The Lumnia building is designed with a strong emphasis on maximizing natural light, aligning with the WELL Building Standard's recognition of light's importance for human health and productivity. The design incorporates a daylight plan with Visible Light Transmission (VLT) greater than 40% and large glass facades to allow ample daylight penetration. To control glare and heat gain, solar shading, including manual blinds and vertical slats, is integrated. The building's morphology, featuring volumes arranged around a central courtyard, further enhances daylight distribution. This focus on maximizing and managing daylight aims to support occupants' circadian rhythms, visual comfort, and overall well-being, while also considering visual ergonomics through careful workstation and lighting design to minimize eye strain.
Based on our analysis, we estimate the points that Lumnia Building would have received for Light based on the WELL v2 Scorecard to be 13 out of 18 points.
WELL v2 (the current version of the WELL Building Standard) offers different options for achieving the Light Exposure feature. With referenced to Option 2, which focuses on the layout of the interior space in relation to glazing. Here's a more detailed look at its requirements:
30% within 20ft of Glazing: At least 30% of the regularly occupied area is within a 20 ft horizontal distance of envelope glazing.
This aims to ensure that a significant portion of the workspace receives adequate daylight.
Common Space Seating: Common spaces have unassigned seating and can accommodate at least 15% of regular occupants at any given time.
This promotes access to daylight and social interaction in shared areas.
70% Seating within 16ft of Glazing: At least 70% of all seating in the spaces is within a 16 ft horizontal distance of envelope glazing.
This is a stricter requirement, prioritizing daylight access for the majority of occupants' workstations.
Here's how we can connect the Lumnia building's design elements to the intent of WELL L02 with WELL L02 concerned with the quality and control of light, not just the quantity.
1. Maximizing Natural Light:
Large windows allowing ample natural light into office spaces and that the design includes large glass facades to immerse the spaces in natural luminosity. Natural light is generally considered beneficial, and maximizing it can help provide adequate illuminance during daylight hours, potentially reducing the need for artificial light.
2. Glare Control:
Blinds or other shading devices that can be used to control the intensity and direction of sunlight and that the building glare can cause discomfort and impair visibility, even if there's enough light. Shading devices help control the intensity of natural light, ensuring it contributes to appropriate illuminance without causing problems.
3. General Layout and Contrast:
A general layout that seems to minimize harsh contrasts in light and shadow, potentially contributing to visual comfort and it abrupt transitions between very bright and very dark areas can cause eye strain and fatigue. A design that minimizes these contrasts creates a more visually comfortable environment. WELL L02 wants uniform and comfortable lighting.
4. Visual Ergonomics:
The design of the Lumnia building also prioritizes visual ergonomics while not a direct requirement of illuminance thresholds, visual ergonomics and L02 share the goal of supporting comfortable and healthy vision.
This WELL feature focuses on providing appropriate light levels and spectra to support occupants' circadian rhythms, which are the body's natural sleep-wake cycles.
Light Levels for Workstations:
The feature sets thresholds for illuminance levels, measured in Equivalent Melanopic Lux (EML) or Melanopic Daylight Efficacy Ratio (Melanopic DER), on the vertical plane at eye level, to simulate light entering the eye.
These thresholds are required for at least four hours, beginning by noon at the latest.
There are different tiers with increasing EML/Melanopic DER targets, with higher tiers awarding more WELL points. Projects can achieve compliance with lower EML if combined with other WELL features.
LUMNIA Building Compliance Summary
Here's a summary of how the Lumnia building's design, relates to the WELL L03 requirements:
Emphasis on Daylighting: large windows allowing ample natural light into office spaces and includes a daylight plan, with Visible Light Transmission (VLT) > 40%. Natural daylight is a potent driver of circadian rhythms due to its high Melanopic DER. Maximizing daylight is a fundamental strategy for meeting L03's EML/Melanopic DER thresholds. Large windows and high VLT contribute to bringing in more of this beneficial light.
Vertical Slats for Shading: a strategic system of vertical slats (0.5 meters deep and spaced 1.5 meters apart) for shading, optimized through three-dimensional modeling to account for sunlight interaction at different times of the day and year. While shading is primarily for glare and heat control, it also plays a role in managing the quality of daylight. By controlling the intensity and angle of sunlight, the shading system can contribute to creating a more consistent and beneficial light environment throughout the day.
