In this exploration I will compare three color pencil brands, Croyola, Winsor and Newton, and Prismacolor. I will try the different colors on different papers along experimenting with different ways of Markmaking. I will close this exploration by drawing a step by step portrait at the end. So follow along to find the best Pencils!
• Pink eraser (Pink Pearl–type): $1–$3
• Pencil sharpener (manual): $2–$8
• Blending stump / tortillon (single or small set): $1–$6
• Strathmore pastel sheets (pad, 9×12): $6–$12
• Canson sketching notebook (9×12, 100 sheets): $7–$12
• Prismacolor pencils (individual): $1.75–$3 each
• Crayola colored pencils, 12-pack: $2–$6
• Winsor & Newton colored pencils, 24-set: $20–$30
I tried using the color pencils at different pressures and layers, overlaying some colors to make new colors and test blending possibilites. I also tried hatching and cross hatching the colors to get a more impressionistic result.
Pressure levels
Colors are nicely pigmented and different levels of value can be achived depending on the pressure and speed you apply.
Hatching
This technique is great for texturing and optical color mixing effect.
sphere Blending
Blending and layering in circular motions across analogous color scheme.
The unboxing
These colors come in a 24 pencil set.The colors range is nice and they are highly pigmented.
Pressure and Value
Colors are nicely pigments but a little rough and hard to use on the sketching paper
Layering
The colors don't blend as nicely. Notice the orange on the pink barely shows any sign of layering and the ochre doesn't blend with yellow or orange much either.
The soft tip of the pencil was cracked a little bit when pushed to much.
Highly pigmented and soft on the paper without too much pressure.
Colors smudge nicely both with stump and finger.
The colors blend seamlessly without showing line strokes.
To sum up the strengths and weakness of each brand, Croyala color pencils provide the best value for the money and are the most affordable for the classroom and while they blend and layer nicely they simply aren't as pigmented as Prismacolor. The Downside of Prismacolor is that because it is so soft and blends nicely, it also runs out too fast and sometimes it breaks in the sharpener.The winsor and Newton is honestly not that great either compared to Croyola and not worth the price in my opinion.
A great Drawing Idea with prismacolor pencils that blend well with each other is to draw portraits with limited colors. I used mostly greens and pinks for this drawing, playing with the warm and cool transitions.
Step01: choose a refrence and sketch it on your paper. for this drawing I used the Pastel paper because it has nice textures. and comes in different colors.
Step02: add flat colors for the base of your drawing.
Step03: add fine details, pushing the darks and bringing the lights forward.
Step04: refine the hair shape and texture and add final touches. some areas with too much contrast can be blended and unified by adding a white overlay.
Overall, I would say that color pencils are a fundemental medium appropriate and safe for use by all ages depending on the assignment. I think that color pencils have their own merits which is that they are neat and precise and not as messy as fluid paint. However, they might not be the best and most fun medium to teach art to younger kids with because of the required motor skills and slow and a limited application time. I think they are a necessary tool for the art room and need to be accessible to all as they are great tools for adding detail to larger artworks. I personally think that I am quite good at using them but I usually work with medias that cover large areas faster and then go to add detail with color pencils. They are a great combination when used with markers and soft pastels.