Running Economy and Efficiency

What is Run Efficiency?

Efficiency, in a general sense, implies doing something in the most efficient manner, i.e. wasting the least amount of resources.  Being able to run at a given speed with the least amount of effort is a desirable thing to do, and we would describe such runners as efficient.  

But instead of the term efficiency, scientists use the term running-economy, this is similar to the fuel economy of a car: a measure of the amount of fuel used to cover a specific distance. 

Running Economy (RE) :

Is the amount of energy needed to maintain a specific speed.  

Running Economy can be best thought of as a look at WHOLE BODY efficiency in terms of oxygen consumption.

It can be improved over time through various training mechanisms.  

Such as better running form and efficiency, an increase in capillary density and also increased mitochondria and enzymes in the muscles has been shown to improve your RE.  

So basically the the amount of oxygen your system can transport so as to fuel muscles, is increased, therefore speed and stamina are able to develop further.

So to me in practical terms economy and efficiency are synonymous and I don't separate them when developing a training and racing programme.  

The two RE's important,  because it is not your actual speed that gives you better running economy, but more of how long you can maintain that pace. 

Runners who have a good RE use less energy and oxygen than a runner who has a poor RE at the same pace.

YOU HAVE THE SAME RE, NO MATTER WHAT PACE YOU ARE RUNNING AT THE TIME

Mechanical Efficiency.

This is what most people think of when they hear “They are a efficient runner.” It is best thought of as how good one’s running form and posture is, and how they look as a runner. 

Are his feet planting the right right way, is his hip extension good, and cadence suitable etc. 

There are other things in this category that you can't see, such as the physiological factors like the tension in the muscles & tendons and how much energy return the runner gets from this, plus lot's of other factors that contribute.

But in general, mechanical efficiency can be seen as, and be improved by, working on the runner’s form.

Physiological Efficiency. 

This encompasses all of the processes that take place within the body’s circulatory and muscular system. A couple of examples would be how efficient the oxygen transport and utilization system is and how efficient the body is at breaking down energy sources.

Neural Efficiency. 

This refers to the processes that are dependent on the Nervous system. The creation of motor programmes that essentially tell the body what to do and how to run is what this efficiency deals with. The more you run, the more efficient the body becomes at sending the neural signals from the brain to the muscles (even if with poor form). The brain also becomes better at determining how many and what muscle fibres to fire to do a certain movement.

Together these efficiencies govern how efficient a runner is in a whole body sense, and their interaction and the fact that you can be much more efficient in one area than another, shows why running form improvement alone, does not necessarily make you a better and more efficient runner, and that's if they are correct improvements. 

If making changes, at first the athlete will become less efficient as they are learning a new skill, because their neural efficiency will drop, but over time your neural efficiency will adapt to the new motion and then the mechanical efficiency will improve.

This takes time, gradually changing and having patience.  

There are though, many runners who have bad form in some way and they are very efficient at running the wrong way. This is because they’d run so many miles that their body had become very efficient at running the wrong way. 

They become better at what they practice, even if what they practice has some wrong form.

Some times making slight changes to poor form may not be worth it for the effort to make those changes, and your body may already have compensated for your personal quirk and get's the best out of your own natural way of running.

This is personal and does not apply to the next person.

This is just one example of how some coaches and scientists have drawn the wrong conclusion from a set of data. Make sure you aren't one of those who makes that mistake.

So in practical terms, what can you do ? 

GET GOOD FORM

Sure, Paula Radcliffe set the world marathon record with her distinct loping gait and nodding head. But for mere mortals, floppy form means wasted energy. Research has shown that through practice you can become more economical. 

The more you rehearse, the more efficient you'll become, 

You don't necessarily have to analyse your stride; the learning occurs naturally as you gain experience. Practice running with good form at a pace that feels comfortable from start to finish. 

You shouldn't be huffing and puffing, or moving so slowly that it feels unnatural. Over time, your gait will become more efficient. 

If you're a beginner, just focus on gradually logging more miles on a regular basis. If you're more experienced, add speed work.

