September 5, 2023
Β
Our field has thought about apes climbing up trees for a long timeβwhat was essentially absent from the literature was any focus on them getting out of a tree.
JEREMY DESILVA, PROFESSOR OF ANTHROPOLOGY
There was recently an article in the New York Times Magazine about running phenom Mary Cain that talked about how talented and dedicated she is to running and breaking records and how her coach Alberto Salazar is trying to carefully guide her to her full potential without injuring her.
If you've seen the times Mary Cain has run, you quickly realize that she has the potential to set not only every middle to long distance American record but maybe even challenge the world records. Alberto Salazar says she has...
βAs much talent as any young athlete Iβve ever seen in running in my life.β
But there is something about Mary that might hold her back from setting more records and could end her career prematurely...her posture.
The Runner's World article, when talking about the girls lined up at the starting line of the 2001 high school national championships 4x800 meter relay, said this:
With their long ponytails and soft bodies, racing numbers pinned to their hips, none of the girls looked like much β but Cain, a freshman, looked like less. She wore hot pink shorts and a black sports bra, and her shoulders slumped with the impatient awkwardness of being 15. "Slumped shoulders" is the key word, and while it might have started with the "impatient awkwardness" of being 15, Mary still has the same slumped shoulders today as a much more confident almost 19 year old. The article says when Alberto Salazar first started working with Mary he noticed her upper body: An obsessive about form, Salazar said that Cainβs lower-body mechanics were excellent, good enough to make her the best in the world, but that her upper body needed work. In particular, if she wanted to reach her potential, she needed to keep her left elbow closer to her body, swing it straight, front to back, instead of out and across her torso. He referred to the elbow as her βchicken wing.β
That "chicken wing", which Mary Cain has on both sides with the left more pronounced, is a result of the thoracic flexion and forward shoulders which do not allow proper front to back arm swing because the shoulder joint is out of position. Her coach can drill her over and over about swinging her arms straight forward and back, but it just won't happen until her upper body posture is improved.
The posture of having thoracic flexion, rounded shoulders, and forward head is very common among runners of all ages and talents and again was clearly shown in a recent Runner's World article titled "The Runners Body". Notice the very rounded forward shoulders, winged scapula, thoracic flexion, and forward head. All very detrimental to both good upper body running mechanics and efficeint breathing.Β
This runner has very fast PRs of 4:34 mile, 15:39 5k, 1:11:27 half marathon, and 2:29:54 marathon, but also forward shoulders and head that are slowing him down.
People often think that this body posture is prevalent in distance runners because they do not do any upper body strength training. While many runners do not spend as much time working on their upper body as they do their legs, many do lift weights including Mary Cain and her Oregon Project teammates as the Runner's World article states: The dominant philosophy now is that girls, like all other runners, should train to become very strong by lifting heavy weights.Β The reason why lifting weights has not corrected the poor posture is because weight lifting will almost always strengthen a persons' imbalances. Lifting weights tends to strengthen the already strong muscles and the weak muscles get even weaker. This can be seen with athletes of all sports and "sports specific" training will always lead to more imbalances by further strengthening the primary muscles used for the particular sport.
Lebron James's normal posture is one with his feet turned out, knees rotated outward, shoulders and head rounded forward, and he has hip and shoulder imbalances.
Michael Phelps has one of the worst postures in swimming: posterior pelvis, excessively flexed thoracic spine, collapsed chest, and his shoulders and head are rounded forward.
βTiger Woods has had strong hip and shoulder imbalances for years leading to his injuries. He is usually seen standing on one leg or the other, rarely squarely on both feet and hips.
Peyton Manning's dropped left shoulder causes his head and neck to shift to the right. That along with his rounded shoulders and forward head have lead to his neck issues.Β
Β
Throughout all sports and athletes we see some very common posture imbalances: rounded kyphotic thoracic spines, rounded shoulders, forward heads, turned out feet, and hip and shoulder asymmetries. Our modern lifestyles involve a lot of forward flexion (sitting, computer use, texting, video games, driving, watching TV) and very little extension and this is a recipe for thoracic kyphosis, rounded shoulders, and forward head posture. Everyone tends to favor one side of their body and without enough balanced motion to restore function to both sides of our bodies, we tend to get a dominate hip and shoulder. This will show up in one hip and shoulder being lower or more forward than the other.
Mary's postural imbalances: feet turned out - left more than right, right shoulder rotated forward, back of hands showing to the front.
Mary's postural imbalances: head forward, shoulders and upper back rounded forward.
Weight training and playing sports will only strengthen these tendencies and imbalances eventually leading to injury. The above athletes have had to deal with the following injuries:
Tiger Woods: knee, achilles tendon, lower back
Michael Phelps: back
Lebron James: lower back, knee, elbow
Felix Hernandez: back, elbow
Peyton Manning: knee, neck
All these athletes, including Mary Cain, can correct their postural imbalances with specific posture exercises that restore balance, function, and symmetry to their bodies. Improved posture will lead to more efficient movement, improved biomechanics, increased performance, and decreased chance of injury.
I do believe Mary Cain has the ability to break every American middle and long distance record and set a world record some day, but she has to stay injury free and rise to her potential, and that's all riding on her shoulders.
Β
Parents ask me at what age or grade should my child start running longer distances which you see in cross country workouts.
