So how are the Cincinnati Bengals going to underachieve this season? Don’t even think about leaving your jaw open to express that you are shocked, they do this every year. After losing the Super Bowl to the Rams and then the Chiefs in the AFC Championship the following season, the Bengals have followed the same script for the last two years. Get off to a horrible start, stumble early in the year, and then rattle off a bunch of wins just to barely miss the playoffs. 2024 was even more frustrating because that team was at full strength. Joe Burrow threw forty-three touchdown passes, Ja’Marr Chase was the Triple Crown winner, and Trey Hendrickson led the league in sacks. Yet they started the season 0-3, then 4-8, and finally pulled off five straight wins just to have a winning record. The Bengals cannot afford to repeat this cycle in 2025. Their offseason is already bleak, but if they fail to make the playoffs once again, then head Zac Taylor might have to look for another job. 


The biggest reason why the Bengals are relevant is because of their offense. Joe Burrow managed to play all seventeen games last year and post career-highs in almost every single category, which won him Comeback Player of the Year for the second time in his career. Chase Brown fell ten yards short of a thousand and totaled eleven touchdowns, so he has slowly emerged as a huge X factor for this offense. If he breaks out this season, then that passing attack is still going to be as dominant as it was the year before. I already mentioned Ja’Marr Chase leading the league in yards, catches, and touchdowns. However, the Bengals also have the best second option in the league: Tee Higgins. The first moves that the team made in the offseason? Sign both of them to long-term extensions. Along with tight end Mike Gesicki and third option Andrei Iosivas, the nucleus for Cincinnati’s offense will stay intact for the foreseeable future. However, the optimism becomes cautious when we talk about the offensive line. They allowed forty-eight sacks last season, and even with the release of Alex Cappa, there have not been any notable changes with that group. Since Burrow was drafted in 2020, this offensive line has been one of the worst in the league, and it is going to take a miracle for them to finally turn the corner. If they cannot protect their face of the franchise, then not only will the turnover rate increase, but the defense is going to further plummet.


Trey Hendrickson was quite possibly the lone bright spot of the defense, yet he is holding out in hopes for a new contract. After Sam Hubbard retired, the Bengals drafted Shemar Stewart in the first round! He is also holding out of training camp because the front office thought it would be a good idea to low-ball him. The same goes with their second round pick Demetrius Knight, the linebacker they drafted to replace the recently released Germaine Pratt. This has been the side of the ball that Cincinnati needed to fix the most over the past two seasons, yet they cannot even pay their top players right. This organization better figure something out soon because if either one of them continues their holdout into the regular season, especially Hendrickson, this defense is going to be a garbage heap. They have nobody else that can generate consistent pressure, their ability to stop the run diminished despite having Logan Wilson and Oren Burks, and their secondary is even worse. Cam Taylor-Britt is probably the only quality defensive back they have, but even he has struggled to stay consistent and mold into a top corner. Geno Stone is more or less the same and has proven that he is more of a ball-hawk than a lockdown defender. They tried to bring back Mike Hilton and Vonn Bell last season but to no avail. If the veterans on this defense are not living up to potential, what do you think is going to happen with the younger guys? Maybe replacing defensive coordinator Lou Anarumo with Al Golden could help, but this is not Notre Dame. I get that Golden was a linebackers coach for the Bengals not too long ago, yet this is the first time that he is calling the plays in the NFL. He is not going to have a lot of depth to work with, so if Cincinnati’s offense makes the tiniest mistake on the field, then the momentum is going to swing around in the opposite direction. 


As long as that offense is fully healthy, particularly Joe Burrow, then the Bengals will always be in the mix of playoff contention. The problem is that the longer the team stumbles, the more divided the locker room becomes. There does come a time where you have to question if Zac Taylor should be the head coach after this season. When you repeat the same things over and over to expect a different result, that is not having a stable winning culture. That is insanity. That is when you lose your voice in the locker room and the team stops caring. Ownership does not get a pass either because this organization has finally risen to incredible heights, yet their self-inflicted incompetence is the reason why several players are holding out and why they have not won a championship in franchise history. To both parties involved, I have one thing to say: get your acts together. Bring back the respectability that this team once had or else Trey Hendrickson is not the only person you are going to lose forever.