(Causes, Elements, & Progression of Controversy)
(Five Scientific Controversies for Analysis & Discussion)
1. Synthetic Biological Robots   2. Artificial Intelligence (AI)     3. Gene Editing in Humans (CRISPR)   4. Neural Implants & InterfacesÂ
(Ethical Dilemmas, Emerging Theories, Unresolved Issues, & Scientific Debates)
Search for Extraterrestrial Life (SETI): Resource allocation and the potential consequences of contact.
Colonization of Mars: Feasibility, ethics, and environmental concerns.
Planetary Protection: Ethical considerations of contaminating other planets.
Hubble vs. James Webb Telescope Funding: Cost-benefit analysis of large-scale space projects.
Astrology vs. Astronomy: Public misunderstandings and its impact on science education.
Space Debris: Risks and responsibility for managing orbital waste.
Private Space Exploration: Role of corporations like SpaceX in space travel and exploration.
Stellar Astronomy
Star lifecycle models
Stellar nucleosynthesis debates
Classification of exotic stars
Planetary Science
Ethics of planetary colonization
Asteroid mining controversies
Pluto's classification
Cosmology
Multiverse hypothesis
Cosmic microwave background interpretations
Dark matter and dark energy origins
Exoplanetary Science
Ethics of habitable exoplanet exploration
Detection methods and verification
Habitability criteria debates
Astrobiology
Search for extraterrestrial life
Planetary contamination ethics
Intelligent extraterrestrial life debates
Evolution: Evolution vs. intelligent design or creationism debates.
Genetically Modified Organisms (GMOs): Ethical, environmental, and health impacts of GM crops and animals.
Stem Cell Research: Use of embryonic stem cells in research and therapies.
Vaccination: Safety, efficacy, and the ethics of mandatory vaccinations.
Synthetic Biology: Creation of artificial life and the potential for misuse.
Cloning: Moral and ethical implications of cloning humans or animals.
Biodiversity Loss: Economic development vs. conservation efforts.
Botany
Genetically modified crops
Deforestation ethics
Rare plant conservation debates
Zoology
Animal testing ethics
Invasive species management
Ethics of zoos and sanctuaries
Microbiology
Gain-of-function research
Microbes in bioterrorism
Microbiome manipulation controversies
Genetics
Human gene editing ethics
Genetic privacy and ownership
Designer babies debates
Ecology
Rewilding programs
Biodiversity loss controversies
Conservation efforts and climate change
Physiology
Performance-enhancing drugs
Organ transplantation ethics
Space travel physiological impacts
Evolutionary Biology
Evolution versus creationism
Role of epigenetics in evolution
Application of evolutionary principles to society
Molecular Biology
Synthetic biology ethics
Molecular basis of consciousness
Molecular cloning applications
Organic Chemistry
Safety of synthetic compounds
Environmental impact of petrochemicals
Patenting genetically modified organisms
Inorganic Chemistry
Heavy metal contamination
Safety of nuclear materials
Mining rare earth elements
Physical Chemistry
Industrial modeling of chemical processes
Artificial photosynthesis debates
Accuracy of quantum chemistry models
Analytical Chemistry
Reliability of forensic evidence
Standardization in environmental monitoring
Privacy concerns in chemical sensing technologies
Biochemistry
CRISPR and genetic editing ethics
Personalized medicine controversies
Biochemistry of aging and enhancement
Environmental Chemistry
Chemical pollution and climate change
Safety of pesticides and herbicides
Geoengineering risks
Materials Science
Renewable energy material impact
Nanomaterials and safety concerns
Biomimetic materials and ethics
Climate Change: Causes, impacts, and mitigation strategies (e.g., anthropogenic vs. natural variability).
Fracking: Environmental consequences of hydraulic fracturing for natural gas.
Sea Level Rise: Debate over projections and socioeconomic impacts.
Mining Practices: Environmental and ethical concerns around rare earth metals and deep-sea mining.
Renewable Energy: Land-use conflicts and feasibility of transitioning to 100% renewables.
Geoengineering: Feasibility and risks of climate intervention technologies.
Volcanic Supereruption Risks: Predictions and preparedness for catastrophic events.
Geology
Environmental impact of fracking
Human-induced earthquakes
Plate tectonics versus alternative models
Meteorology
Climate model reliability
Geoengineering debates
Weather modification ethics
Oceanography
Deep-sea mining controversies
Marine protected areas and fishing rights
Ocean acidification impacts
Hydrology
Water privatization debates
Transboundary water management
Ecological effects of dams
Paleontology
Fossil record interpretations
Fossil trade ethics
Mass extinction events
Soil Science
Sustainable agriculture versus conventional farming
Soil degradation controversies
Biochar and soil amendments
Deforestation: Balancing economic needs with ecological preservation.
