2022 Season

Garrett's skill was unknown coming into 2022. He missed Week 1 and started off Week 2 with a 10-0 mercy rule over Carston. Garrett had a great year offensively, scoring the most runs in the league. He struggled to get it going some games though. That led to him finishing 3-4 and 5th in the league. He avenged his Week 3 loss to Wilson in the first round in the playoffs. He then beat undefeated Andrew, however rules at the time were that the semifinal would be best of 3. Garrett then dropped the next 2 games 0-1.

Schedule

W 10-0 vs. Carston (3 innings)

L 0-1 vs. Jacob

L 0-1 vs. Andrew (8 innings)

W 6-0 vs. Keith

W 5-2 vs. Will

L 2-3 vs. Joe (6 innings)

L 0-2 vs. Wilson

W 4-2 vs. 4. Wilson (Quarterfinals)

W 1-0 vs. 1. Andrew (Semifinals Game 1)

L 0-1 vs. 1. Andrew (Semifinals Game 2) (9 innings)

L 0-1 vs. 1. Andrew (Semifinals Game 3)

Roster:

King K Rool, Brown Kritter, Blue Kritter, Mario, Red Pianta, Yellow Pianta, Purple Toad, Toad, Green Shy Guy

No poll rankings in 2022. Final Place: 3rd

2023 Season

Garrett looked to keep up his solid run in 2022. Garrett's team was arguably worse in 2023, but his performance was better. He fell to 0-2 at the start of the year but flipped things around with a 14-0 win over Wilson. Garrett stayed in the middle of the pack all year. He finished 2nd in Night Division and 4th overall with a 5-5 record and 3-3 divisional record. In the playoffs, he fell victim to a King K Rool walk-off home run.

Schedule

L 0-1 vs. Carston

L 0-1 vs. Will

W 14-0 vs. Wilson (4 innings)

L 3-5 vs. Andrew

W 2-0 vs. Andrew

W 1-0 vs. Jacob

L 0-2 vs. Carston

L 0-1 vs. Joe

W 2-1 vs. Matt

W 3-0 vs. Wilson

L 0-1 vs. 5. Matt (Quarterfinals) (7 innings)

Roster:

Red Pianta, Blue Pianta, Diddy Kong, Yellow Pianta, Purple Toad, Toadsworth, Tiny Kong, Gray Shy Guy, Shy Guy

Poll Rankings:

Pre-Draft: 8th

Pre-Season: 5th

Post-Week 1: 7th

Post-Week 2: 6th

Pre-Playoffs: 6th

Final Place: 6th

2024 Season

Despite less playoff success in 2023, Garrett had more regular season success than he did in 2022. A trend he would hope to see continue. Garrett started out the year tremendously. Undefeated in Week 1 and 7-2 through two weeks. At second place, he was only half a game behind Andrew in first. Garrett missed Week 3 and came back Week 4 going 4-4, finishing with an 11-6 record and a 5-4 division record. This put him at the 3 seed and 2nd in Night Division. Garrett had a remarkable comeback in the last inning to beat Will in round 1 before losing to eventual champion Joe in the semifinals.

Schedule

W 4-0 vs. Wilson

W 2-0 vs. Jacob

W 1-0 vs. Tween (6 innings)

L 0-1 vs. Joe (10 innings)

W 2-0 vs. Will

L 0-2 vs. Andrew

W 1-0 vs. Jacob

W 1-0 vs. Wilson

W 3-1 vs. Matt

L 0-1 vs. Wilson (8 innings)

W 3-2 vs. Andrew

L 0-1 vs. Andrew (6 innings)

W 3-0 vs. Tween

W 3-0 vs. Will

L 0-1 vs. Tween (6 innings)

L 1-2 vs. Joe

W 1-0 vs. Matt

W 2-1 vs. 6. Will (Quarterfinals) (7 innings)

L 0-1 vs. 2. Joe (Semifinals)

Roster:

Mario, Luigi, Red Kritter, Blue Kritter, Green Noki, Gray Shy Guy, Green Shy Guy, Monty Mole, Baby Luigi

Poll Rankings:

Pre-Season: 6th

Post-Week 1: 4th

Post-Week 2: 2nd 

Post-Week 3: 3rd

Pre-Playoffs: 3rd

Final Place: 3rd

2025 Season

With Andrew out of the league, Garrett had his best chance yet to claim the Night Division crown. However, starting off 0-2 is not a recipe for success. Garrett stayed around the middle of the pack all season. He finished 5-5 and 3-3 in his division to get the 4th seed and 2nd in Night. He continued his mild playoff success by taking down Anthony in round 1. Unfortunately, he ran into the future champion Joe in round 2 and his season ended.

Schedule:

L 0-2 vs. Wilson

L 0-1 vs. Anthony (7 innings)

W 1-0 vs. Jack

L 1-2 vs. Hayden

W 6-0 vs. Will

L 0-1 vs. Joe

W 3-1 vs. Wilson

W 2-1 vs. Jacob (9 innings)

W 3-0 vs. Hayden

L 0-2 vs. Jack

W 2-1 vs. 5. Anthony (Quarterfinals)

L 0-1 vs. 1. Joe (Semifinals) (8 innings)

Roster:

Luigi, Blue Kritter, Red Kritter, Boo, Gray Shy Guy, Green Shy Guy, Monty Mole, Goomba, Blooper

Poll Rankings:

Pre-Season: 2nd

Post-Week 1: 6th

Post-Week 2: 4th

Pre-Playoffs: 4th

Final Place: 4th

OFfseason events

Garrett was not a regular at offseason events, but he has participated in a couple. He played in the 2023 NSL Friendlies during the Fall Classic and went 1-2, and he took home 2nd place in the 2025 Summer Showdown.