From a Gray Cook / Functional Movement Systems (FMS) perspective, the issue is not that marathon running is inherently “bad.” The concern is that high volumes of repetitive running can expose movement limitations that an athlete has never addressed.
Running is a highly repetitive skill. A marathon involves roughly tens of thousands of running cycles. If the body repeatedly moves through the same pattern while lacking adequate mobility, stability, or motor control, the same compensation can be repeated thousands of times.
A simplified FMS chain is:
Foot → Ankle → Knee → Hip → Pelvis → Trunk → Shoulder
If one part of that chain doesn't move or stabilize well, another part may compensate.
For example:
Limited ankle mobility
↓
Foot changes how it accepts the ground
↓
Knee/hip compensate
↓
Pelvis and trunk alter their movement
↓
Thousands of repetitions
↓
Greater orthopedic stress
Marathon characteristic
Potential movement problem
Very high repetition
Small compensations are repeated thousands of times
Long duration
Fatigue can reduce movement quality
Mostly one movement pattern
Less exposure to other movement patterns
Large training volume
Less opportunity for recovery
Running-specific training
Mobility/stability deficiencies may go unnoticed
Increasing mileage
A previously tolerated limitation may become symptomatic
The important FMS distinction is:
Capacity has to match demand.
Someone may be able to run 5 miles without a problem while having a movement limitation that becomes apparent at mile 18 or 22.
Cook's approach is more movement-first:
Can the athlete perform fundamental movements well?
Before assuming that a painful knee, hip, Achilles tendon, or foot needs a particular isolated exercise, examine the larger movement pattern.
That is why the FMS philosophy emphasizes fundamental patterns such as:
squat
hurdle step
inline lunge
shoulder mobility
active straight-leg raise
trunk stability
rotary stability
The screen isn't intended to diagnose an orthopedic injury. It is a way of looking for movement limitations and asymmetries that may deserve further investigation.
A marathoner can have tremendous cardiovascular fitness while having relatively poor movement capacity.
That's an important distinction:
Cardiovascular fitness ≠ movement fitness
Someone can have the aerobic engine to run 26.2 miles while the foot, ankle, hip, pelvis, or trunk doesn't have the movement capacity to tolerate the accumulated workload.
From an FMS perspective, the goal isn't necessarily:
“Stop running.”
It's closer to:
“Don't let running be the only movement your body knows.”
That means maintaining a broad movement vocabulary—squat, lunge, crawl, hinge, rotate, step, balance, jump/hop, and other fundamental movements—while progressively building running volume.
And this connects directly to the youth-athlete idea you've been developing: movement literacy should be established before enormous volumes of sport-specific repetition are accumulated. A young runner who learns many movement patterns before specializing heavily in distance running has a different foundation than someone whose primary movement experience becomes running.