Pollution: Responsibility for global pollution (corporations vs. individuals)
Carbon Offsetting: Effectiveness and ethics of carbon offset programs.
Endangered Species Protection: Flagship species vs. biodiversity hotspots
Overfishing: Balancing global food security with marine conservation.
Plastic Bans: Effectiveness and consequences of single-use plastic bans.
Renewable vs. Nuclear Energy: Best strategies for decarbonization.
Balancing development and conservation
Environmental costs of renewable energy
Abortion: Ethical and scientific arguments surrounding fetal viability.
Euthanasia: The role of science in supporting end-of-life decisions.
Drug Testing: Animal testing vs. alternative methods.
Mental Health Treatment: Use of psychedelics and other controversial treatments.
CRISPR in Humans: Ethics of editing genes in embryos or adults.
Pandemic Management: Vaccine distribution equity and lockdown policies.
Health Disparities: Structural racism and inequities in healthcare delivery.
Cognitive Science & Consciousness
The Hard Problem of Consciousness – Can consciousness be explained purely by physical processes, or does it require something beyond neuroscience?
Neural Correlates of Free Will – Does neuroscience disprove the existence of free will, or is decision-making still an emergent phenomenon?
Brain-Computer Interfaces (BCIs) & Ethics – Are invasive BCIs, such as Elon Musk's Neuralink, ethical for human enhancement and medical treatments?
Neurotechnology & AI
Artificial Intelligence & the Brain – Can AI ever fully replicate or surpass human intelligence, and what are the ethical concerns?
Neuroscience of Criminal Behavior – Should brain scans be used as legal evidence to determine criminal responsibility?
Memory Manipulation & Erasure – Is it ethical to erase traumatic memories or enhance memory beyond normal human limits?
Neuropharmacology & Mental Health
Psychedelics for Mental Health – Should substances like psilocybin and MDMA be widely used for treating PTSD and depression?
Antidepressants & Neuroplasticity – Do SSRIs and other antidepressants actually "rewire" the brain, or are their effects overstated?
ADHD Overdiagnosis & Medication Ethics – Are ADHD diagnoses being overused to justify stimulant prescriptions in children and adults?
Neuroethics & Human Enhancement
Cognitive Enhancement Drugs ("Smart Drugs") – Should drugs like Modafinil or Adderall be used for cognitive enhancement in healthy individuals?
Human Brain Augmentation – Should we develop and normalize implantable chips to enhance memory, intelligence, or sensory perception?
Mind Uploading & Immortality – If we could upload human consciousness to a machine, would it be the same person, or just a copy?
Neurological Disorders & Research Ethics
Animal Testing in Neuroscience – Is using primates and other animals in brain research justified, given the potential benefits for human health?
Gene Editing for Neurological Disorders – Should CRISPR or other gene-editing techniques be used to "correct" genetic predispositions to conditions like Alzheimer’s or schizophrenia?
The Ethics of Deep Brain Stimulation (DBS) – Should electrical brain stimulation be used for non-medical purposes, such as personality alteration or cognitive enhancement?
Sleep & Consciousness Alteration
Polyphasic Sleep & Productivity – Is extreme sleep modification (e.g., Uberman sleep schedule) a viable cognitive enhancement or harmful?
Lucid Dreaming & Neuroscience – Can techniques like targeted brain stimulation safely induce or control lucid dreaming?
Effects of Sleep Deprivation on Decision-Making – Should sleep deprivation be taken as seriously as intoxication when considering responsibility in accidents or crimes?
Neuroplasticity & Development
Screen Time & Brain Development – Are digital screens fundamentally changing how children's brains develop, and should we regulate exposure?
Neurodiversity & Autism – Should autism be treated as a disorder to be "cured" or as a natural variation in human neurology that should be accepted?
Quantum Mechanics: The interpretation of quantum mechanics (Copenhagen interpretation vs. Many-Worlds interpretation).
Dark Matter and Dark Energy: The nature and existence of dark matter and dark energy.
Big Bang Theory: Competing models of the universe's origin (steady-state theory, multiverse theories).
Nuclear Energy: Safety, environmental impacts, and its role in combating climate change.
String Theory: Debate over its testability and status as a scientific theory.
Speed of Light Limit: Challenges to relativity and potential evidence of faster-than-light particles (e.g., neutrinos).
Climate Engineering (Geoengineering): Ethical and physical risks of technologies like solar radiation management.
Classical Mechanics
Determinism and free will
Limits of Newtonian mechanics
Militarization of classical mechanics technologies
Thermodynamics
Entropy and life
Perpetual motion machines
Climate modeling controversies
Electromagnetism
Health risks of electromagnetic fields (e.g., 5G)
Environmental impact of material mining
Unification of fundamental forces
Quantum Mechanics
Quantum measurement problem
Quantum entanglement and faster-than-light communication
Ethical implications of quantum computing
Relativity
Time dilation and real-world applications
Singularities and event horizons
Integration of relativity and quantum mechanics
Optics
Blue light and human health
Commercialization of laser technologies
Wave-particle duality debates
Astrophysics
Ethics of space exploration
Dark matter and dark energy disputes
Big Bang versus alternative cosmological models
(Ideas at the Boundary of Established Knowledge)
Pseudoscience: Topics lacking scientific rigor or not supported by empirical evidence.