The answer is basically that you are asking the wrong question. The better question is: Should I have my child screened first to see what deficiencies she or he may have? The answer is yes.
Another common question I get asked is how may miles per week should I be running during the summer/winter and during the season for cross country?
Well, first of all, I would not recommend running year around. Participate in another sport if possible. The number of miles per week willΒ be determined based on your Functional Movement Screen results. The number of miles one person can handle per week can be quite different from another person. Injury prevention is critical.
All distance runners (cross country runners) need to be screened (Functional Movement Screen) at least once a year, preferably twice a year. As you grow and have more wear and tear on your body, the screen will show different results. The best time to be screened is during the spring/summer. You can be screened during the Great Plains Track Club season. Members cost is $10, which is 50% off. Screens should start once you become involved in organized sports where heavy loads of practice/training start to occur.
email for more information skubisiak@bis.midco.net
Other unintended factors can become involved over time, like overuse injuries (i.e. stress fractures), burnout, addiction to running, eating disorders.
Middle school is very early to be logging (running) miles. Focusing of "one movement pattern", in this case running, is not healthy for any body. So other movement patterns should be integrated into the cross country program. Yes, that means not just "going out for a run".
Sports specific training is an outdated approach! Other movement patterns should be integrated into all sports, whether it is running, basketball, hockey, football, etc. So this means integrating other movement patterns "during the season".
Keep in mind that winning a state championship as an individual or team, has nothing to do with being healthy. So the question is, "Do you value your health?"
Β
Why Iβm Not Surprised Alan Webb Split From Alberto Salazar
March 31, 2011
Alan Webb is a runner without a coach, and possibly a runner without a contract. Photo: PhotoRun.net
Mario Fraioli takes a deeper look at Alan Webbβs coaching commitment issues over the course of his competitive career.
Alan Webb has commitment issues.
Iβm not knocking the American record holder in the mile β just pointing out an obvious fact. Yesterdayβs news that Webb left Alberto Salazarβs Oregon Project shouldnβt come as such a big surprise.
Over the course of his now ten-year quasi-collegiate/mostly professional career, the 28-year old has been through three coaches, making an early exit from the University of Michigan in 2002 to return to his high school coach, Scott Raczko, in his native Virginia. Then, after another nearly seven years training under the man who helped him become the fastest high school milerβand eventually the fastest American milerβof all-time, Webb packed his bags and headed west to join Salazarβs Oregon Project in August of 2009.
βWith any change thereβs risk,β Webbβs agent, Ray Flynn, told USA Today at the time. βFor whatever reason, things werenβt working.β
Not working? In the worldβs most black and white sport, the numbers donβt lie. As a senior at South Lakes High School in Reston, Virginia, Webb became the first high schooler to break the hallowed 4:00-barrier indoors, running 3:59.86 in New York City in 2001. That spring, Webb shattered Jim Ryunβs longstanding mark in the outdoor mile, running 3:53.43 to take nearly two seconds off Ryunβs 36-year old clocking. His coach? Scott Raczko. Things were definitely working.
Upon graduation from South Lakes High School, Webb left Raczko and rightfully accepted a full scholarship to the University of Michigan, joining a loaded class ofΒ middle-distance runners led by longtime Wolverine headman Ron Warhurst. Initially, Webb thrived, winning the Big 10 cross country championship as a freshman and placing an impressive 11th at the NCAA meet. Everyone, including Webb himself, could agree that despite a new coach and a new training system that things were still working just fine.
βI felt so in control of my stride,β Webb told Chris Lear in the book Sub 4. βIβve never felt that much in control of my body, ever, even last year at the end of outdoor [track season].β
After suffering an untimely injury to his Achilles tendon during the indoor track season, however, Webb was thrown off his game. Hurt for the first time in his career and frustrated to no end, Webb was forced to redshirt the indoor track season, a decision he was reluctant to accept. After finally putting the injury behind him, he resumed training and returned outdoors to win a Big 10 title in the 1,500 meters and finish fourth in the same event at NCAAβs, seemingly salvaging a successful season for himself given the circumstances. In Webbβs head, however, it was a sign that things werenβt working well anymore. So what did he do? He got out of dodge.
Upon Webbβs return to Virginia, Raczko made it his mission to rebuild the greatest high school miler ever to lace up a pair of spikes. He did one hell of a job.
From 2005 to 2007, Webb went on a three-year tear, winning the 1,500 meters at the 2005 U.S. Championships in a display of dominance not seen since the days of Steve Scott. That same year Webb set personal bests at every distance from 1,500 to 5,000 meters, breaking an American Record at 2 miles in the process. In 2006 he ran 10,000 meters for the first time, winning the Payton Jordan Invite in 27:34.72, the fastest debut ever by an American at the distance. One year later he finally made his mark as a potential world-beater, breaking Scottβs 25-year-old American Record in the mile with a 3:46.91 clocking. His coach? Scott Raczko. Things seemed to be working better than ever before, and then all of a sudden everything went to shit.
Webb failed to make the Olympic team in 2008, and spent the rest of the summer plagued by injuries. One year later, the story was still the same. Within two years Webb went from being one of the best runners in the world to a burned-out, broken down shadow of his former self who was looking for an answer as to why all of a sudden things werenβt working for him. Was Scott Raczko to blame? No, just as I donβt believe Warhurst was to blame at Michigan. Webb seemed to think otherwise, however, and left his longtime coach for greener-looking pastures in Swooshtown, USA.
