By Robert Mcg. Thomas Jr.
Nov. 15, 1986
About the Archive
This is a digitized version of an article from The Times’s print archive, before the start of online publication in 1996. To preserve these articles as they originally appeared, The Times does not alter, edit or update them.
t has become a fixture at college sports events and some high school games. Forming a human pyramid, cheerleaders stand in ranks on each other's shoulders with one, generally a nimble young woman, perched triumphantly at the top. Then she dismounts in what appears to the gasping crowd as a death-defying leap to the arms of catchers waiting below.
For all its popularity, it is becoming increasingly clear that the stunt can be as dangerous as it seems, and the recent death of a 21-year-old football cheerleader who suffered fatal head injuries while practicing a leap from a pyramid at North Dakota State University has made the inherent danger clearer still.
That and another recent accident, in which a 22-year-old University of Kentucky cheerleader was paralyzed from the neck down after flipping off a small trampoline, have focused new attention on cheerleading, a largely unregulated activity that experts say has become as demanding and dangerous as any sport.
Although the experts could provide no statistics on fatalities and serious injuries, they agreed that cheerleading has become far more dangerous in recent years as cheering squads have adopted more perilous routines. Pyramid Especially Dangerous
The pyramid, a formation that has figured in previous deaths and a number of serious injuries in both high school and college, is considered an especially dangerous stunt.
The North Dakota State cheerleader, Janis Thompson, suffered multiple skull fractures and irreparable brain damage Oct. 29 when her head slammed against the floor as she was attempting a leaping dismount from the top of a three-tier pyramid to the arms of a pair of waiting catchers.
Randy Neil, the president of the International Cheerleading Federation, one of three national organizations that publish safety guidelines and sponsor high school and college instruction clinics but which have no regulatory authority, ticked off several recent incidents in which cheerleaders had been paralyzed or suffered other serious injuries in pyramid accidents.
Like other experts, Mr. Neil suggests that cheerleading is still regarded by educators as the social activity it once was rather than the skilled sport it has become. Once a simple showcase for the prettiest and most popular female students and agile male students, cheerleading has come far since the days when, aside from waving one's arms while grasping a pompon, the most strenuous activity was standing on one foot while kicking the other in the air. No Safety Regulations
Spurred by the annual clinics that teach new and more demanding formations and by the sight of college squads performing at televised games, cheerleaders during the last decade have increasingly adopted tumbling and other routines that often combine the skill of gymnastics with the daring of a high-wire act, but without benefit of the safety regulations, skilled coaching and close supervision associated with organized team sports.
For despite all the recent athletic developments, cheerleaders remain the stepchildren of organized athletics both at the college level, where the National Collegiate Athletic Association and individual athletic conferences disclaim jurisdiction because cheerleading is not a competitive sport, and at the high school level, where state athletic associations have been similarly reluctant to accept authority.
Instead, cheerleading is generally classified as a student activity, such as playing in the band. While many cheerleading ''coaches'' are themselves skilled former cheerleaders who take great pains to stress safety, there are no rules and regulations. Official Is 'Appalled'
Susan True, a former college gymnastics coach who informally follows cheerleading as an official of the National Federation of State High School Associations, said that during her coaching days she had been ''appalled'' to see cheerleaders come into the gymnastics room and ''do things the gymnasts would never try without far more safety precautions.'' Mrs. True said she was still dismayed by cheerleaders' widespread disdain for safety measures during performances on hardwood basketball floors.
''You rarely see mats,'' she said. Although a grass football field offers a softer landing than a basketball floor, cheerleading officials note that many football cheerleaders perform on the stadium track, which can be as hard as a basketball court.
Despite the lack of formal regulation, there have been sporadic moves, generally after well-publicized accidents, to curb some dangerous practices. For example, the once-popular mini-trampolines have been abandoned at many colleges and high schools. A handful of states, including Michigan, have banned pyramids for high schools, while others have limited them to no more than two bodies high. Some Stunts Banned
In addition, the N.C.A.A. and some college leagues, such as the Southeastern Conference, have banned pyramids and trampolines at their basketball tournaments but have made no effort to expand the ban to regular-season games or to football.
