Why I'm Not a Christian
Why I'm An Agnostic Christian
Why I'm An Agnostic Christian
11/21/2025 1431 v1.00
Why I'm Not a Christian
Why I'm An Agnostic Christian
“Where can I go from your presence? Or where can I flee from your spirit? If I ascend to the heavens, you are there. If I make my bed in the depths of Sheol, you are there.
If I take the wings of the morning and settle at the farthest limits of the sea, even there your hand shall guide me, and your right hand shall hold me fast.”
This poem, in its entirety, is given by the NRSV the title, “The Inescapable God.” It's a message of bold reassurance to the believer, reminding them that since God is present everywhere—pervading every inch of our universe—He is, in the happiest sense possible, inescapable.
But my first argument, and it’s going to be the first of three, against the viability of theism flows from the demonstrable fact that this divine consolation is seemingly not offered universally, and often, in fact, restricted from those who want it the most.
I’m going to be making the claim specifically that atheism or naturalism provides a better account for three facts of our universe:
The hiddenness of God.
The geographical-statistical arrangement, shall we say, of religious belief.
The problem of gratuitous suffering.
And we'll see if we get time to finish it off.
Far from being unable to escape God, there is a very real contingent of non-believers—and I would count myself among their number—who are unable by any means to discover Him; who seek and do not find; who knock and receive, as it were, no answer.
This strange phenomenon is known as the problem of divine hiddenness.
If there is a God, then simply, why is He hidden from so many of us, so much of the time?
If theism is to offer a sufficient account of reality, then it must offer an account of what J. L. Schellenberg has famously labeled non-resistant non-belief, which he distinguishes from resistant non-belief.
It's sometimes said by a theist who wishes to explain the problem of divine hiddenness that people simply disbelieve through their own fault. They're too stubborn.
They're purposefully blinding themselves to the evidence because they don't want it to be true. They’re not approaching the arguments honestly, with an open heart.
And that if they would only do this, then God would surely reveal Himself.
Such a person would be what Schellenberg calls a resistant non-believer. He disbelieves, in some sense, because he actively resists it.
For what it's worth, I do think that such people exist. I think many such people exist.
There are people who come to this debate with their minds already made up.
There are people who want it not to be true that God exists and, in fact, wouldn't submit to that truth even if it were true. There was a recent poll run by the Atheist Experience YouTube channel—which I know Jonathan, you're a fan of—which asked, "If there was a God, would you worship it?" To which an astonishing 85% of respondents said that they would not.
There are, however, also people who disbelieve in God, not out of resistance or stubbornness or a hardened heart, but rather due to sheer lack of conviction.
Indeed, many such people actively want to be convinced of God's existence and would jump at the chance of entering into a relationship with Him if they thought that He did exist.
But no matter how hard they search, they simply find no answer forthcoming from the heavens. And this is the non-resistant non-believer.
Formally then, Schellenberg's problem of divine hiddenness can be stated as follows:
Premise 1: If there is a God, He is perfectly loving. (Something I'm pretty sure Jonathan agrees with.)
Premise 2: If a perfectly loving God exists, non-resistant non-belief does not occur.
Premise 3: Non-resistant non-belief does occur.
4. Therefore: No perfectly loving God exists.
And the conclusion from the first premise is that therefore there is no God.
A loving God, like the Christian God, would surely not refuse any willing person from developing a relationship with Him.
And so, if somebody is truly non-resistant and open to receiving God's grace, we should expect them to receive it.
Thus, Schellenberg's assertion that if God exists,
then non-resistant non-belief does not exist.
The question then is, is there such a thing as a non-resistant non-believer?
To which all I can really say is, "Nice to meet you."
The last time I debated Jonathan, a number of years ago, when I was just a few months out of being a teenager, I said that even if I found Christianity to be true, I still wouldn't want to worship the God that it promotes.
I have since then realized how irrational and self-defeating this assertion is and stand before you today as an example of a non-resistant non-believer.
I think it would be great if God existed. I really do. I would absolutely love to escape death. I would relish being the recipient of unconditional love.
