From a Gray Cook / FMS perspective, the idea isn’t that physics is useless—it’s that traditional college physics does not meaningfully prepare you to understand or coach human movement.
Here’s how Cook and the FMS community frame it:
Intro physics courses focus on:
Rigid bodies
Ideal levers
Predictable forces
Closed systems
Humans are:
Adaptive, self-organizing systems
Influenced by pain, fear, fatigue, perception, and history
Constantly changing motor strategies
➡️ You can calculate torque all day and still miss why someone can’t squat.
Most movement dysfunctions are:
Mobility restrictions
Stability deficits
Asymmetries
Poor motor control
Not:
Insufficient force production
Incorrect equations
Mechanical ignorance
➡️ You don’t fix a valgus knee with a formula—you fix it with better movement options.
Physics courses do not teach:
Motor learning
Reflexive stability
Proprioception
Sensory-motor integration
Yet movement is driven by the nervous system, not physics equations.
“The brain is the most important piece of equipment in the gym.” — Gray Cook
Physics assumes:
Repeatability
Consistency
Predictability
Human movement depends on:
Load history
Injury history
Fatigue
Environment
Emotional state
➡️ Same athlete, same exercise, different day = different movement.
Gray Cook often points out:
Great coaches existed long before biomechanics labs
Indigenous cultures developed efficient movement without equations
Observation, pattern recognition, and feedback matter more than math
Instead of physics-heavy paths, Cook emphasizes:
Anatomy (especially joints and fascial connections)
Developmental movement (crawl, roll, carry)
Motor learning principles
Screening and pattern recognition
Coaching cues and regressions/progressions
Understanding pain vs. dysfunction
Physics explains movement.
It does not teach you how to restore it, coach it, or protect it.
Physics may describe what happened.
FMS cares about why it happened and how to fix it safely.
Here’s a simple, Gray Cook / FMS–style contrast that coaches, parents, and students can immediately grasp.
Biomechanics
Motor Control
Studies how the body moves
Studies how the body learns to move
Focuses on forces, angles, levers
Focuses on timing, coordination, and control
Asks: “Is the movement efficient?”
Asks: “Is the movement safe and repeatable?”
Often looks at ideal movement
Looks at available movement
Works best in labs and slow analysis
Works best in real life and coaching
Describes motion
Organizes motion
Answers what happened
Answers why it happened
Biomechanics: “This is what the squat should look like.”
Motor control: “This is what your nervous system can actually manage right now.”
Biomechanics may say:
The angles are safe
The forces are acceptable
Motor control asks:
Can the athlete repeat it under fatigue?
Can they own the pattern without compensation?
➡️ Control precedes strength.
Biomechanics assumes:
Neutral joints
Predictable output
Motor control recognizes:
Pain, fear, or past injury instantly alter patterns
➡️ The body chooses protection over efficiency every time.
Biomechanics may measure:
Left vs right force differences
Motor control asks:
Does the brain trust both sides equally?
Is one side guarding or avoiding load?
➡️ Fixing the pattern often fixes the numbers.
Biomechanics: “Knees track, spine neutral.”
Motor control: “Can you squat slowly, pause, breathe, and come back up without shifting?”
Biomechanics: “Stride length and ground reaction forces.”
Motor control: “Can you maintain rhythm when tired or stressed?”
Biomechanics: “Reduce joint stress.”
Motor control: “Improve movement options so the body doesn’t panic.”
Biomechanics describes the movement.
Motor control determines whether you can own it.
Or the classic Cook logic:
Don’t add load to a pattern the brain doesn’t trust.
From a Gray Cook / FMS perspective, colleges shouldn’t remove rigor—they should replace physics with a course that actually prepares students to understand and manage human movement.
Below is what Gray Cook and the FMS philosophy would argue belongs in place of traditional physics for Exercise Science and Physical Therapy majors.
(or “Applied Human Movement Science”)
Physics asks:
➡️ “What forces act on a body?”
FMS asks:
➡️ “Why does this person move this way, and how do we improve it safely?”
Only the second question prepares:
Coaches
PTs
Strength professionals
PE teachers
Students learn:
Joints don’t work alone
Mobility, stability, and control interact
Compensation patterns are predictable
Key ideas:
Regional interdependence
Joint-by-joint approach
Cause vs. symptom
This replaces equations with:
How the nervous system selects movement
Reflexive vs voluntary stability
Feedback vs feedforward control
Skill acquisition under fatigue
Why it matters:
Movement quality changes before strength changes.
Students study:
Rolling
Crawling
Squatting
Gait development
Why:
You can’t understand adult dysfunction without understanding childhood movement.
Instead of solving problems on paper:
Observe real humans moving
Identify asymmetries and limitations
Distinguish pain from dysfunction
Decide regress vs progress
Tools:
FMS
SFMA concepts
Basic movement screens (no diagnosis)
Physics ignores this completely.
Students learn:
Diaphragm as a postural muscle
Breathing’s role in stability
Relationship between respiration, posture, and movement
Rather than idealized forces:
How fatigue changes motor strategy
Why technique breaks down
Stress, sleep, and environment effects
Instead of memorizing formulas, graduates could:
Look at a movement and see the problem
Choose appropriate regressions and progressions
Know when to train, correct, or refer
Communicate effectively with PTs, coaches, and physicians
Protect athletes and patients from avoidable injury
Human Movement Systems
Motor Control & Movement Variability
Applied Movement Screening & Correctives
Neuro-Musculoskeletal Movement
Movement Quality & Injury Risk
Physics explains motion.
Movement science explains people.
If colleges want safer athletes and better clinicians, they must:
Teach how movement emerges
Not just how forces act