Sometimes it takes more than a serious accident to spur reform. When Michelle Munn, a Syracuse University basketball cheerleader, suffered a serious head injury during a pyramid accident at a game at Georgetown University in January 1982, neither Syracuse nor the Big East Conference took immediate action. It was not until a year and a half later, when Miss Munn, who had recovered in time to rejoin the squad later that season, filed a lawsuit against Syracuse (it was later dropped) that the conference decided to limit pyramids to no more than two tiers.
Officials of the cheerleading organizations, citing various surveys, insist that cheerleading, with all its sprained ankles and dislocated shoulders, is safer than women's basketball and volleyball and far safer than football. The experts concede, however, that the persistence of especially serious injuries suggests the need for new safety techniques and enforcement.
Mr. Neil, the International Cheerleading Federation official, likens the developing sport to an earlier stage of women's gymnastics, when flips and other new acrobatic moves produced a number of balance beam injuries until padding was added to the beam. Paralyzed by Injury
Even a 12-inch-thick padded mat, however, was not enough to protect Dale Baldwin, a 22-year-old University of Kentucky cheerleader who suffered a broken neck Nov. 4 when he flipped off a mini-trampoline at the annual intrasquad basketball scrimmage before 19,000 fans at Freedom Hall in Louisville. After surgery to fuse his fourth and fifth vertebrae, his doctors said that except for some slight movement in his arms he would probably be paralyzed from the neck down for life.
Like many cheerleaders who have been injured using the unpredictable mini-trampolines, Mr. Baldwin was not a novice. Indeed, he was widely regarded as one of the most skilled cheerleaders in the country, one who had served as an instructor. Because of his special skills he, along with two other members of this year's squad, had been the first Kentucky cheerleaders allowed to use the mini-trampoline since 1978, when the school banned it. Following his accident, the school reimposed the ban and prohibited three-tier pyramids.
Although some serious pyramid injuries, such as Miss Munn's at Syracuse, have occurred in actual performances, experts say the pyramid is inherently safe when executed by well-trained and well-rehearsed cheerleaders who know the routine's essentially simple moves.
The pyramid is most dangerous, they say, when it is first being learned. For that reason, the cheerleading organizations recommend that pyrmaid dismounts be perfected through practice at ground level before being attempted in the air, and that when they are tried on a stack at least two spotters catch any falling bodies. And there should be protective mats on the floor.
Miss Thompson and her fellow North Dakota State cheerleaders followed most of the precautions before the fatal accident. Miss Thompson, a former high school and college track star who held the North Dakota State record in the 100 and 400 meters, had been a cheerleader since her freshman year in high school, had served as an instructor for high school cheerleaders at clinics run by the National Cheerleaders Association and had been named by the group as a second team all-America selection.
The routine the cheerleaders were practicing was one they had learned at a cheerleaders association clinic over the summer, and in accordance with standard safety recommendations, Miss Thompson had first practiced her dismount at ground level. Inexperienced Spotters
At the time of the accident, university officials say, 16 spotters, including members of the varsity basketball team had been stationed around the pyramid. It was an apparent extra precaution that may actually have contributed to the accident in part because the basketball players had no training as spotters and in part because there were so many of them they may have gotten in each other's way when Miss Thompson unexpectedly veered to the side when she began her dismount.
''Basketball players have no business serving as spotters,'' said Linda Bell, the Syracuse cheerleading coach, who said she devoted the first half hour of her practices to correct spotting techniques such as the need for preplanned coordinated action by the spotters and the need to grab a falling cheerleader around the chest - never the legs - to assure proper leverage in breaking a fall.
According to North Dakota State officials, some of the 16 spotters did manage to get their hands on Miss Thompson as she fell, but they caught only her legs and lower torso, allowing the back of her unprotected head to slam into the floor.
In addition to the use of inexperienced spotters, who may have contributed to the force of the impact by providing an unintended fulcrum as they grabbed Miss Thompson's hips, there was a crucial departure from safety procedures: No padded mats had been placed on the field house floor.
Later, in the course of an interview, one college official initially descscribed the field house floor as being made of ''soft rubber'' and later as identical to the basketball floor in a different building. Accident to Be Discussed
Whether Miss Thompson's death leads to new pressures for reform remains to be seen. Officials at North Dakota State say the pyramid routine will no longer be used by its cheerleaders, and officials of the North Central Conference, of which the school is a member, said that the fatal accident might be discussed at the group's next meeting but that no specific proposals have been made.