Less selfishly, I would love to be able to worship that which deserves to be worshipped. I just don't think it's true. Now, try as I might, look where I can, I find no response, no hint, nothing. I don't choose to disbelieve in God anymore than I choose to disbelieve in aliens, despite how much I might want them to.
So, when faced with a psalm like Psalm 139, I'm overwhelmed with a sense not of beauty and consolation, but envy and disappointment.
“Where can I go from your spirit? Where can I flee from your presence?”
Where can I go, I should ask in response, to find it?
Of course, you cannot know my heart. You can't know if I'm truly as non-resistant as I claim. But I hope that my actions here might betray me. As a Catholic child, I was once an altar boy. I would serve the altar of Mother Church every Sunday dressed in a white robe. In the time since then, I have, to put it mildly, been looking for God.
I went to Catholic schools. I studied philosophy and theology at A-Levels. I made a career out of engaging with religious arguments. I have explored arguments from contingency, from fine-tuning, from motion, from mathematics, from, indeed, from irreducible complexity and the alleged resurrection of Jesus of Nazareth.
It may surprise my followers online to learn that at university I visited numerous churches on the invitation of various friends. I spent hours talking with religious friends until the sun rose again, if you like. I attended Bible groups regularly, too, which might surprise people as well, and in fact, I still do attend such groups.
Just recently, I agreed to embark on a series of study of the wisdom literature, specifically reading it again in the hopes that this time I might finally feel a divine presence seeping from between the lines.
I moved into a house for a year with two devoutly Christian housemates with the express intention of seeing if the obvious truth of Christianity and theism that people like to talk about can be found in the minutia of daily life.
I have looked, in other words, in a great deal of places. I read Athanasius and Anselm.
I read Augustine and Aquinas. I looked in Julian of Norwich and Catherine of Siena.
I looked at the sociological origin of religious belief in Durkheim and Marx and Freud and Jung.
I looked at religious experience in William James and Rudolph Otto. I've looked in the modern works of people like Ed Feser and Bill Craig and Michael Murray and Richard Swinburne and Alvin Plantinga. I have looked in poetry. I've looked in the Psalms.
I've looked in Job. I've looked in Ecclesiastes. I've looked in Dostoyevsky. I read C. S. Lewis.
I listened to worship music. I prayed. I studied the Gospel.
I even got an actual degree in theology from a university.
And nothing. Nothing. Not once. Not nearly. Not ever. Not even briefly, have I experienced anything that speaks to the existence of a God in the universe.
I think it's asking a lot of any atheist to seriously engage with a religion that he does not believe is true in any circumstances. But I feel like I have gone above and beyond what can be reasonably expected of any atheist who wishes to entertain the God hypothesis.
And for my efforts, I have been awarded radio silence. The "inescapable God" of the NRSV, in other words, is for me the invisible God or the inapproachable God, the deaf, distant God.
The best account that I can give of this experience of complete and utter silence from a deaf heaven is that all that truly exists is impersonal space and air and rocks—and nothing more. I know. I know it sucks. I'm sorry. It's a shame, but there's no need to cry about it.
My question to Jonathan then is simple: How can theism account for this lived experience? How can it account, in other words, for non-resistant non-belief?
And doesn't atheism offer a better explanation at the very least?
Am I a non-resistant non-believer? If so, what offers a better account of such a condition?
A universe in which there is a loving God who does want to be my friend, but is for some reason refusing or hiding or toying with me? Or a universe without one?
Or is there no such thing as a non-resistant non-believer, which is the only remaining option? Do we all secretly resist in some way or other?
After desperately trying to convince myself of God's existence for years and being left painfully unconvinced, will you just submit, as if to add insult to this spiritual injury, that this is in some way my fault? And if it is, then what could I have done differently?
What should I be doing differently? What could I possibly have done differently given the course of my...