βIt gives me confidence to know that I have all the tools in place for me to push myself and we are just now starting that process,β Webb said shortly after joining Salazarβs Oregon Project, a group which included Galen Rupp, Dathan Ritznehein and Kara Goucher, amongst others.
The oft-injured but immensely talented Webb would have no excuses in Oregon: he had the talent, the coaching, the training partners, the facilities and the resources to return to his perch as the top middle-distance track runner in the U.S. Salazar, who was admittedly thrown for a loop when Webb approached him to be his coach, knew exactly what kind of athlete he had on his hands, even if he didnβt have another middle-distance runner in the group to call his own.
βI would have to say that even my athletes agree as a group β Galen Rupp and Dathan Ritzenhein β we all know he is the most talented in the whole group,β Salazar said last summer of Webb.
After recovering from Achilles surgery in early 2010, Salazar started Webb from scratch and helped him work his way back up the racing ranks. Last summer, after a less-than-impressive 1:52 800-meter opener in London in August, Webb got on a roll once again. Less than a month after that opening race, Webb ran 1:48:34 for 800 meters in Padova, Italy, and a few weeks later finished fifth amongst a loaded 1,500-meter field in Milan, running 3:36.21, his fastest time since 2008. Fast forward to Thanksgiving where Webb made a rare road racing appearance and won the Silicon Valley Turkey Trot in 13:36, beating Oregon Project teammate Galen Rupp by 3 seconds. Despite a small hiccup at the New Balance Indoor Grand Prix earlier this year in Boston β where Webb ran 4:00.70 to finish a disappointing seventh in the mile, nearly six seconds back of the winner, Russell Brown β he most recently finished third in a loaded 1,500-meter race in Australia, clocking 3:37.82, a tremendous track time for early March. In short, after years of injury and under-performance, the arrangement with Salazar seemed to be working pretty well.
Today, however, Webb is a runner without a coach, and maybe even a runner without a contract. Letsrun.com is reporting that Webbβs contract with Nike has run out and he is no longer on a professional payroll. None of this is confirmed, but it wouldnβt be a big surprise, either.
So who will be Webbβs next coach? Speculation is rampant, but no one knows for sure. One thing is certain, however: who is coaching Alan Webb isnβt the issue.
Liebermanβs central evolutionary insight is that exercise, as we think of it today (e.g., planned workouts, gym sessions, training for health), is not something natural that humans evolved to do. Instead:
Our ancestors moved a lot because their lives depended on it β walking to forage, running to hunt, climbing, digging, etc. There was no concept of βexercise for fitnessβ in hunter-gatherer societies. Activity was part of daily survival. WYPR+1
In evolutionary terms, we evolved efficient bodies that require movement to stay healthy β but we also evolved to avoid unnecessary exertion because conserving energy was vital when calories were scarce. Harvard Magazine
So paradoxically, Lieberman argues, exercise (voluntary, planned physical activity) is a modern cultural invention, not an evolutionary adaptation. Harvard Scholar
Lieberman distinguishes between:
Physical activity: walking, running, carrying, digging β necessary behaviors for survival
Exercise: voluntary activity done for health or fitness reasons
In the Stone Age, people didnβt βgo for a runβ for health. They moved because they had to. WYPR
Thatβs why hunter-gatherers today (used as models of ancestral lifestyles) spend far more time in moderateβvigorous activity than most Western adults β not because they βexerciseβ in a modern sense, but because their lifestyle depends on it. Harvard Gazette
Lieberman explains a kind of evolutionary tension:
We are good at moving β humans are among the best endurance walkers and runners among mammals. Features like efficient bipedal walking, sweating for cooling, and longβdistance running capacity were adaptations that helped hominins hunt and forage. Harvard Magazine
But we also evolved to conserve energy whenever possible β because calories were precious, and unnecessary movement was costly. This is why many people today naturally avoid exercise unless thereβs a compelling reason. WYPR
In everyday language: humans are built to move when needed, but not to work out for its own sake. Harvard Magazine
Lieberman frames the health crisis in evolutionary terms:
Modern environments of inactivity, processed food, and machine labor are mismatched with bodies shaped by millions of years of high physical activity. Harvard Magazine
Physical inactivity is linked to so-called βmismatch diseasesβ: heart disease, type 2 diabetes, obesity, osteoporosis, some cancers, depression, and cognitive decline. Harvard Gazette+1
Our bodies depend on mechanical stresses (movement) for biological maintenance β muscles, bones, circulation, metabolism, and even brain health β mechanisms that didnβt evolve to deal with long periods of sitting still. Harvard Magazine
So while exercise isnβt something we evolved to do, physical activity remains essential because our physiology evolved with it*. Harvard Magazine
Lieberman offers an explanation and practical advice:
It often feels unnatural because evolution didnβt make it intrinsically pleasurable β conserving energy was more essential than burning it. Harvard Gazette
He advises reframing exercise β donβt think of it as a chore, but make movement necessary, social, and pleasurable (e.g., group activities, dance, play, outdoor pursuits). Harvard Gazette
He also suggests not obsessing over time or intensity, and focusing more on consistent, sustainable movement patterns than on performance or guilt. Harvard Gazette