But for a distance runner and in general terms, having a mid-foot strike, with the plant under you and not out in front, and not over striding. A slight heel flick with the hamstring automatically pulling your leg through in a gravitational way to your next stride, and so using less energy. 

Think a tall upright carriage, not sinking low hips, but not bouncing up and down, a slightly bent leg trail leg coming through and not straight leading to foot plant. And look ahead by 20 metres or more not straight down, try to be light on you feet and not heavy slapping, and try not to have exaggerated arm movements.

You can practise this and be conscious of it in training, but run naturally when racing. Be patient this is a personal thing and do what suits you best.

Obviously there are some genetic factors in size and shape, capilliary and muscle fibre distribution etc that may predispose you to being a better distance runner / racer.

Obviously being at your best racing weight is more energy efficient and don't over develop upper body muscles as this is like racing with a full back pack.

So for distance runners don't over do the conditioning, core, gym work and weights, just keep it event specific and eliminating any imbalances. 

Light shoes and clothing are better, well fitting and not too flappy either. But in cold weather wear sufficient, so as not to waste energy if too cold.

Practice proprioceptive drills on a regular basis, to help posture and good form, to aid and practice good efficient movement.

GET POWER & STRENGTH 

Core Stability Exercises. Working on your Strength

Increasing the force in your stride will make your running feel easier. The more powerfully you can push off the ground, the less effort each stride will take, and ultimately it will be easier to run faster. You'll feel like you have more strength in reserve.

So try plyometrics in some form, whether explosive bounding movements that help you push off the ground, (could be on a hill). These exercises mimic parts of the running stride and help give you more push-off power on the road.

I actually like regular step up exercises, using a bench (lower if you are small), and something like left leg 30 steps in one minute, rest then same with right. progress to alternate steps of left and right. Moving on to a number of reps or variations on a theme. Usually these are done after an easy or steady run or part of a conditioning session.

Hill runs, reps and sprints, give you strength and power. Whether out and 10 - 20 sec sprints, longer 30 - 60mins hills, undulating fartlek, 2 - 3mins hill efforts, tempo sessions on hills or long climbs of 5 - 30mins, and obviously long off-road hilly runs.

Regular strides or fartlek at the end runs  for 5 - 10 efforts, 15 - 20 seconds is sufficient, with 5 on short runs and up to 10 on longer runs. I like to do approx 1 effort per 10 mins of length of run, not as a strict rule and not every day ie 30 - 50 mins : 4 - 5 strides, 55 - 75 mins : 6 - 7 strides, 80 - 90mins 10x maximum, but on longer runs may be too tired, depending on the objective of the run.

Obviously conditioning sessions, whether circuits, plyometrics, isometrics, yoga, pilates, core sessions etc

N.B. drop the volume and top end speed of intense sessions before important races, also keep any conditioning, circuits / core sessions light, as they all can leave you heavy legged and tight quads, taking the spring and freshness out of your legs, during the race.

TEMPO RUNNING 

(or High-End Aerobic Training) Tempo Running

So tempo running in various forms and objectives, and progressing that ability to run fast, but for longer and more comfortably, gives a better RE.

This is training at the very upper edge of aerobic running. Includes (LT),Lactate Threshold running, or (OBLA), on-set of blood lactate accumulation, lactate turn point, others use various names for this.

So the faster you are able to run at your lactate turnpoint, the faster you'll race.

What is usually called the lactate threshold / turnpoint, is at a pace approximately  10 - 30 seconds per mile slower than your current 10k race pace, dependant on how fast you are and current level of fitness.

And you should be able to hold that reasonably comfortably for up to an hour, ie roughly your 15k/ 10 mile race pace or ½ marathon pace for real fast guys.

This can be a straight run, progressing the time from 15 to 40mins, over the weeks.

It can be broken down into, long cruise repetitions, nearer to 10K pace, out and back tempo’s, acceleration runs or progression runs.

Or AT (Aerobic Threshold) which is essentially steady state aerobic running performed at your marathon pace for longer runs of 40 to 60mins, although marathon runners could periodically take this up to 75mins .