Miss Thompson, who never regained consciousness, was pronounced dead two days after the incident.
A day after her death, the North Dakota State football team, wearing memorial helmet decals bearing Miss Thompson's initials, played a home game against Nebraska-Omaha. Except for a brief pre-game ceremony in which Miss Thompson's fellow cheerleaders stood at attention in street clothes while the game was dedicated to her memory, the cheerleaders did not perform at the game.
University officials said that a trophy Miss Thompson was to have received at the game for her all-America selection would be given to her parents.
Below is a complete, modern system you can hand to a coach, school, or AD. It blends today’s cheer safety standards with movement-quality thinking inspired by Gray Cook and Lee Burton.
Qualified coach present (trained in stunt progressions + emergency response)
Certified spotters only (no athletes from other sports “helping”)
Defined roles: flyer, bases, back spot, front spot (if used)
Matting appropriate for stunt height
Clear verbal count system (“5–6–7–8”, “UP”, “DOWN”, “BAIL”)
Emergency plan rehearsed (who calls 911, who stabilizes, who clears space)
Spotters must:
Track center of mass (torso), not limbs
Keep eyes on flyer at all times
Use preplanned hand targets (upper back/ribs/hips)
Never:
Grab only legs/ankles
Freelance or “react late”
Crowd the stunt without a role
Floor → low stunt → half height → full extension → dismounts
Master STATIC control before DYNAMIC movement
No pyramids until:
Single-leg balance is controlled at ground level
Flyers demonstrate safe bail mechanics
Limit high-risk reps per session
Stop on:
technique breakdown
late reactions
mental hesitation
Rotate groups to avoid fatigue-based errors
Every stunt has:
1 caller (usually back spot)
1 decision voice for aborts
Mandatory calls:
“SET” (ready)
“UP”
“HOLD”
“DOWN”
“BAIL”
No extra bodies near stunt
No music during learning phases
No simultaneous new skills across groups
👉 “Safety Isn’t Numbers — It’s Coordination.”
3-tier pyramid
Multiple spotters (too many)
Unclear roles
🧠 Lesson:
More people ≠ more safety
Flyer drifts off-line
Spotters react independently
No unified catch plan
🧠 Lesson:
Uncoordinated reaction = delayed protection
Contact made at legs/lower body only
Upper body/head not controlled
🧠 Lesson:
If the torso isn’t controlled, the head isn’t protected
Head becomes uncontrolled end segment
Ground contact occurs
🧠 Lesson:
Head safety depends on torso control + timing
✔ Trained spotters only
✔ Assigned zones (not crowding)
✔ Chest/torso-first catch strategy
✔ Pre-timed coordination
👉 “Don’t react to falls. PREPARE the catch.”
This is where it gets powerful—movement quality predicts stunt safety.
In a pyramid dismount, force should transfer:
Feet → hips → trunk → controlled descent
Breaks happen when:
Ankles collapse (pronation/instability)
Hips lack control
Trunk can’t stabilize
➡️ Result: off-line drift + unpredictable fall path
10 sec hold
No foot wobble
❌ Fail → high drift risk
Arms overhead, squat deep
❌ Forward lean = poor trunk control
❌ Knee collapse = poor landing control
Rotate without trunk shifting
❌ Loss of control = unstable air positions
Small hop → controlled catch by bases
❌ Late hands = timing failure risk
Risk = Height × Complexity × Movement Dysfunction × Fatigue
Lower ANY variable → safer stunt
Chin tucked (neutral, not extended)
Arms ready to absorb and connect
Hips under torso (not piked or arched)
Land into people, not space
Eyes: track chest/sternum
Hands: ribs/upper torso first
Elbows: soft and absorbing
Feet: staggered, ready to move
👉 “You can’t stabilize what you didn’t align.”
If alignment breaks:
movement becomes reactive
reaction becomes chaotic
chaos leads to injury
This isn’t just about cheer—it’s a system failure vs system design issue.
Too many people ≠ safety
Movement quality = predictability
Predictability = protection