In his view, making movement a normal, social part of life aligns more with how humans moved in the past β which may be the key to making it stick now. Harvard Gazette
Exercised: Why Something We Never Evolved to Do Is Healthy and Rewarding β Liebermanβs 2020/21 book that lays out this evolutionary framework for physical activity and exercise. Harvard Scholar
βExercise is done against oneβs wishes and maintained only because the alternative is worse.β
β Lieberman highlights that evolution didnβt hard-wire us to enjoy planned exercise; we do it because we know the health risks of not doing it. Goodreads
βFor generation after generation, our ancestors β¦ generally steered clear of nonessential physical activities that divert energy from the only thing evolution really cares about: reproduction.β
β This stresses how our ancestors moved only when necessary or socially rewarding, not for healthβs sake. Goodreads
βWe evolved to be physically active as we age, and in turn being active helps us age well. β¦ it is almost never too late to benefit from getting fit.β
β Lieberman on active aging and the evolutionary benefits of movement throughout life. Goodreads
βThe resulting paradox is that our bodies never evolved to function optimally without lifelong physical activity, but our minds never evolved to get us moving, unless it is necessary, pleasurable or otherwise rewarding.β
β One of the core takeaways: our bodies need movement, but our brains are wired to conserve energy. Goodreads
βNothing about the biology of exercise makes sense except in the light of evolution, and nothing about exercise as a behavior makes sense except in the light of anthropology.β
β Liebermanβs overarching framework: evolution explains both our bodies and our behaviors related to movement. YouTube
These quotes give a sense of how Lieberman reframes exercise not as a modern βself-improvementβ project but in evolutionary context. Goodreads
Lieberman references long-term research showing physical fitness significantly reduces mortality and chronic disease risk:
Women who exercised had about one-third the death rate of less active women, and fitter men had about one-third to one-fourth the mortality risk of less fit men.
Those who improved fitness half-ed their mortality risk compared to persistently inactive peers.
More physically fit individuals were about half as likely to develop chronic conditions like diabetes and Alzheimerβs and tended to get sick later in life. Harvard Magazine
These findings support Liebermanβs point that activity has deep health impacts even if it doesnβt feel βnatural.β Harvard Magazine
Lieberman cites comparative activity level research (e.g., on the Hadza of Tanzania) to show:
Contemporary hunter-gatherers (proxy for ancestral lifestyles) are far more active than sedentary Western populations β not because they βexercise,β but because their daily survival depends on walking, running, digging, etc. WUNC
Activity was embedded in life, not isolated as leisure time exercise. WUNC
This anthropological evidence is part of his broader argument that exercise as we know it is a modern, optional behavior, not an evolved obligation. WUNC
Lieberman also discusses cognitive and motivational studies suggesting:
Humans evolved to avoid unnecessary exertion because conserving energy was crucial when food was scarce. Harvard Gazette
Making exercise social or enjoyable (like ancestral group activities) can help overcome our natural tendencies to avoid exertion. Harvard Gazette
Myths (e.g., running ruins knees) donβt hold up across scientific research; in fact, evidence suggests running can be neutral or slightly protective against osteoarthritis. Harvard Gazette
Lieberman consistently emphasizes:
Physical activity evolved as life requirement (for survival and reproduction), not health optimization. WYPR
Many commonly touted fitness beliefs (e.g., βwe must get exactly 8 hours of sleepβ) donβt hold up when examined through evolutionary and anthropological data. OUP Academic
The best approach today is to make movement necessary, enjoyable, or social β aligning modern activity with evolved motivations. Harvard Gazette
This study measured real activity using heart monitors in Hadza adults and found they:
Engage in very high levels of moderateβtoβvigorous physical activity (MVPA) (about 135β―min/day).
Maintain high activity across the lifespan.
Show very low cardiovascular disease risk markers (low hypertension and favorable biomarkers). PubMed+1
Citation:
D. A. Raichlen et al., Physical activity patterns and biomarkers of cardiovascular disease risk in hunterβgatherers, American Journal of Human Biology 29 (2017). PubMed
Researchers used wrist accelerometers (~6 days) to quantify activity in 177 Hadza men and women. Findings show:
Consistently high physical activity across age groups.
Movement patterns were not dramatically lower even in older adults, implying active lifestyles well into later years. PubMed
Citation:
Lifestyle and patterns of physical activity in Hadza foragers, American Journal of Biological Anthropology (2023). PubMed
This energyβexpenditure study measured daily activity and total energy use with GPS units and doubly labeled water. Key insights:
Hadza had similar total energy expenditure (TEE) to Western populations despite much higher activity, suggesting metabolic adaptation.
Activity level varied by sex but wasnβt a strong predictor of TEE once body composition was accounted for. PubMed
Citation:
Energy expenditure and activity among Hadza hunterβgatherers, American Journal of Human Biology (2015). PubMed
Lieberman and Exercised often cite longβterm cohort evidence such as this, which found:
Higher midlife fitness is linked to significantly lower mortality rates later in life.