Where can I go from your presence? Or
where can I flee from your spirit? If I
ascend to the heavens, you are there. If
I make my bed in the depths of the
shiel, you are there. If I take the
wings of the morning and settle at the
farthest limits of the sea, even there
your hand shall guide me and your right
hand shall hold me fast. This poem in
its entirety is given by the NRSV a
title, the inescapable God. It's a
message of bold reassurance to the
believer, reminding them that since God
is present everywhere, pervading every
inch of our universe, he is in the
happiest sense possible inescapable. But
my first argument, and it's going to be
the first of three,
uh against the viability of theism flows
from the demonstrable fact that this
divine consolation is seemingly not
offered universally and often, in fact,
restricted from those who want it the
most. I'm going to be making the claim
specifically that atheism or naturalism
provides a better account for three
facts of our universe. The first being
the hiddenness of God. The second being
the geographical uh statistical uh
uh arrangement, shall we say, of
religious belief. And the third will be
the problem of gratuitous suffering. And
we'll see if we get time to finish it
off.
Far from being unable to escape God,
there is a very real contingent of
non-believers. And I would count myself
among their number who are unable by any
means to discover him who seek and do
not find who knock and receive as it
were no answer. This strange phenomenon
is known as the problem of divine
hiddenness. If there is a god then
simply why is he hidden from so many of
us so much of the time? If theism is to
offer a sufficient account of reality,
then it must offer an account of what JL
Shelonberg has famously labeled
non-resistant non-belief, which he
distinguishes from resistant non-belief.
It's sometimes said by a theist who
wishes to explain uh the problem of
divine hiddenness that people simply
disbelieve through their own fault.
They're too stubborn. They're
purposefully blinding themselves to the
evidence because they don't want it to
be true. They're not approaching the
arguments on uh honestly with an open
heart. and that if they would only do
this, then God would surely reveal
himself. Such a person would be what
Shelonburgg calls a resistant
non-believer. He disbelieves in some
sense because he actively resists it.
For what it's worth, I do think that
such people exist. I think many such
people exist. Uh there are people who
come to this debate with their minds
already made up. There are people who
want it not to be true that God exists
and in fact wouldn't submit to that
truth even if it were true. There was a
recent poll run by the Atheist
Experience YouTube channel, which I know
Jonathan you're a fan of, uh, which
asked, "If there was a God, would you
worship it?" To which an astonishing 85%
of respondents said that they would not.
There are, however, also people who
disbelieve in God, not out of resistance
or stubbornness or a hardened heart, but
rather due to sheer lack of conviction.
Indeed, many such people actively want
to be convinced of God's existence and
would jump at the chance of entering
into a relationship with him if they
thought that he did. But no matter how
hard they search, they simply find no
answer forthcoming from the heavens. And
this is the non-resistant
non-believer. Formally then,
Shelonberg's problem of divine
hiddenness can be stated as follows.
Premise one, if there is a God, he is
perfectly loving. Something I'm pretty
sure Jonathan agrees with. Premise two,
if a perfectly loving God exists,
non-resistant non-belief does not occur.
Premise three, non-resistant non-belief
does occur. Four, therefore, no
perfectly loving God exists. And the
conclusion from the first premise is
that therefore there is no God. A loving
God like the Christian God would surely
not refute any willing person from
developing a relationship with him. And
so if somebody is truly non-resistant
and open to receiving God's grace, we
should expect them to receive it. Thus
Shelonburg's assertion that if God
exists, then non-resistant non-belief
does not exist. The question then is, is
there such a thing as non-resistant
non-belief? A non-resistant
non-believer. To which all I can really
say is nice to meet you. The last time I
debated Jonathan a number of years ago
when I was just a few months out of
being a teenager, I said that even if I
thought even if I found Christianity to
be true, I still wouldn't want to
worship the God uh that it promotes. I
now since then have realized how
irrational and self-defeating this
assertion is and stand before you today
as an example of a non-resistant
non-believer. I think it would be great
if God existed. I really do. I would I
would absolutely love to escape death. I
would relish being the recipient of
unconditional love. Less selfishly, I
would love to be able to worship that
which deserves to be woripped. I just
don't think it's true. Now, try as I
might, look where I can, I find no
response, no hint, nothing. I don't
choose to disbelieve in God anymore than
I choose to disbelieve in aliens,
despite how much I might want them to.
