There is good news and bad news for the Cleveland Browns. The good news is that Myles Garrett no longer wants to be traded and signed a $160 million extension for four years. Ok, that might be too steep, but the face of your franchise is back. The bad? They do not have a surefire starter at quarterback. Deshaun Watson just suffered two torn Achilles injuries and the backups behind him have too many question marks. Kenny Pickett is merely a backup, Joe Flacco is a fossil, and both Dillon Gabriel and Shadeur Sanders are unproven rookies. At least one of them is going to get cut before Week 1 and nobody even knows who is going to be the starter. It does not help that this offense does not have the best supporting cast. You could say that they still have Kevin Stefanski as their head coach, but he gave up play-calling duties to Ken Dorsey last year, then took it back for the start of the 2025 season. I will give Tommy Rees a chance since he is a promising young coordinator, but college ball is nowhere near the same as the NFL, so he has a big chip on his shoulder.


Not only did the Browns draft two quarterbacks, but they also selected two running backs as well! The eventual replacement for recently departed Nick Chubb is either going to be Quinshon Judkins or Dylan Sampson. Heck, maybe Jerome Ford finally hits his peak and surprises us with a strong campaign. Either way, if they cannot run the ball, then passing it is going to be a hell of a lot harder. Jerry Jeudy finally had an outstanding season in 2024 and showed his first round pedigree, but I am hoping that this is not just a one year wonder. If David Njoku is the only reliable weapon, that is an issue. We do not know what to expect from Diontae Johnson or Cedric Tillman, so unless one of these quarterbacks jumps into the radar out of nowhere, then I do not expect this group to thrive consistently. Lastly, let’s get to the state of the offensive line, which allowed the second most sacks in the NFL last year. The only real changes they made were letting Jedrick Wills go in free agency and signing Teven Jenkins, so I do not have a whole lot of confidence in this group heading into the 2025 season, especially with the flux at the quarterback position. 


Myles Garrett might be back but that will not matter if that defense does not return to its form a couple years ago. Last year, they went from allowing the fewest total yards in the league to the fourteenth most. It also allowed the sixth most points and totaled the third fewest takeaways, which was very surprising considering that there were next to no changes on that unit from the previous year. That is why Cleveland made the gamble to trade out of the second overall pick and move a few spots down to select defensive tackle Mason Graham out of Michigan. They might have passed up drafting Travis Hunter, but the Browns did get a first round pick out of the deal, so it is not the worst thing in the world. Unfortunately, that was the only notable move they made on the defensive line. The Browns have a few decent rotational guys, but nobody else that can really move the needle, so that means Graham is going to be expected to have an immediate impact. What amplifies the pressure even more is that their stud linebacker Jeremiah Owusu-Koromoah is expected to miss the entire 2025 season to a neck injury, which will thrust Jerome Baker, Jordan Hicks and Devin Bush as the starting linebackers. Maybe it will not be an issue if second round pick Carson Schwesinger peaks earlier than expected. I cannot let the secondary off the hook either, because although Denzel Ward and Grant Delpit are still playing at an elite level, there are not a lot of guys stepping up. Greg Newsome and Martin Emerson have been disappointing support options at corner, Rayshawn Jenkins is an okay safety but has never been a game changer, and Nik Needham has not been good in almost five years. Defensive coordinator Jim Schwartz has his work cut out for him and if he cannot get this group playing at a high level, he might be the next to walk out the door.


I want to have all of the faith in the world in Kevin Stefanski and Andrew Berry, but ever since they made that all-in push for Deshaun Watson, this team has been on a downward spiral. I bet they are missing Baker Mayfield now because even though his last season there was forgettable, he is a million times better than whatever the Browns have at the quarterback position. They better know what they are doing with this roster, or else Jimmy Haslam is more than likely going to blow it up and fire both of them at the end of the year. He has done it before and he will not be afraid to do it again.