Increased fitness later in life still halves death risk compared to staying unfit. Harvard Magazine
Reference described in:
Harvard Magazine summary of exercise and aging outcomes, including Cooper data. Harvard Magazine
Another major longitudinal cohort often referenced in evolutionary exercise discussions:
Alumni expending ~2000 kcal/week on physical activity had much lower longβterm mortality than sedentary peers.
The mortality benefit increased with age, showing that continued activity predicts better survival. Harvard Magazine
Reference described in:
Harvard Magazine evolutionary overview (2024). Harvard Magazine
This evolutionary review integrates exercise with aging, proposing:
Lifelong physical activity was selected for in humans even after reproduction ended.
Such activity likely helped maintain repair and maintenance processes that slow aging. PubMed
Citation:
M. Raichlen & D. Lieberman, The active grandparent hypothesis: Physical activity and the evolution of extended human healthspans and lifespans, Evolutionary Applications (2021). PubMed
While not always directly cited by Lieberman, these types of studies are in the same research sphere supporting evolutionary and anthropological frameworks about activity:
Ageing & Physical Function in NonβIndustrial Populations:
Examines physical ability and mobility with age among East African foragers and pastoralists β useful for understanding aging with high activity. PubMed
Sedentary Time & Muscle Engagement in HunterβGatherers:
Shows that hunterβgatherer resting postures (e.g., squatting) involve higher muscle engagement than chair sitting β relevant to discussions on activity quality versus quantity. Phys.org
Core Point Lieberman Makes
Supporting Evidence
Humans evolved for movement, not exercise intentionally
High habitual activity in Hadza across lifespan with survival dependence (Raichlen et al.). PubMed
Activity affects health & aging
Cooper Center & Harvard Alumni longitudinal mortality effects. Harvard Magazine+1
A mismatch exists today
Crossβcultural comparisons showing Western low activity vs. hunterβgatherer patterns. WYPR
Evolution may have selected for activity in older age (Active Grandparent)
Evolutionary model linking PA and healthspan/lifespan. PubMed
MVPA stands for Moderate-to-Vigorous Physical Activity.
MVPA includes movements that raise heart rate and breathing enough to challenge the body.
πΉ Moderate activity
Brisk walking
Easy jogging
Carrying loads
Steady cycling
Active play
You can talk, but not sing.
πΉ Vigorous activity
Running
Fast cycling
Hard manual labor
Competitive sports
Talking is difficult.
Human physiology evolved around frequent daily MVPA, not long periods of sitting.
Studies like Raichlen et al. (2017) use MVPA because it strongly predicts:
Cardiovascular health
Metabolic health
Longevity
The Hadza average ~135 minutes/day of MVPA, compared to ~10 minutes/day in many modern Western populations.
Movement quality + enough intensity = resilience
MVPA is not βexercise sessionsβ β itβs walking with purpose, carrying, playing, and moving often, just like humans evolved to do.
The Hadza are a traditional hunter-gatherer people who live in northern Tanzania (East Africa) and are often studied by scientists because their lifestyle closely resembles how humans lived for most of our evolutionary history.
π Location: Near Lake Eyasi, Tanzania
𧬠Lifestyle: Hunter-gatherers (not farmers, not industrialized)
πΉ Food:
Men often hunt animals
Women often gather tubers, berries, and baobab fruit
Honey is a major food source
π« No modern conveniences:
No cars
No gyms
No chairs most of the day
No structured βexerciseβ
Researchers (including Daniel Lieberman and David Raichlen) study the Hadza because:
They move the way humans evolved to move β naturally, daily, and with purpose.
πΆββοΈ Walk long distances every day
πββοΈ Run, climb, dig, carry, squat
π Move throughout the day, not in one workout
π΅ Stay physically active from youth into old age
Studies show Hadza adults average:
~135 minutes per day of MVPA
Very low rates of heart disease
Rare high blood pressure
Low inflammation
Activity stays high across the lifespan
π This makes them a living example of what human bodies were built for.
The Hadza are not βbetterβ or βidealβ people.
They are not a fitness program.
They are studied because they help answer this question:
What happens when humans live in a way closer to how our bodies evolved?
Humans didnβt evolve to exercise β
they evolved to MOVE to survive.
The Hadza still do.Β
Β How Human Evolution Shaped Todayβs Exercise & Sports Culture
(Through the Lens of Gray Cook & FMS)
𦴠1. Humans Evolved for Constant, Varied Movement
Liebermanβs research shows that our ancestors lived in a world where near-constant movement was normalβwalking, carrying, climbing, sprinting occasionally, and performing diverse physical tasks daily.
β’ Movement was functional, not optional.
β’ The body adapted to variability, not specialization.
β’ Chronic disease was rare; inactivity is the mismatch.
FMS tie-in:
FMS is built on the idea that humans are wired for fundamental movement patternsβsquat, hinge, lunge, push, pull, rotate, gait. These patterns evolved long before βsportsβ existed. When modern athletes skip these basics, dysfunction appears.
2. Humans Evolved to Be Endurance Athletes
Smithsonian research highlights that humans evolved unique traitsβspringy tendons, sweat cooling, long legs, stabilized trunksβthat make us exceptional endurance movers.
This shaped:
β’ Distance running
β’ Persistence hunting
β’ Long-duration locomotion
β’ Team-based pursuit strategies
FMS tie-in:
Endurance capacity only works when the movement patterns underneath it are clean.