Building Morphology: The building's design, with four volumes arranged around a central courtyard, allowing natural light to penetrate deeper into the interior spaces. Deeper penetration of daylight means that more workstations can potentially receive the circadian-effective light needed to meet the EML/Melanopic DER thresholds.
Artificial Light's Role: While daylighting is emphasized, WELL L03 also considers artificial lighting. Whether the artificial lighting system is designed to contribute to circadian lighting (e.g., tunable white lighting).
L04: Manage Glare from Electric Lighting
WELL L04: Manage Glare from Electric Lighting
This WELL feature aims to minimize discomfort and visual impairment caused by glare from artificial light sources. The Unified Glare Rating (UGR) is a metric used to assess the likelihood of discomfort glare from artificial lighting. A UGR of 19 or lower is generally considered acceptable for most office environments.
LUMNIA Building Compliance Summary
Here's how the available information relates to L04 compliance:
1. Visual Ergonomics and Lighting Design: design of the Lumnia building also prioritizes visual ergonomics and this implies a careful consideration of lighting to minimize eye strain and promote visual comfort. Visual ergonomics and glare control are closely linked. Good lighting design, which is a component of visual ergonomics, directly affects glare.
2. Layout and Light Distribution: From the EXEO brochure mentions "general layout that seems to minimize harsh contrasts in light and shadow, potentially contributing to visual comfort". Glare is often exacerbated by uneven lighting and strong contrasts. A layout that minimizes these contrasts can indirectly contribute to lower UGR values.
3. Control of Natural Light: While L04 focuses on electric lighting, the control of natural light is crucial to overall visual comfort. Blinds or other shading devices that can be used to control the intensity and direction of sunlight. While not a direct substitute for UGR compliance, managing daylight glare is essential for creating a comfortable visual environment. If daylight glare is well-controlled, it reduces the overall visual burden on the artificial lighting system.
L05 Daylight Design Strategies
The main atrium, a significant interior space with a metal and glass façade, also welcomes ample natural light. This comprehensive approach to maximizing daylight penetration aligns strongly with the principles of the Light WELL concept, which also emphasizes visual comfort, a consideration addressed by the shading elements and curtains:
Daylight Plan: The Lumnia building incorporates a daylight plan that includes a Visible Light Transmission (VLT) of >40%. This feature indicates an emphasis on maximizing the amount of natural daylight that enters the building's interior.
Solar Shading: To manage glare and control the intensity of sunlight, the building integrates solar shading, with manual blinds installed on all floors. This feature allows occupants to adjust their light environment, contributing to visual comfort .
[Fulfills L05.1, L05.2, L09.1, L09.2]
L07 Visual Balance
WELL L04: Visual Lighting Design
Ambient Lighting: This part of WELL L04 sets criteria for the general lighting in a space, not task lighting.
Luminance Contrast Ratios: Horizontal and vertical luminance contrast ratios for an ambient light system is no more than 10:1 between adjacent independently controlled zones. This means that the brightness difference between different areas of the space shouldn't be too extreme, reducing eye strain from adapting to varying light levels.
Illuminance Uniformity: Illuminance uniformity ratio of at least 0.4 or 1:2.5 (minimum light level: average light level) is achieved on any horizontal task plane within a space. This ensures that light is evenly distributed across work surfaces, preventing overly bright or dim spots.
Lighting Automation met: A lighting automation system is in use and automatic changes in lighting characteristics, such as light levels, changes in color and distribution take place over a period of at least 10 minutes.
[Fulfills L01.1, L02.1, L04.1, L07.1, L09.1, L09.2]
L09 Occupant Lighting Control
Lumnia building complies with WELL's L09 Occupant Lighting Control, focusing on "Enhance Occupant Controllability" and "Provide Supplemental Lighting".
Part 1: Enhance Occupant Controllability
WELL aims to give building occupants control over their lighting to enhance comfort and productivity.
Daylight Control: The existence of manual blinds on all floors. This is a key feature for occupant control, allowing them to adjust the amount and intensity of daylight.
