Gray Cook and Lee Burton’s FMS philosophy provides a strong framework for arguing that K–12 physical education should be built around a movement curriculum first, with sports specialization coming later. The important distinction is not “sports are bad.” It is what comes first in a child’s physical education.
Teach the child how to move before asking the child to specialize in how to play a sport.
Cook and Burton describe a progression from fundamental movement competency → physical capacity → sport-specific skill. In their model, sport-specific skill belongs at the top of the pyramid, not at its foundation.
Cook has specifically questioned what the ultimate goal of physical education should be. His argument is that PE should produce something analogous to other academic subjects: a level of functional independence and competence that the student can carry into life.
That changes the question from:
“What sport are we teaching?”
to:
“What movement abilities should every child possess?”
That is a very different educational philosophy.
A child may never play:
football
basketball
baseball
volleyball
hockey
tennis
soccer
But every child will need to walk, run, jump, land, balance, squat, get up and down from the floor, climb, carry, push, pull, rotate and control their body.
Those are human skills rather than sport skills.
This is probably the most important Cook/Lee Burton concept for your K–12 idea.
Their model can be simplified as:
MOVEMENT COMPETENCY
↓
MOVEMENT CAPACITY
↓
SPORT-SPECIFIC SKILL
FMS describes fundamental movement competency as the foundation. Capacity comes next. Sport-specific skill is the specialization at the top.
So a PE curriculum could look like:
K–2
→ explore movement
3–5
→ develop fundamental patterns
6–8
→ develop movement capacity and adaptability
9–12
→ develop strength, speed, endurance, power and more complex movement
AND THEN
→ allow individual students to specialize in sports if they choose.
That is very different from making PE essentially a succession of sports units.
This is an important educational distinction.
Imagine a PE class that spends several weeks on basketball.
The student who already has:
coordination
balance
good acceleration
good deceleration
throwing ability
spatial awareness
previous basketball experience
may immediately succeed.
Another student may struggle.
But the second child may not have a basketball problem.
They may have an underlying movement-development problem.
For example:
difficulty jumping
could involve:
poor balance
limited ankle mobility
poor landing mechanics
poor coordination
inability to control the trunk
A sport curriculum can easily say:
“You need to get better at jumping for basketball.”
A movement curriculum asks:
“Why is jumping difficult in the first place?”
That is much closer to the FMS philosophy.
FMS explicitly uses the term movement literacy.
Gray Cook describes it as the ability to essentially “read and write movement patterns”—to recognize movement and reproduce it.
Think about the analogy:
Students learn:
letters → words → sentences → literature
Students learn:
numbers → operations → concepts → advanced mathematics
A movement-centered model would be:
fundamental movements → movement combinations → physical capacities → sport/recreation skills
You wouldn't design elementary English around having children memorize Shakespeare before they can read.
Likewise, the FMS philosophy suggests that PE shouldn't make sport specialization the foundation before children develop the physical vocabulary needed to move.
This is where play and exploration become important.
A movement curriculum can expose children to:
crawling
climbing
rolling
getting up and down
balancing
walking
running
hopping
skipping
jumping
landing
throwing
catching
carrying
pushing
pulling
rotating
changing direction
accelerating
decelerating
These aren't merely exercises.
They are movement experiences.
Cook's FMS material emphasizes that natural movement development involves progressing through mobility, motor control, stabilization, locomotion and manipulation.
This is one of the biggest philosophical differences.
A sports-centered PE program can unintentionally reward the children who already possess sport skills.
A movement-centered PE program starts with the premise:
Every child is a mover.
The goal isn't to identify the best athletes.
The goal is to help every child develop a physical foundation.
That's particularly consistent with Cook's discussion of fundamental capacities: he notes that these qualities are not inherently sport-specific and can be evaluated from a young age.
This doesn't mean eliminating sports from PE.
Quite the opposite.
Sports become more meaningful after the movement foundation is established.
Think of it like a tree:
ROOTS
Movement literacy
↓
TRUNK
Mobility + stability + coordination + balance + locomotion + object control
↓
BRANCHES
Running
Jumping
Throwing
Catching
Climbing
Swimming
Dancing
etc.
↓
FRUIT
Soccer
Basketball
Tennis
Track
Baseball
Volleyball
Hockey
etc.
The sport is the expression of the movement foundation.
Burton's FMS work repeatedly emphasizes evaluating fundamental movement before progressing toward performance.
The FMS roadmap describes the purpose of evaluating basic physical literacy before moving toward more demanding training or sport.
And the FMS Motor Control Screen, developed by Lee Burton, specifically looks at whether someone possesses a minimum level of bodyweight motor control necessary for adaptability in human performance.
That's an important concept for K–12:
Don't ask a child to perform increasingly complicated physical tasks without first developing the underlying ability to control their body.
This is another reason a K–12 movement curriculum makes sense.
Children aren't simply miniature adults.
Their bodies change dramatically through:
childhood → preadolescence → growth spurt → adolescence
FMS specifically notes the importance of monitoring developmental changes in adolescents and preparing them for higher-level exercise and athletics.
A movement curriculum can therefore be developmentally continuous rather than simply repeating sports every year.
For example:
Explore
Crawl • roll • balance • hop • run • climb
Organize
Squat • hinge • jump • land • throw • catch • rotate
Adapt
Acceleration • deceleration • change of direction • landing • coordination • strength
Develop
Strength • power • speed • endurance • agility • complex movement
Specialize if desired
Track • tennis • soccer • basketball • hockey • etc.
That is a developmental movement curriculum rather than a collection of sports units.
Perhaps the most powerful way to express Cook and Burton's philosophy is:
It should produce physically literate human beings.
Some of those people will become:
runners
tennis players
basketball players
hockey players
soccer players
weightlifters
dancers
But many won't.
They might become:
teachers
mechanics
nurses
farmers
engineers
parents
hikers
gardeners
grandparents
They still have a body.
And they will still need movement competency.
That's why Cook's fundamental-capacity framework emphasizes qualities that aren't tied to one particular sport.
I would frame it this way:
K–5: MOVEMENT LITERACY
Learn the vocabulary of human movement.
6–8: MOVEMENT DEVELOPMENT
Build coordination, balance, mobility, stability, strength, speed and adaptability.
9–12: MOVEMENT CAPACITY
Develop physical qualities and learn how to train intelligently.
SPORTS:
Use sports as one of many ways to apply and specialize the movement foundation.
That is very close to the hierarchy FMS presents: competency → capacity → specialization.
And importantly, FMS itself has highlighted a school program that redesigned PE around functional movement and physical literacy, with the stated goal of helping pupils access sports while developing their own movement skills.
A child shouldn't have to become an athlete to receive a physical education.
The child should first become physically literate—and then have the opportunity to become an athlete, if they choose.
That is the strongest Cook/Burton/FMS-based case for making movement curriculum the foundation of K–12 PE rather than sports curriculum.