From a Gray Cook–style Functional Movement Screen (FMS) lens, the issue isn’t just that people “aren’t knowledgeable,” it’s that youth coaching is often treated as something you earn by passion instead of something you build through competency.
Cook’s general philosophy would frame it like this: most well-meaning youth coaches are trying to coach sport skills (how to throw, run plays, win games) before they understand movement quality (how the body actually produces and tolerates force). That gap is where problems show up.
From an FMS-informed view, the motivation is usually solid:
They love the sport and want to give back
Their kid is involved
They remember their own experience (good or bad)
They believe “effort and enthusiasm” are enough
Cook wouldn’t dismiss that—he actually respects the intent. The issue is the assumption that intent equals competence.
In FMS terms, many youth coaches skip the “screening layer” entirely:
They coach output (faster, stronger, win)
Without understanding input quality (mobility, stability, asymmetry, compensation)
So you get patterns like:
Training speed without control of landing mechanics
Repeated throwing without shoulder/scapular capacity
Early specialization without movement variety
Conditioning used as punishment instead of assessment
Cook’s core argument would be: you can’t reliably improve performance if you don’t first recognize dysfunctional movement patterns.
A big Cook-style insight is that many coaches rely on:
“That’s how I did it”
“That worked for my team”
“We just ran harder and got better”
But FMS philosophy pushes back: what worked for a resilient outlier athlete doesn’t generalize to developing youth bodies with unknown asymmetries.
It’s not just poor performance—it’s:
Accumulating dysfunction during development
Overuse injuries disguised as “toughness issues”
Kids learning compensation patterns as “normal sport technique”
Not fewer coaches—but better-informed ones:
Basic movement literacy (squat, lunge, hinge, push, pull, rotate, gait)
Understanding asymmetry vs. symmetry
Knowing when to regress instead of progress
Using movement as the foundation, not conditioning alone
In Cook’s framing, the goal isn’t to turn youth coaches into clinicians—it’s to stop treating movement as something assumed rather than assessed.
You’ve articulated the Cook/FMS worldview with real precision — and you’re circling the exact tension he’s been trying to expose for two decades: youth coaching is treated as a moral credential (“I care, therefore I’m qualified”) instead of a movement‑competency role (“I understand how bodies develop, therefore I’m safe”).
Let me push your framing one layer deeper — the layer Cook usually implies but rarely says outright — so you can use it in your educational materials, coach development, or movement‑literacy advocacy.
From an FMS lens, this is the root of everything you described.
Most youth coaches — even the good-hearted ones — assume:
Kids “just know how to run”
Throwing is “just a skill you learn by doing”
Strength “just comes from effort”
Injuries “just happen”
Cook’s philosophy flips that:
Movement is a trainable, screenable, regressable skill — not a default setting.
Once you accept that, everything else changes.
You nailed the surface motivations. Cook would add two psychological drivers:
Adults coach because they want to pass down the identity the sport gave them.
But identity ≠ competency.
If they endured bad training, they assume kids today can too.
FMS calls this survivorship bias disguised as tradition.
You already listed the big ones. Here’s the Cook-style framing underneath:
Sprinting without landing control
Jumping without deceleration
Throwing without scapular rhythm
Cutting without frontal-plane stability
Cook’s line:
“Don’t load what you can’t pattern.”
More reps, more laps, more throws — without knowing whether the pattern is even safe.
Conditioning becomes a test of character instead of a test of movement integrity.
“What worked for me must work for them.”
“If the team won, the training must have been good.”
Using the most resilient kid as the model for the least prepared kid.
Cook’s counterpoint:
“You can’t coach to the outlier. You coach to the baseline.”
Kids grow up believing their compensations are their sport technique.
A kid with a mobility asymmetry gets told they’re “soft.”
A strong 12-year-old with poor patterns becomes a broken 17-year-old.
This is the part Cook thinks is preventable.
Not medical knowledge. Not clinical screening. Just:
Squat
Hinge
Lunge
Push
Pull
Rotate
Gait
Mobility vs. stability
Symmetry vs. asymmetry
Pattern quality vs. pattern quantity
Regression isn’t punishment — it’s precision.
Sport skills sit on top of movement skills, not beside them.
If I compress everything you wrote into a single Cook-aligned statement:
Youth coaching fails not because coaches don’t care, but because the system treats caring as a substitute for movement competency — and kids pay the price in patterns, not just performance.