have this pedestrian of an offense because it has a bunch of talent! Jonathan Taylor is one of the best running backs in football and jumped right back onto the scene with 1400 yards and eleven touchdowns after a couple of injury-riddled seasons. Their receiving trio is one that a lot of quarterbacks would love to have featuring Michael Pittman Jr., Alec Pierce, and Josh Downs. They just drafted the best tight end prospect Tyler Warren with their first round pick and you know that he is going to be an immediate impactful player! Even their offensive line did well last year, giving up the seventh fewest sacks in the league, despite the fact that they did not have a quarterback! They will definitely take a little bit of a dip now that Will Fries and Ryan Kelly are gone, but they still have one of the best guards in Quenton Nelson to have as a centerpiece. 


Throughout the offseason, Indianapolis spent most of it fixing the defensive side of the ball. Former defensive coordinator Gus Bradley got shown the door and justifiably so because his units got worse the longer he was there. However, is Lou Anarumo really an upgrade? Since the Bengals went to the Super Bowl in 2021, his defenses also regressed as the years passed, and the team decided to move on from him after a god-awful 2024 season. Last year, the Colts defense ranked near the bottom in several categories. They allowed the fourth most total yards, the seventh most passing yards, the ninth most rushing yards, and the ninth most points. They totaled the seventh fewest sacks and allowed the third highest completion percentage, but the lone bright spot was that they accumulated twenty-five takeaways, the ninth most in the NFL. That sounds promising, but when you look at the negative stats, it just proves that opposing offenses are not afraid or intimidated to attack this Indianapolis defense. It should not be the case because just like the offense, it has a bunch of well-known players that have proven to make positive contributions in their respective roles. The front four has DeForest Buckner, Laiatu Latu, Grover Stewart, and Kwity Paye! They have Samson Ebukam returning to replace Dayo Odeyingbo, who recently left in free agency. The Colts had not one, not two, not three, but FOUR guys that totaled over 100 tackles last season! Two of them are their starting linebackers Zaire Franklin and EJ Speed, and the other two were Nick Cross and Jaylon Jones. In free agency, Indianapolis signed Camryn Bynum and Charavarius Ward to shore up the secondary, which helps the two aforementioned defensive backs plus Kenny Moore, Sam Womack and JuJu Brents. 


If their quarterback play improves, then this team will win between seven to eight games. However, if Anthony Richardson and Daniel Jones completely implode and prove to be the biggest weak links on the squad, then I don't even know how they will get five wins. The Colts cannot afford to have a terrible season so Steichen has to get the guys in his locker room to buy in and follow a more disciplined approach to winning football games. Otherwise, he is going to get fired and the new owner in charge is not going to be afraid to have Chris Ballard walk out the door either. Something has to give here one way or the other because this organization cannot repeat its constant cycle of mediocrity for another year.