1968 Darrel Dugan   

2nd Team Offensive Tackle

1974 David Hartley 

3rd Team Defensive Tackle

1975 Mike Echstenkamper

2nd Team Cornerback

1977 Greg Holbert             

2nd Team End

1977 Kevin Meade              

3rd Team Quarterback

1978 Jeff McClelland           

1st Team Defensive Back

1979 Jay Faires                  

2nd Team Center

1980 Gene Campbell         

1st Team Running Back

1980 Mike Roback              

1st Team Quarterback

1980 Scott Holbert       

1st Team End

1980 Larry Dixon               

3rd Team Nose Guard 

1980 Ed Bolin                

Coach of the Year   

1981 Scott Holbert              

1st Team End            

Lineman of the Year

1981 Bruce Fouts                

3rd Team Running Back

1982 Mark Echstenkamper 

2nd Team Quarterback

1983 Scott Russell             

3rd Team Defensive Line

1984 Danny Lackey             

1st Team Linebacker

1989 Brent Swaro                

1st Team Offensive Line

1989 Todd Fouts                

2nd Team Linebacker

1989 Jerry Pastol               

2nd Team Defensive Line

1990 Roger Bingman          

1st Team Quarterback

1991 Reuben Kittle             

1st Team End

1992 Reuben Kittle             

1st Team End

1992 Tom Hardy                  

1st Team Defensive End

1993 Rusty Richards           

1st Team Quarterback

1993 Josh McClelland       

2nd Team Linebacker

1994 Joe Wright                  

1st Team Defensive End

1994 Josh McClelland       

2nd Team Linebacker

1995 Joe Wright                  

1st Team Linebacker

1997 Brady Trace                 

1st Team Linebacker

1997 Josh Limo                    

2nd Team End

1998 Brady Trace               

1st Team Linebacker

1999 Phillip Faires              

1st Team End

2001 Kyle Andrews            

1st Team Linebacker

2003 A.J. Jenkins                

1st Team Quarterback

2004 Robby Jenkins          

1st Team Running Back

2004 Bruce Fouts              

1st Team Linebacker

2004 Mike Harper            

2nd Team Offensive Line

2005 Mark Christman        

1st Team Linebacker

2005 Anthony Dixon       

2nd Team Quarterback

2006 Mark Christman     

2nd Team Linebacker

2007 Charles Faires           

1st Team Offensive Line

2008 Tyler Dyla                 

1st Team Running Back

2009 Tyler Dyla                 

1st Team Running Back

2010 Tyler Dyla                   

1st Team Running Back

2012 Konner Standley 

1st Team Quarterback

2012 Jacob Koons                

1st Team Linebacker

2012 Casey Degarmore      

1st Team Defensive Line

2013 Konner Standley        

1st Team Quarterback

Offensive Player of the Year

2013 Jacob Koons               

1st Team Linebacker

Defensive Player of the Year

2013 Austin Downs             

1st Team End

2013 Jon Stevens                 

1st Team Defensive Line

2014 Austin Downs             

1st Team End          

Offensive Player of the Year

2014 Tanner Koons             

1st Team Defensive Line

2014 Justice Jenkins         

2nd Team Running Back

2014 Terry Simerly           

2nd Team Linebacker

2014 Micah Couch             

3rd Team Offensive Line

2015 Justice Jenkins            

1st Team Running Back

2015 Andrew Losey           

3rd Team Quarterback

2016 Jacob Hardy               

1st Team End

2016 Nathan Downs           

1st Team Linebacker

2016 Kamron Curry 

3rd Team Running Back

2017 Cameron Kittle         

3rd Team Quarterback

2017 Max Hooper               

3rd Team Running Back

2018 Sawyer Koons            

1st Team Linebacker

Defensive Player of the Year

2018 Conner Wright          

1st Team Running Back

2018 Alex Coffman             

1st Team Offensive Line

2018 Cameron Kittle          

3rd Team Quarterback

2019 Sawyer Koons            

1st Team Linebacker

Defensive Player of the Year

2019 Conner Wright           

1st Team Running Back

2019 Ian Joyce                     

1st Team Defensive End

2019 Cameron Kittle        

2nd Team Quarterback

2020 Tabor Lackey             

1st Team Quarterback

2020 Blake Guffey             

1st Team Linebacker 

2020 Bryce Downs                 

3rd Team Running Back

2020 Ian Spencer                   

3rd Team Offensive Line

2021 Tabor Lackey                 

1st Team Quarterback

2021 Blake Guffey                 

1st Team Linebacker

2021 Bryce Downs                

3rd Team Running Back

2021 Conner Wooten          

3rd Team Offensive Line

2023 Xavier Cunningham   

3rd Team Running Back