Ms. Byars, English teacher at Dept. Chair at Dorman Freshman Campus uses a strategy called "TCSE" to help her students grow in proficiency as writers with their analysis writing.
This approach helps students structure their essay step by step, showing them how to think carefully about:
*What their thesis will be and specifically what they will provide,
*What their claim will be and how it will provide focus for their upcoming support,
*What their support for their claim will be ,
*What their explanation will be that shows the reader how their direct quotes provide evidence to support their claim.
In the four steps below you can see how Ms. Byars introduces the TCSE strategy with her freshman students to support their literacy analysis of Romeo and Juliet and to help scaffold their writing of their assigned literary analysis essay.
In the video clip to the left, Ms. Alyssa Byars shares with her students a step by step outline that helps her students organize their essays using the TCSE format. Please see the links below to view the scaffolding documents that Ms. Byars reviews with her students to help guide their understanding of the TCSE format and also guides their implementation of this framework into their independent writing. After introducing the outline and support documents to students, Ms. Byars walks them step by step through setting up their sample /exemplar paper following MLA formatting so they have an exact model and have gone through the process of setting up their own paper.
In the video clip to the right, Ms. Byars models for students how to create an effective thesis that tells the reader the author, genre, and title of the text that and provides a thesis explaining what they are wanting to prove.
In the video clip to the left, Ms. Byars models for students step three in the TCSE strategy that focuses on writing a clear and concise claim.
In the video clip to the right, Ms. Byars models for students how they can provide support for their claim through carefully selecting relevant, direct quotes from their text. Ms. Byars provided a scaffolding tool for students for their quote selection through the use of her quote handout that asked students to consider quotes that support their one word characterization of Romeo and Juliet's relationship. See a student example of this scaffolding tool below. Ms. Byars uses this tool again when students are working to explain their support in step 5.
In the video clip to the left, Ms. Byars models for students how to create logical explanations that prove the previous quote and adding additional support for the essay's claim. Ms. Byars explains that students need two sentences of explanations that answer the question, "How does the quote prove the claim and thesis?"
Notice also in the video how Ms. Byars models for students how to write in "placeholder" statements such as "This quote shows" to help transition into their explanation components and then how they can take it out once their explanation statements are strong and carry the meaning on their own.
In the first video clip below and to the right, Ms. Byars models for students how they can repeat the process of creating a claim and providing support through a direct quote. In the second video clip below you will see Ms. Byars modeling how to add two explanation sentences that helps to strengthen the quote selection and helps to prove the claim.
In the video clip to the left, Ms. Byars models for students how to repeat the CSE process for paragraph 2, doing just enough modeling to review the outline and remind them of the structure before releasing them to work on practicing this strategy on their own.
In the video clip to the left, Ms. Byars begins her mini-lesson with a review of the TCSE strategy with students. She then models for students how to write a conclusion statement that will be at the end of the second paragraph.
In the video clip to the right you will see a brief interview with a student from Ms. Byars's class discussing the TCSE strategy. When asked about her thoughts on the strategy the student shared, "To me it was very helpful. It helped me to organize everything to make sure I had everything in the right place and to make sure everything fits together perfectly." This student shared that she will use the handouts Ms. Byars gave and will look through the different suggestions for wording to be sure it was the best it can be.
In this video clip you will see Ms. Byars providing explanations to students for feedback she provided to them in their Google Doc drafts through comment boxes. When asked about the return on her time investment for this practice, Ms. Byars explained that the time she spends providing students with feedback on their early drafts pays off in her final grading in increased quality of student writing and in more efficient grading because she has already reviewed earlier drafts of the writing. See an example of her feedback to students below.
In the video clip to the right, you will see Ms. Byars providing individualized instruction to students through one on one conferencing. Notice how she refers students back to resources she has provided to them in previous instruction to help them grow in independence as well as improve the quality of their drafts.
In the video clip to the left, Ms. Byars uses questioning effectively to promote student thought and problem solving as they work to work on applying the feedback Ms. Byars provided to them. In my subsequent conference with Ms. Byars regarding this practice she explained how she knows her students are smart enough to figure out the answers for themselves and will be more likely to understand and apply the process independently than if she just gave them the answer. She also explains her intentional use of a gradual release of responsibility where she models for students how to get started with their papers using the TCSE strategy but then expects them to work on applying it on their own with her support and the support of their peers so they can then independently use the strategy on their own papers.
In the video clip to the right, Ms. Byars explains to students how to use the process of Peer Editing to provide each other with feedback on their rough drafts using a step by step checklist that guides them through the process. You will see in the link below the Peer Editing checklist that Ms. Byars uses.
In the links below you will see examples of Ms. Byars's student drafts of this essay using the TCSE strategy.