Speculative Science: Ideas that are theoretical or lack substantial evidence but are not entirely dismissed by the scientific community.
Contested Science: Fields where there is significant debate or disagreement within the scientific community.
Pathological Science: Research that persists despite being based on flawed methods or interpretations.
Anomalistic Science: The study of phenomena that fall outside conventional scientific understanding.
(Ethical Dilemmas, Conspiracy Theories, & Fringe Beliefs)
AI Safety and Existential Risk
CRISPR Gene Editing and Human Embryo Modifications
Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) Development
Quantum Computing Ethical Implications
Brain-Computer Interface Privacy Concerns
Autonomous Weapon Systems Development
Synthetic Biology and Engineered Organisms
Genetic Privacy and Predictive Genetic Testing
Nanotechnology Potential Risks
Climate Engineering Technologies
Geoengineering Climate Interventions
Mass Extinction and Biodiversity Loss
Nuclear Fusion Feasibility
Renewable Energy Transition Challenges
Ocean Acidification Mitigation
Arctic and Antarctic Ecological Preservation
Rewilding and Species Restoration
Plastic Pollution Remediation
Vertical Farming Technologies
Sustainable Urban Design Strategies
Stem Cell Research Boundaries
Synthetic Embryo Creation
Longevity and Life Extension Technologies
Neurotechnology and Cognitive Enhancement
Personalized Medicine Ethics
Animal-Human Hybrid Research
Organ Printing and Transplantation
Microbiome Manipulation
Cancer Treatment Immunotherapies
Neuroethics and Consciousness Research
CRISPR in Humans: Ethics of editing genes in embryos or adults.
Quantum Supremacy Claims
Blockchain and Decentralized Systems
Cryptocurrency Environmental Impact
Privacy in Digital Surveillance
Cybersecurity and State-Sponsored Hacking
Internet Fragmentation
Advanced Cryptography
Quantum Communication Networks
Big Data Ethics
Algorithmic Bias in Machine Learning
Consciousness Transfer Technologies
Extraterrestrial Communication Attempts
Dark Matter and Dark Energy Theories
Multiverse Hypotheses
Quantum Consciousness Theories
Holographic Universe Principles
Exotic Matter Research
Gravitational Wave Communication
Panspermia and Origin of Life Theories
Quantum Entanglement Communication
(Resources To Find & Research Scientific Controversies)
(Find & Research Scientific Controversies)
UT Austin Library: RHE 309S, Books, databases, & guides.
Gale in Context: Opposing Viewpoints: Resources, articles, & opinions
Gale in Context: Topic Finder: Search terms & topic connectionsÂ
ProCon: Pros and Cons of 100+ Topics
CQResearcher: Browse by topic, hot topic, or pros/cons.Â
ClearerThinking: Improve decision-making & boost critical thinking
SAGE Knowledge: Broad overviews of topics.
RHE 306 Research Guide: UT Austin library guide for RHE 306.Â
Brookings Institute: Topics: Browse contemporary controversies.Â
The Heritage Foundation: Select "Explore Issues."Â
Pew Research Center: Topics: Extensive list of controversies. Â
RAND Reports by Topic: See trending topics or list all topics.
Retraction Watch: Tracks scientific retractions & controversies in research
The Conversation (Science Section: Articles by scientists on controversial topics.
FactCheck.org (Science): Investigates misinformation & media scientific claimsÂ
(Scientific Publication Details)
Nature: Covers scientific debates, emerging issues, & controversial findings.
Science: Cutting-edge research, policy discussions, & scientific disagreements.
Scientific American: Accessible articles on controversial scientific topics.
The Lancet: Medical journal, controversies in health, medicine, & public policy.
PLOS One: Open-access journal, discussions on emerging & disputed research.
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS): High-impact research, often addressing controversial issues.
BMJ (British Medical Journal): Medical & public health controversies & ethics
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC): Controversies surrounding climate science & policy.
National Academies Press: Scientific controversies in health, energy, & tech.
World Health Organization (WHO) Reports: Public health controversies.
Quanta Magazine: Physics, biology, AI debates & unresolved questions.
MIT Technology Review: Technological advancements' ethical & societal implications.
(Twelve Departments Natural Science)
(Biosciences & Beyond)
(Science-Based, Human-Focused)
(Computer Science, Statistics, Data, Math)
(Fundamentals of Matter & Energy)
Table of Contents
(This Page)