So when faced with a psalm like Psalm
139, I'm overwhelmed with a sense not of
beauty and consolation, but envy and
disappointment.
Where can I go from your spirit? Where
can I flee from your presence? Where can
I go? I should ask in response to find
it. Of course, you cannot know my heart.
You can't know if I'm truly as
non-resistant as I claim. But I hope
that my actions here might betray me. Uh
as as a Catholic child, I was once an an
alter boy. I would serve the altar of
mother church every Sunday dressed in a
white robe. Um in the time since then I
have to put it mildly been looking for
God. I went to Catholic schools. I
studied philosophy and theology at A
levels. I made a career out of engaging
with religious arguments. I have
explored arguments from contingency,
from fine-tuning, from motion, from
mathematics, from indeed from uh
irreducible complexity and the alleged
resurrection of Jesus of Nazareth. It
may surprise my followers online to
learn uh that at university I visited
numerous churches on the invitation of
various friends. I spent hours talking
with religious friends until the sun
rose again, if you like. I spent I
attended Bible groups regularly, too,
which might surprise people.
uh as well and in fact I I still do
attend such groups. Just recently I
agreed to embark on a series of study of
the wisdom literature specifically
reading it again in the hopes that this
time I might finally feel a divine
presence seeping from between the lines.
I moved into a house for a year with two
devoutly Christian housemates with the
express intention of seeing if the
obvious truth of Christianity and theism
that people like to talk about can be
found in the minutia of daily life.
I have looked in other words in a great
deal of places. I read Athanasius and
Anelm. I read Augustine and Aquinus. I I
looked in Julian of Norwich and
Catherine of Sienna. I looked at the
sociological origin of religious belief
in Durkheim and Marx and Freud and
Young. I looked at religious experience
in William James and Rudolph Otto. I've
looked in the modern works of people
like Ed Faser and Bill Craig and Michael
Murray and Richard Swinburn and Alvin
Plantinger. I have looked in poetry.
I've looked in the Psalms. I've looked
in Job. I've looked in Ecclesiastes.
I've looked in dsttoyki. I read CS
Lewis. I listened to worship music. I
prayed. I studied the gospel. I even got
an actual degree in theology from a
university. And nothing, nothing, not
once, not nearly, not ever, not even
briefly, have I experienced anything
that speaks to the existence of a god in
the universe.
I think it's asking a lot of any atheist
to seriously engage with a religion that
he does not believe is true in any
circumstances. But I feel like I have
gone above and beyond what can be
reasonably expected of any atheist who
wishes to entertain the God hypothesis.
And for my efforts, I have been awarded
radio silence. The inescapable god of
the NRSV, in other words, is for me the
invisible god or the inapproachable god,
the deaf distant god. The best account
that I can give of this experience of
complete and utter silence from death
heaven is that all that truly exists me
is impersonal space and air and rocks. I
know. I know it sucks. I'm sorry. It's
it's it's a shame, but there's no need
to cry about it
and nothing more. My question to
Jonathan then is simple. How can theism
account for this lived experience? How
can it account in other words for
non-resistant nonbelief?
And if atheism and doesn't atheism offer
a better explanation at the very least,
am I a non-resistant non-believer? If
so, what offers a best account or a
better account of such a condition? A
universe in which there is a loving God
who does want to be my friend, but is
for some reason refusing or hiding or
toying with me? Or a universe without
one? Or is there no such thing as a
non-resistant non-believer, which is the
only remaining option? Do we all
secretly resist in some way or other?
After desperately, in other words,
trying to convince myself of God's
existence for years and being left
painfully unconvinced, will you just
submit as if to add insult to this
spiritual injury that this is in some
way my fault? And if it is, then what
could I have done differently? What
should I be doing differently? What
could I possibly have done differently
given the course of my