If gait, hip mobility, or core stability break down, the evolutionary advantage collapses into overuse injuries.
3. Ancient Cultures Linked Movement to Identity
From Greek gymnasia to Spartan military training, physical culture was tied to:
β’ Citizenship
β’ Virtue
β’ Community
β’ Ritual and celebration
Sports werenβt hobbiesβthey were expressions of human excellence.
Modern echo:
Todayβs sports cultureβyouth leagues, high school athletics, the Olympicsβstill carries this ancient DNA. We compete, gather, celebrate, and build identity through movement.
FMS tie-in:
FMS restores the idea that movement quality is foundational to human development, not just performance.
4. The Modern Mismatch: Sedentary Life + High-Intensity Sports
Lieberman calls this the fundamental mismatch:
We are built for a world of constant low-to-moderate movement, but we now live in a world of chairs, screens, and climate control.
Yet we ask kids and adults to:
β’ Sit all day
β’ Then perform high-intensity, specialized sports
β’ With limited movement literacy
β’ And limited recovery
This mismatch drives:
β’ Overuse injuries
β’ Early specialization problems
β’ RED-S
β’ Poor movement competency
β’ Chronic pain
FMS tie-in:
FMS exists because of this mismatch.
It screens for the evolutionary βdefaultsβ weβve lost.
5. Why Todayβs Fitness Culture Looks the Way It Does
Modern gyms evolved from ancient gymnasia, military training, and public health movements.
But they also reflect the mismatch:
β’ We βexerciseβ because we no longer move naturally.
β’ We βtrainβ because daily life no longer trains us.
β’ We βwork outβ because work no longer requires movement.
Sports culture, meanwhile, amplifies:
β’ Specialization
β’ Competition
β’ Performance metrics
β’ Spectacle
All layered on top of bodies evolved for generalist movement, not specialization.
The Gray Cook FMS Interpretation
Hereβs the clean, FMS-style summary:
Human evolution gave us:
β’ A body built for varied, functional movement
β’ Endurance capacity
β’ Team-based pursuit and coordination
β’ Movement as identity and culture
Modern life removed:
β’ Daily movement variability
β’ Natural strength and mobility
β’ Organic skill development
β’ Community-based physical culture
Sports added:
β’ Specialization
β’ Intensity
β’ Volume
β’ Early competition
FMS bridges the gap by:
β’ Restoring fundamental movement patterns
β’ Identifying asymmetries and dysfunction
β’ Rebuilding the evolutionary foundation
β’ Preparing athletes for modern sport demands
β’ Protecting against the mismatch injuries of modern life
βMovement reflects the health of the system.β
FMS isnβt about exercises. Itβs about:
Pattern β before performance
Development β before specialization
Capability β before capacity
Evolutionary design β before modern training hacks
Both Your Inner Fish and Tracking Life: The Timescale of Evolution explain why those rules exist.
Key idea of the video:
Your body is not engineered from scratch. It is layered adaptations stacked on top of older movement solutions.
1. The human body is a βpatched systemβ
Neil Shubin shows that:
Our shoulders evolved from fish gill arches
Our neck, spine, hips, and limbs were never designed for chairs, shoes, or barbells
π FMS implication:
Movement limitations arenβt βtight musclesβ or βweak cores.β
They are design compromises.
Thatβs why FMS:
Screens movement instead of isolated strength
Looks for asymmetries and compensations
Assumes dysfunction is normal, not failure
2. Development mirrors evolution
Fish β amphibian β reptile β mammal β human
The same sequence appears in human motor development:
Supine β prone β rolling β quadruped β standing β walking
π FMS principle:
If you skip stages, the system pays later.
Thatβs why:
Rock backs matter
Crawling patterns matter
The Deep Squat is a developmental checkpoint, not a gym test
Your Inner Fish explains why regressing movement works.
3. Pain = strategy conflict
Shubin explains back pain, hernias, shoulder issues as:
Old structures forced into new tasks
π Gray Cook translation:
βPain changes movement; movement changes pain.β
FMS doesnβt chase pain.
It restores efficient strategy so the nervous system doesnβt need pain as a governor.
Key idea of the video:
Complex systems emerge slowly, and only after simpler systems stabilize.
1. Stability came before power
Life spent:
Billions of years stabilizing in water
Hundreds of millions learning land stability
Only recently expressing speed, jumping, throwing
π FMS rule:
Stability β Mobility β Strength β Power
You donβt load chaos.
You earn complexity.
This is why FMS correctives look βtoo simpleβ to modern eyesβthey reflect evolutionary order.
2. The nervous system always chooses efficiency
Evolution didnβt choose:
Maximum strength
Maximum speed
It chose:
Lowest cost
Highest survival
π FMS insight:
Compensation is not failureβitβs survival.
Screens exist to detect:
When efficiency becomes pathology
When survival strategies block performance
3. Humans are newβmovement systems are old
On the evolutionary track:
Humans appear in the last millimeters
Squats, hinges, gait patterns are ancient
π Gray Cook takeaway:
The movement patterns matter more than the sport.
Thatβs why FMS applies equally to:
Kids
Seniors
Elite athletes
Rehab patients
The patterns predate all of them.