It’s faster and harder than your normal day to day steady maintenance running, but usually slower than your half marathon racing pace.

LSD : LONG STEADY RUNNING

THE LONG RUN

So what essential training effect and physical gains do LSD runs give you. Better running economy and efficiency

Increased mitochondria, multiplying your capillary system, improving your oxygen carrying capacity.

Increased glycogen storage, and increased fat utilization at race pace. The benefits of long runs are not just obtained by simply accumulating "time on your feet." 

Long, slow distance is often touted as the most effective way to train, but elite runners, have always known that would only prepare them to run a long way slowly, but that knowledge did not used to be widespread.

In my mind LSD is Long Steady Distance, and we realize that many of the physiological adaptations to long runs (e.g., increased glycogen storage, and increased fat utilization at race pace) are specific to your training pace.

So there are various forms of long run and actual length or time of the run that you can do at various times in your plan.

I prefer it on an empty stomach and then your body can experience the adaptations for fuel distribution, fat utilization etc ( I might take water on a 2 hour run when very hot.

N.B. You will have gains later on as you get lighter from

Obviously if less fit, then you need to take a drink on long runs when very hot, but gels are not needed when you train your body, to avoid the hitting wall effects.

The ability to up the pace to race pace in latter stages of long training runs, is essential to training for long races and marathons.

More to follow regarding putting this all into practice.

VO2max : Maximal oxygen uptake.   

The basic definition of VO2 max is the maximum amount of oxygen your body can use during exercise.  V is volume, O2 is oxygen,  and max is maximum.

As you begin running your VO2 rate will increase and continue to increase until a point it can increase no more.  This plateau of where you can no longer utilize oxygen any faster is your VO2 max. The higher your VO2 max, the better your fitness level, but it has a limit.

Running Economy (RE) : is the amount of energy needed to maintain a specific speed.  

It is found by measuring the amount of oxygen consumed (VO2) at a certain steady sub maximal (meaning under Lactate Threshold or Turnpoint (LT) pace and looking at the respiratory gas exchange ratio.  

Once you get above the LT pace your VO2 no longer reaches steady levels as it is increasing, and therefore running economy can not be measured. 

 

The lower the ratio of VO2 to running pace, the better the Running Economy, or in simple terms the lower your VO2 is at a certain pace, the better your Running Economy.  

N.B. Your VO2 has a limited scope for improvement once you get to elite level, but in fact your genetics may have a limiting factor and influence on it also.

The very elite level is rarely obtainable except for the most exceptional of athletes. 

At elite level the difference in VO2max between runners is minimal for particularly and obviously middle distance and distance runners. 

Many other factors also come in to play to be a successful runners at this level.

There is no need to dwell on VO2max, but the sessions are worked in at the right time in the leading up to peaking for your main race, not the be all and end all as there are many more things to do in your seasonal progressions, plus year on year development.

But Running Economy can be improved over time through various training mechanisms.  

It can be improved through better running form and efficiency and also an increase in capillary density.  

Also an increase in mitochondria and enzymes in the muscles has been shown to improve RE.  

So basically the the amount of oxygen your system can transport so as to fuel muscles is increased, therefore speed and stamina are able to develop further.

So to me in practical terms economy and efficiency are synonymous and I don't separate them when developing a training and racing programme.  

Why the two RE's important?  

It is not your actual speed that gives you better running economy, but more of how long you can maintain that pace. because runners who have a good RE use less energy and oxygen than a runner who has a poor RE at the same pace.

So tempo running and progressing that gives a better RE

Paula Radcliffe

Paula Radcliffe is a good example, she has been tested and monitored regularly and each year since she was a Junior age runner. 

Her VO2max has reduced since she was a Junior, but year on year her economy has improved as she was getting faster and moving on to peak marathon performances. 

And even when her VO2max was lower her short distance race times were far faster on the back of training to be the marathon runner she was.

She left no stone unturned when exploring her economy and efficiency. Although deciding that the effort needed to focus on reducing her head nod and efficiency, was not worth it, for the tiny amount of economy saved and in fact extra neural activity and focus, detracted from the racing at hand.