Part 2: Provide Supplemental Lighting
The need for supplemental lighting, which allows users to fine-tune their lighting for specific tasks. Support visual ergonomics and Provide workstation orientation suggests lighting that supports tasks at workstations with features like task lighting provisions (e.g., outlets for desk lamps) and lighting design that minimizes glare on computer screens.
[Fulfills L09.1, L09.2]
Lumnia EXEO Office campus
The design of the Lumnia EXEO Office campus places a significant emphasis on maximizing natural light in the office spaces through its large glass façades.
Curtains are installed to help manage glare and prevent discomfort from excessive brightness. Studies have indicated that increased exposure to natural light in workspaces can lead to higher productivity.
The building's upper volumes feature a fully glazed façade with a strategic system of vertical slats (0.5 meters deep and spaced 1.5 meters apart) for shading, optimized through three-dimensional modeling to account for sunlight interaction at different times of the day and year.
This careful consideration of solar incidence creates varied textures and tonalities on the building's exterior. The unique morphology of the building, with four volumes arranged around a central courtyard, allows natural light to penetrate deeper into the interior spaces, benefiting offices that may not have direct access to the exterior façade. Three of these volumes are hollowed out at the ground level, creating a seamless connection between the central courtyard and the surrounding urban environment, including gardens, further enhancing the flow of light.
Meet Lighting for Day-Active People
LUMNIA building incorporates several features that align with the WELL Building Standard's Light concept, which aims to support the health and well-being of occupants by addressing their lighting needs during the day.
The building features a daylight plan with a Visible Light Transmission (VLT) greater than 40%, indicating a focus on maximizing the amount of natural daylight that enters the interior spaces. This is important because natural light helps regulate the body's circadian rhythm, which influences sleep, hormone production, and overall mood.
To control glare and manage sunlight, the building is equipped with solar shading, using manual blinds on all floors. This allows occupants to adjust the lighting to their comfort levels.
Additionally, the building's design emphasizes visual ergonomics, suggesting attention to the design of workstations and lighting to minimize eye strain and promote visual comfort for those working in the space.
[Fulfills L03.1, L04.1]
Enhance Color Rendering Quality
The focus on a daylight plan with high Visible Light Transmission (VLT) suggests an intent to provide a more natural and full-spectrum light source, which is generally associated with better color rendering than some artificial lights.
[Fulfills L08.1]
Flicker Management
The WELL Building Standard addresses light quality to promote health and well-being. And to address light flicker it does emphasize aspects of lighting that are related to flicker management. These include:
High-Quality Lighting: WELL promotes the use of high-quality light sources. This implies minimizing undesirable characteristics of artificial light, such as excessive flicker, which can cause eye strain, headaches, and neurological issues.
Visual Acuity: WELL's focus on visual acuity also relates to flicker. Flicker can interfere with clear vision and contribute to visual fatigue, so managing it is important for supporting visual acuity
[Fulfills L08.2]
For more information on the critique and recommendations, please click here.
Source:
[1] https://standard.wellcertified.com/light
[2] https://lumnia-building.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/Well-Feature-Guide_MS.pdf
[3] https://www.exeo.pt/en/lumnia/
[5] https://lumnia-building.com/
[6] https://www.archilovers.com/projects/313308/lumnia-building.html
[7] https://www.skyscrapercity.com/threads/lisbon-exeo-office-campus-u-c.2095179/
[9] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WELL_Building_Standard
[10] https://www.exeo.pt/docs/EXEO_Catalogo%20Geral%20Digital_EN_2021.pdf
[11] www.exeo.pt
[13] https://ofs.com/resources/well/certification
[14] https://v2.wellcertified.com/en/wellv2/overview
[15] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-YunGg0eJJE
[16] https://vidaimobiliaria.com/noticias/escritorios/edif%C3%ADcio-lumnia-100-ocupado/
[17] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J0go5Bgl8BQ
[18] https://effisus.com/en/effisusportfolio/europe/exeo-office-campus-portugal/
[19] https://www.skyscrapercity.com/threads/lisbon-exeo-office-campus-u-c.2095179/
[20] https://commercial.lutron.com/us/en/global-experience-center-earns-well-platinum
[21] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0360132322007697