Put simply:
Evolutionary Reality
FMS Principle
Old systems dominate new tasks
Screen patterns before loading
Development follows order
Correctives regress movement
Efficiency beats intensity
Quality > quantity
Asymmetry is normal
Symmetry is a training goal
Pain is protective
Remove threat, donβt chase symptoms
Your Inner Fish explains where movement comes from.
Tracking Life explains how long it took to get here.
FMS explains how to respect that design today.
Gray Cook didnβt invent movement rules.
He organized evolutionary logic into a usable system.
(Visual β’ Public-facing β’ Quick comprehension)
(Tracking Life: The Timescale of Evolution)
Life evolved stability before power
Simple movement patterns existed hundreds of millions of years before sport
Humans appear in the final moments of the timeline
β‘οΈ Movement patterns are ancient. Performance is recent.
(Your Inner Fish β Neil Shubin)
Shoulders = modified gill arches
Spine = adapted for land, not chairs
Hips & knees = inherited compromises
β‘οΈ The body is adaptive, not perfect
βMovement reflects the health of the system.β
Evolutionary Rule
FMS Principle
Stability came first
Screen before loading
Development followed order
Regress to progress
Efficiency = survival
Quality > intensity
Compensation = normal
Asymmetry reveals risk
Pain protects
Restore pattern, donβt chase pain
FMS identifies:
Where evolution left weak links
Where development was skipped
Where compensation is blocking performance
β‘οΈ We donβt fix muscles. We restore strategies.
FMS is not exercise selection.
It is evolutionary respect applied to modern movement.
(Academic β’ Conceptual β’ Systems-based)
LEFT: Evolutionary Evidence
4+ billion years of movement adaptation (Tracking Life)
Fish β amphibian β reptile β mammal β human (Your Inner Fish)
Movement patterns predate sport, fitness, and training
CENTER: Developmental Parallels
Ontogeny mirrors phylogeny (development reflects evolution)
Supine β prone β crawl β stand β gait
Missing stages = persistent compensation
RIGHT: Gray Cookβs FMS Logic
Pattern before performance
Mobility + stability before strength
Screening identifies neurological priorities
Correctives reintroduce developmental order
βYou cannot train what evolution and development did not prepare.β
Why does modern training often overload patterns that biology spent millions of years protecting?
(Plain language β’ Practical β’ Policy-ready)
Most programs:
Teach skills before movement readiness
Load kids with adult drills
Ignore asymmetries and pain signals
This leads to:
Injuries
Dropout
Burnout
Long-term dysfunction
(Your Inner Fish + Tracking Life)
The human body evolved slowly and sequentially
Movement patterns must be earned
Compensation is a survival strategy β until sport magnifies it
FMS:
Screens basic movement (squat, lunge, push, hinge, gait)
Identifies risk before injury
Uses simple correctives to restore fundamentals
βοΈ Safer participation
βοΈ Better long-term athletic development
βοΈ Fewer injuries and complaints
βοΈ More inclusive programming
βοΈ Stronger public health outcomes
If a child canβt move well, training harder makes it worse.
Screen first. Correct early. Develop forever.
Your Inner Fish explains the body.
Tracking Life explains the timeline.
Gray Cookβs FMS explains what to do about it.
Adam Oliver Brown is a science educator and ecologist affiliated with the University of Ottawa in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada. He is known for work in:
Ecology and animal behavior
Science communication
Teaching and learning in the sciences
Development of methods to improve undergraduate biology education
He also has been involved in TV and radio science communication, contributing to programs such as The Nature of Things (CBC) and childrenβs science shows like TVOKids Finding Stuff Out and The Prime Radicals.
π His roles include assistant professor (professeur adjoint) in the Faculty of Science (Biology), with a cross-appointment in education, reflecting his research interest in teaching, learning, and public engagement with science.
There are several professionals named Adam Brown across different fields β not necessarily the person you asked about but included here in case you meant one of them:
Clinical psychologist / global mental health researcher β Professor at The New School for Social Research focusing on trauma and global mental health.
Psychologist and trauma researcher β Formerly at Sarah Lawrence College and NYU, with research in PTSD and stress.
Professor of social work & clinical researcher β Focused on trauma, violence, and behavioral outcomes.
Particle physicist β Research fellow in dark matter detection at University of Sheffield.
Senior lecturer in biopharmaceutical engineering β Also at University of Sheffield.
Other professionals in medicine (e.g., rheumatology, optometry) and academia.
Adam Oliver Brown, Ph.D. is an Assistant Professor in the Department of Biology with a cross-appointment in the Faculty of Education at the University of Ottawa. His work focuses on science education, science communication, and biology teaching methods.
Email: abrown@uottawa.ca
Office: (613) 562-5800 ext. 6308
Cell (public listing): 613-558-2326
Preferred Contact: Email
Dr. Brownβs scholarly work bridges biology education and public communication of science. His research includes:
Developing teaching techniques and technologies for improved undergraduate biology learning.
Studying science communication to non-specialist audiences.
Creating learning scaffolds that improve conceptual understanding and knowledge transfer in science.
Designing pedagogical approaches to science communication education.
Some representative academic publications (often co-authored) include:
Oliveira, A.W. & Brown, A.O. (2021) β Fostering creativity in science learning: The potential of open-ended student drawing, Teaching and Teacher Education.
