Collect and discuss quantitative and qualitative information about the success of implementation
Common Domain: Implementation Process
Transversal Domain: Evidence & MEL
Ask yourself...
How are you interpreting feedback about the success of implementation?
How will you review the process of observing your innovation's performance?
What do you need to help you review the observation process?
Have any of our assumptions about the project turned out to be wrong?
At what stages in the scaling process are you evaluating your innovation's scaling?
Who comes up with ideas and who puts them into action in your organization?
How does your organization use active learning to help innovation?
How will we ensure we have enough capacity to evaluate the project?
Is there an effective system for monitoring and evaluation in place?
Is there an intermediate outcome reflecting subsequent benefits and impacts from the outputs?
Is there an ultimate outcome showing long-term, sustainable impacts on the target population?
How will we track the progress and performance of the project?
How can we keep checking and improving our project over time?
How can we learn and improve our project continuously as we go?
How can we collect and look at information to see if our project is working?
How can we think about what went well and what didn’t in our project?
See also
Terms
Implementation Process - Reflecting on Implementation
reflection on actions
reflection on resources
scaling progress reflections
assumptions monitoring
assumptions reflections
plans monitoring
plans reflection
monitoring activities time table
monitoring activities responsible person
reflection activities time table
reflection activities responsible person
monitorable
Monitoring
Evaluation
Experiential learning cycle (Kolb)
Nesta's Innovation Skills team pedagogy
Feedback loops
Evaluation tools
Evaluation capacity
Measure progress of the scaling process
sharing lessons
M&E (Monitoring and Evaluation)
Intermediate Outcome
Ultimate Outcome
observable
monitoring and evaluation
success
track performance
dynamic evaluation
measure
evaluations
adaptive evaluation
overall theory of change
hypothesis testing
data assessment
reflect
Definitions
Collect and discuss quantitative and qualitative information about the success of implementation
A process of reviewing and analyzing the actions taken during the implementation of the proposed solution, identifying successes, challenges, and areas for improvement.
A process of evaluating and assessing the adequacy, efficiency, and effectiveness of the resources allocated or utilized during the implementation of the proposed solution.
Deliberate reviews and analyses of the progress made in scaling up the implementation of the proposed solution, identifying achievements, setbacks, and opportunities for adjustment.
Observing and evaluating the validity and accuracy of the assumptions made about the proposed solution's implementation and its expected outcomes.
Thoughtful consideration and analysis of the assumptions underlying the proposed solution, reflecting on whether they hold true or need adjustment based on observed outcomes.
Tracking and assessing the implementation of the planned activities and strategies outlined to achieve the goals of the proposed solution.
Engaging in critical examination and review of the plans developed for the implementation of the proposed solution, identifying strengths, weaknesses, and areas for refinement or adaptation.
A schedule or plan outlining when monitoring activities will be conducted to track progress, assess performance, and gather data related to the implementation of the proposed solution.
The individual or team designated to oversee and carry out the monitoring activities, ensuring that they are conducted effectively and according to the established timetable.
A schedule or plan outlining when reflection activities will be conducted to review and analyze the results, assumptions, and plans related to the scaling progress of the proposed solution.
The individual or team responsible for facilitating and leading reflection activities, ensuring that lessons learned are captured, insights are shared, and adjustments are made as needed to support the scaling process effectively.
The ease with which the uptake and quality of implementation of the initiative can be observed and assessed
The systematic process of tracking the progress and quality of an initiative's implementation
The determination of the merit, worth or significance of something.
A learning process that puts experience at the heart of learning and development
NESTA's vision on learning for innovation
Mechanisms that allow for continuous feedback and improvement in processes and systems.
Methods and instruments used to assess the effectiveness of programs and interventions.
The ability of an organization to conduct thorough evaluations of its initiatives.
Monitoring the advancement of an innovation through its scaling stages to ensure it is on track.
Conducting trials to assess the viability and effectiveness of innovations.
systematic processes for assessing the progress and outcomes of a project to ensure effectiveness and guide improvements
the subsequent benefits and impacts that result from the utilization of outputs, often at the organizational or community level
the long-term, sustainable impacts of a project on the well-being of the target population
ensures that potential users can see the results in practice
the processes of tracking performance and assessing the outcomes of a model to inform decision-making
the achievement of intended outcomes and goals through the implementation of a model
monitoring the effects of introducing the new model and making adjustments if the results differ from what was intended
assesses how, why, for whom, and under what conditions changing actions influence impacts within a dynamic system.
process of evaluating the effectiveness of the concept through specific indicators and data collection
evaluations are systematic processes to determine the effectiveness, impact, and sustainability of interventions. They involve assessing processes, outcomes, and contexts to inform decision-making and improve future implementations
an adaptive evaluation is an approach that combines elements of realist and developmental evaluations, focusing on understanding the context, supporting innovation, and facilitating scaling. It emphasizes continuous learning, adaptation, and the use of various techniques depending on the complexity of the task
an overall theory of change outlines the pathways through which an intervention is expected to lead to the desired outcomes. It includes assumptions, intermediate steps, and the relationships between different components of the intervention
hypothesis testing involves systematically evaluating specific predictions about the outcomes of an intervention. This process helps determine whether the intervention is having the expected effects and informs adjustments
data assessment is the process of collecting, analyzing, and interpreting data to evaluate the effectiveness of an intervention. It includes identifying relevant data sources, ensuring data quality, and using data to inform decision-making
the process of critically analyzing the outcomes and processes of an intervention to understand what worked, what didn’t, and why. It informs future decisions and adjustments to improve the intervention
Framework: