What are the key sustainability values of this type of textile?
Material description: Fish leather can be made from the skins of a wide variety of marine and freshwater species: tuna, shark, salmon, carp, stingray, cod, sea wolf, sturgeon, and even tilapia and catfish. It usually has a scaly structure and is often prized for its interesting texture. Fish skins are usually smaller and thinner than calfskin, requiring fewer chemicals and less energy to tan. But it may be relatively stronger due to the crisscrossing structure of the fibers in fish skin that make it more elastic and tear-resistant than cowhide. Fish leather has a long but poorly recorded history, largely because it was associated with poverty. Indigenous people in northern latitudes all around the world have used fish leather for a variety of purposes, including coats, mittens, and clothing. Medieval Icelanders, who had access to a lot more fish than livestock, made boots from fish skin. (Currently, Nordic shoe company Woden makes a salmon skin sneaker.) Fish leather continued to be common until the Industrial Revolution led to greater assimilation of Indigenous peoples and the proliferation of cheaper leather goods.
Production process: Traditionally manufactured by indigenous communities in Nordic countries and elsewhere, this type of producing leather from fish skin is accessible as it can be achieved at micro and macro-level - from one's private kitchen, to the industrial level. Fish leather will appear different depending on what fish is used to make it and each species will have its own distinct pattern. Common fish like salmon, perch, tilapia, carp, and cod will have a scaly surface while fish like catfish, sharks, and stingray are smooth. Some species, like salmon and eels, will always have a distinct “scar” lie through the pattern. Despite this they share some characteristics like a scaly or pore like structure and it is relatively elastic compared to other leather. Fish skin goes through the following steps of manufacturing: scraping, tanning and softnening.
Fish skin in Romania: Although this practice is not historically connected to the leather industry in Romania, which relies heavily on cow leather, its potential and importance has been increased in the past few years by the niche adoption by small Romanian start-ups and designers experimenting with new ways of being sustainable. In particular the salmon and sturgeon skin leather have been valorised here. For example, a Romanian start-up company is using organic and synthetic tanning methods, without any toxic chrome compounds, to produce eco friendly and sustainable salmon skin leather. Also the potential of sturgeo skin leather has been positively assessed by researchers from the Romanian Leather and Footwear Research institute, stressing its high value for the luxury market. Tests with sturgeon skins were performed with fish from farms from Tulcea. Due to the high variety of fish species in Romania (both salt and sweet water fish), this would represent a huge potential for the sustainable leather industry.
Key values for sustainable fish skin leather in Romania:
1. Long term ecological impact through recycling of fish waste: As an alternative to animal leather, fish skin leather is more sustainable as it deals with the waste amunt generated by fishing industries. For example, fish skin comprise about 30% of the total fish weight available after fish fillet is extracted, which represents an important impact upon the ecosystem when dumped back to the water. Moreover, research shows that in the Tulcea area in Romania, the impact of fish canneries on soil, water and air is not neglectable, deriving mainly from the wastewater resulting from the manufacture of canned fish. This comes mainly from:
- After unloading the fish, the storage compartments are washed, resulting large amounts of wastewater with ice, salt, blood, protein substances, etc.;
- During the operation of removing the scales, large amounts of water are consumed, resulting wastewater with high content of scales, fragments of fish skin, fins, etc.;
- In the section on cutting and cleaning the fish, the water is highly contaminated with fragments of fish meat, fats, and blood with rapid tendency to ferment and putrefaction;
- In the process of washing and degreasing the tin cans and sterilizing the finished product, the result is water containing fish remains fats, detergent, and used sauces. Studies reveal the special potential of the fish processing industry in Romania and the need for superior recovery of waste preparation.
2. Research and industry collaborations: Fish leather is created using natural tanning and dyeing methods, which makes it a much more environmentally friendly option, with a much lower carbon footprint. The organic tanning available solutions are extracted from mimosa, acacia, tara or oak quebracho. Moreover, a specific type of collagen was developed from fish skin coming from grey mullet fish in the Black Sea, which is used as an important component of bio-materials, as well as for the treatment of degraded soils (agriculture).
3. Unique structural properties: Fish leather tends to be strong due its unique cross-fiber structure (with a tensile strength of 90 Netwons, which is 10times stronger than calf leather) and also water-resistant. The fibres criss-cross and it makes more durable leather for products that have to be strong. Fish skins are usually smaller and thinner than calfskin, requiring fewer chemicals and less energy to tan. Therefore, leather from fish skin is more breathable, thinner and stronger than lamb and cow leather.
4. Economic sustainability for local communities and local culture: fish skin leather can be an important source of income, especially for those rural and small communities where fishing is a long tradition. In Romania, this is the case of the Dobrogea area, close to the Black Sea, which is rich in sweet and salt water fish and where the fishing tradition has a long history. Adding important economic return through fish ski leather for these rural communities which rely on fishing is an important factor in keeping traditions alive and preserving the authenticity of the place.
Which threats does this type of textile innovation mitigate?
1. Water and soil pollution: Fish skin leather eases pressure on the ecosystem by providing an alternative to cow leather. Today, the leather industry is one of the most polluting segments of the fashion industry, with 65% of pollution due to cattle leather, 15% to sheep leather, 11% to pig leather and 9% to goat leather. Leather production not only requires a significant amount of water, but it also pollutes natural waterways. Polluted water dumped out of tanneries and slaughterhouses and which runs off farms and feedlots, can lead to environmental pollution and eutrophication. Tannery waste contains large amounts of pollutants, such as salt, lime sludge, sulfides, and acids. A report supported by the European Commission found that tanning 1kg of leather uses up to 2.5kg of chemical substances and up to 250 liters of water, and generates up to 6.1kg of solid waste.
2. Loss of traditional heritage: The leather industry in Romania is considered a traditional industry. Howver, after 1989, the industry entered a rapid decline. Although today there are still some major players on the Romanian leather market, competition from countries like Turkey, India, China and Mexico is rapidly increasing, putting pressure on the local market and calling for innovative solutions. In parallel, young designers and fashion professionals with an interest in sustainable and innovative practices, look more and more towads alternative materials such as bio-materials and highly engineered solutions.
3. Loss of biodiversity: Some fish species are highly invasive, such as for example the lion-fish which kills 79% of baby reef fish. Fishing for example 1 lionfish saves 70000 reef fish contributing to maintaining the biodiversity of seas and oceans.Thus fish leather helps to maintain biodiversity and contributes to a more circular economy.
How can we conceptualise this type of textile innovation?
Fish skin leather falls within the category of 'localised production', but also within the category of 'technological breakthrough'. In terms of localised production, fish skin leather represents an important local resource, derived from the extensive fishing and fishery activity in Romania. currently, there are over 100 fish species in Romania (salt and sweet water), of which around 50 are protected. Romania ensures around 30% of its fish consumption, with over 20.000 tonnes of produced fish. In terms of fish waste, if we consider that 30% of a fish is represented by waste and 15% would be the skin, there are over 3.000 tonnes of waste available to be transformed into fish skin leather. In terms of technological breakthroughs, fish skin leather is connected to advanced processing methods for collagen, but also to sustainable methods for tanning. These technological breakthroughs render fish skin leather an advanced and resistent technological product.
What data categories and indicators can we use to map the sustainability of this innovation?
The key environmental indicators for fish skin leather are:
RAW MATERIALS:
Waste reduction: there are over 6 million tonnes of by-products/waste generated by the global fishery industry, a third of which represented by fish skin, which could be cut through the production of fish skin leather
Maintaining biodiversity: There are fish species which harm the biodiversity chain. For example the lionfish kills 79% of baby reef fish. Therefore, using 1 lionsfish for fish leather can save up to 70000 reef fish.
PROCESSING:
Carbon footprint: the tranformation of fish skin leather generates 0 kg CO2/m2 during tanning processes.
Chemical treatment/waste: during tanning, 1.2 t Chromium waste is produced The global leather market generates 4-6.000 tonnes of Chromium. If we consider that 1% of total animal leather is fish leather and that 20%-40% of Chromium is disposed as waste during Tanning, 1.2 t of Chromium waste is still produced by the fish skin leather industry, which puts a strain on the environment. Vegetal tanning instead produces 0 waste, but is still not mainstream. The degreasing process happening at 35-40 degrees uses petroleum which is also harming for the environment,
POST-PROCESSING:
Local sourcing of fish skin for leather production is very sustainable as it generates low CO2.
In addition, stoarge requirements are better than for other types of leather, as samples are much smaller than for example for other animal leather.
RECYCLING:
Fish skin leather is vegan and bio-degradable yet it can still release chemicals in the environment from tanning.
The key economic indicators for fish skin leather are:
Exclusive luxury segment: Fish skin costs up to twice as much as animal leather, making it expensive.
Social indicators:
Business ethics: is to a certain extent ethical due to controlled fishin practices. However, public lealth is questionned if chemical tanning is used, as it can put a strain of local and rural communities intensifying this practice.
Conservation of traditions: For rural communities, fish skin can preserve local traditions and culture. It can become also an important income source for small communities. However, this practice can have a low resilience to exploitation (some fish types could become endangered if overfishing is practiced).
Fair trade: some fair trade labels exist on the market. Most brands are young, innovative and transparent, keeping a medium to high levle of transparency of business activities.
How do the indicators relate to fashion production management processes?
For fish skin leather, these indicators help manage:
Material Sourcing: Ensuring the sustainable sourcing of leather from fish skin directly from nature.
Environmental pressures: Ensuring a highly sustainable practice and the reduction of waste if natural tanning and ethical sourcing are practiced.
How can we measure sustainability of this textile innovation?
Sustainability of fish leather can be measured at the level of ecology through the impact of sourcing, pre-tanning and tanning processes; at the level of economic impact through the benefit generated to the subsistance of small/rural communities of fishermen and the preservation of local culture and authenticity; at a social level through more equitable practices in dealing with poverty, as well as more fair and equal chances for rural communities for decent pay.
How were the thresholds for each indicator measured?
Indicators were calculated based on the following studies of fish skin leather:
Elsacker E, Vandelook S, Peeters E. Recent technological innovations in mycelium materials as leather substitutes: a patent review. Front Bioeng Biotechnol. 2023 Aug 7;11:1204861. doi: 10.3389/fbioe.2023.1204861. PMID: 37609120; PMCID: PMC10441217.
Zengin, A. C. A., Basaran, B., Karavana, H. A., & Mete, M. (2015, November). Fish skins: valuable resources for leather industry. In IULTCS Congress.
GAIDAU, C., MAEREANU, M., FOIASI, T., ZENGIN, C. A., KARAVANA, H. A., MUTLU, M. M., ... & BASARAN, B. (2013). Sturgeon Skins—A Valuable Resource for Luxury Leather Industry. Revista de Pielarie Incaltaminte, 13(4), 311.
Cherim, M., Sirbu, R., Tomescu, A., Popa, M. F., & Cadar, E. (2019). Comparative studies on the physico-chemical characteristics of bio-materials with collagen from calf and fish skins from Black Sea. Mater. Plast, 56(179), 10-37358.
Zainescu, G., Albu, L., Deselnicu, D., Constantinescu, R. R., Vasilescu, A. M., Nichita, P., & Sirbu, C. (2014). A new concept of complex valorization of leather wastes. Materiale plastice, 51(1), 90-93.
PLAVAN, V., KOLIADA, M., CHEN, W., & BARSUKOV, V. (2014, October). Extraction of collagen from fish waste and determination of its amino acid composition. In Proceedings of the 4th International conference on advanced materials and systems,(Bucharest, Romania, 23th-25th Oct. 2014)/National R&D Institute for Textile & Leather, Division Leather& Footwear Research Institute. Bucharest: ICPI (pp. 267-272).
GACEU, L., GRUIA, R., & OPREA, O. (2021). PRELIMINARY STUDY ON THE CURRENT STATE OF THE MARINE BIOMASS PROCESSING INDUSTRY IN ROMANIA. Journal of EcoAgriTourism, 17(2).
Radulescu, V. (2023). Environmental Impact Assessment Of Fish And Meat Canneries. Sofia: Surveying Geology & Mining Ecology Management (SGEM). doi:https://doi.org/10.5593/sgem2023/5.1/s20.15
Environmental indicators
Waste: 4/5
Biodiversity: 3.5/5.
Carbon footprint (for processing): 5/5
Chemical treatment (for processing): 1/5
Vegan tanning: 5/5
Degreasing: 1/5
Energy impact on storage/distribution: 3.5/5
Carbon footprint (distribution): 5/5
Biodegradability: 5/5
Price effectiveness: 1/5
Business ethics: 3/5
Cultural ethics: 4/5
Fair trade: 4/5
Cultural conservation: 5/5
Local impact: 5/5
Exposure to exploitation: 5/5
Medium-high label transparency: 4/5
FINAL SCORE: 4.2
Case studies: In Romania, the use of fish skin leather is only emerging, with some companies experimenting with technological processes for the processing of the leather. Other designers use fish skin such as salmon to create accessories. However, the best known cases of the use of fish skin leaher comes from the North and extra-European context:
1. South America: Piraccucu - Unlike most fish used for leather, pirarucu can provide skins as large as cow hides. The largest freshwater fish in the world, pirarucu is from the Amazon Basin and routinely reaches up to two meters in length and 100 kg in weight but can be much larger. It has been subject to commercial fishing for half a century, but in the last two decades, Brazil has adopted a more sustainable management program for pirarucu fisheries. Local communities are now involved in managing and monitoring their resources. The skins, once a discarded waste product, are now tanned domestically and exported. Companies like Piper & Skye and numerous artisans on Etsy manufacture them into luxury leather products.
2. Fishskinlab initiative, centralising resources about fish skin leather and its transformation. It hosts a collection of projects, info about institutions from North-European Countries and beyond, as well as on conferences related to the topic. The initiative was developed by the researcher Elisa Palomino from Smithsonian National Museum (https://www.fishskinlab.com).
Below are some interesting stories offish skin production at a worldwide level.