Oliveira, A.W., Brown, A.O., Carroll, M.L., et al. (2021) β Developing undergraduate student oral science communication through video reflection, International Journal of Science Education, Part B.
Oliveira, A.W., Bretzlaff, T., & Brown, A.O. (2020) β Memorable Exemplification in Undergraduate Biology, Research in Science Education.
Brown, A.O. (2017) β The Role of Values in the Effectiveness of Public Communications of Science for Sustainability, Education Review.
Oliveira, A.W. & Brown, A.O. (2016) β Exemplification in Science Instruction: Teaching and Learning through Examples, Journal for Research in Science Teaching.
Brown, A.O. (2014) β Lexical access, knowledge transfer and meaningful learning of scientific terminology via an etymological approach, International Journal of Biology Education.
Dr. Brown is known not only for academic research but also for media involvement, including production, scripting, and hosting of science content for television and radio, such as CBCβs The Nature of Things, TVOKids Finding Stuff Out, and The Prime Radicals.
His specialties include: ecology, animal behaviour, science education, communication and technology, curriculum design, environmental science, sustainable development, and public engagement with science.
π¬ Teaches biology (the science of living things!)
π§ Helps students understand BIG science ideas in simple ways
πΊ Shares science on TV and radio
π± Studies how to make science learning fun and meaningful
Biology is the study of:
π³ Plants
π¦ Animals
π¦ Ecosystems
𧬠How living things grow and survive
Dr. Brown believes:
β¨ Science should be for everyone
β¨ Big ideas can be explained clearly
β¨ Curiosity makes us smarter
β¨ Learning should be creative and exciting
π Drawing science ideas
π₯ Making science videos
π£ Practicing speaking about science
π€ Asking better questions
Science isnβt just facts β itβs understanding the world around you!
π Look closely.
β Ask questions.
π Explore.
π¬ Share what you learn.
All you need is:
Curiosity β€οΈ
Questions β
And a love for learning πβ¨
Evolution is how living things change over time.
Tiny changes β Over millions of years β Big differences!
π¦ First simple life in the oceans
Tiny cells begin the story of life!
Fish swim in ancient seas
Life becomes more complex
Plants and animals move onto land
The world starts to turn green!
Dinosaurs rule the Earth
Gigantic reptiles dominate
Dinosaurs disappear
Mammals begin to grow and spread
Humans are part of the story
Evolution is still happening!
If Earthβs history were ONE YEAR:
π
Dinosaurs appear in December
π
Humans appear in the last few minutes of December 31!
We are a tiny part of a very long story.
β¨ Life is connected
β¨ Small changes matter
β¨ Nature takes time
β¨ We are part of evolution too
β What changes help animals survive?
𦴠What clues do fossils give us?
π‘οΈ How does the environment shape life?
AND THE STORY IS STILL BEING WRITTEN! πβ¨
Evolution is how living things change over long periods of time.
Small changes β Over millions of years β New kinds of life!
Life on Earth is a very long story β and weβre still in it!
The first tiny life forms appear in the oceans.
Simple cells start the journey of life!
Fish and sea creatures become more complex.
Life is growing and diversifying!
Plants and animals begin living on land.
Forests grow. Insects and amphibians appear.
Dinosaurs rule the Earth!
Huge reptiles dominate land, sea, and sky.
Dinosaurs disappear.
Mammals grow, adapt, and spread across the planet.
If Earthβs history were one calendar year:
π
Dinosaurs appear in December
π
Humans appear in the last few minutes of December 31
We are a tiny moment in a huge timeline!
β¨ Life changes slowly over time
β¨ All living things are connected
β¨ The environment shapes survival
β¨ Evolution is still happening today
𦴠What can fossils tell us?
π‘οΈ How does climate affect life?
𧬠What small changes can lead to big differences?
create a large colored poster
4
Science helps us understand the world:
π³ Plants
πΎ Animals
π¦ Insects
π Oceans
π§ People
β¨ Draw what you see
β¨ Explain ideas to friends
β¨ Make short videos
β¨ Ask βWHY?β and βHOW?β
β¨ Explore and be curious
π Look closely at nature
π Draw it carefully
β Ask one big question
π¬ Share your discovery
β€οΈ Curiosity is your superpower
π§ Thinking leads to understanding
π Learning is an adventure
π YOU can be a scientist today!
Evolution is how living things change over long periods of time.
Small changes β Over millions of years β New kinds of life!
Life on Earth is a very long story β and weβre still in it!
The first tiny life forms appear in the oceans.
Simple cells start the journey of life!
Fish and sea creatures become more complex.
Life is growing and diversifying!
Plants and animals begin living on land.
Forests grow. Insects and amphibians appear.
Dinosaurs rule the Earth!
Huge reptiles dominate land, sea, and sky.
Dinosaurs disappear.
Mammals grow, adapt, and spread across the planet.
If Earthβs history were one calendar year:
π
Dinosaurs appear in December
π
Humans appear in the last few minutes of December 31
We are a tiny moment in a huge timeline!
β¨ Life changes slowly over time
β¨ All living things are connected
β¨ The environment shapes survival
β¨ Evolution is still happening today
𦴠What can fossils tell us?
π‘οΈ How does climate affect life?
𧬠What small changes can lead to big differences?