Clean air is essential for good health. However, urbanization has introduced multiple sources of air pollution, including increased vehicular emissions, construction activities, and agricultural processes. When constructing a building, it is crucial to consider that outdoor air can degrade indoor air quality. Poor ventilation practices can exposure occupants to unhealthy levels of volatile organic compounds (VOCs), polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) and microbial pathogens, potentially leading to health issues such as asthma, allergies, and other upper respiratory illnesses.
To ensure healthy indoor air quality, WELL sets limits on pollutant and contaminant concentrations. It also incorporates best practices from industry organizations such as the American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE), whose guidelines are evidence-based and widely recommended by professionals.
As an office complex, LUMNIA building must manage indoor air quality to prevent issues like sick building syndrome, which can negatively impact occupant well-being and productivity. We will look at some of the features that the Lumnia Building has incorporated to comply with the Air standard under WELL v2.
Based on our analysis, we estimate the points that Lumnia Building would have received for Air based on the WELL v2 Scorecard to be 5 out of 18 points.
Lumnia Building meets the Air Quality Thresholds [1], as summarized below [2]. Details on the actual indoor air quality within the Lumnia Building were not available.
Particulate Matter
PM₂.₅ less than 15 μg/m³.
PM₁₀ less than 50 μg/m³.
Organic Gases
Formaldehyde levels less than 27 ppb.
Total volatile organic compounds less than 500 μg/m³.
Inorganic Gases
Carbon monoxide less than 9 ppm.
Ozone less than 51 ppb.
Radon
Radon less than 0.148 Bq/L [4 pCi/L] in the lowest occupied level of the project.
Air quality performance tests are conducted onsite to ensure that occupants have access to a basic level of high indoor air quality.
[Fulfills A01.1, A01.2, A01.3, A01.4 and A01.5]
Smoking and the use of e-cigarettes is prohibited in interior spaces within Lumnia Building. "No smoking" signs are clearly displayed at the entrances of the building [1].
Similarly, outdoor smoking is also banned as indicated by signages located at strategic outdoor locations. CCTVs are also installed to ensure that occupants comply with the outdoor smoking ban. While we are unable to find specific on the ban on outdoor smoking, we assume that it would comply with the WELL requirements, as detailed below.
A smoking ban within 7.5m of all entrances, operable windows and building air intakes.
A smoking ban on all decks, patios, balcony, rooftops and other regularly occupied exterior building spaces. For Lumnia Building's case, this would apply to their rooftops on the 3rd, 5th and 8th Floor and nearby green spaces. Please click here to view Lumnia building's floor plans.
The hazards of smoking, in all areas beyond 7.5m of the building entrances (if smoking is permitted in this areas). These signs are to be placed along all walkways with a distance of not more than 30m between signs.
[Fulfills A02.1 and A02.2]
Lumnia Building optimizes indoor air quality with renewal rates 30% higher than those recommended by the international reference standard, ASHRAE 62.1 [1]. This meets the WELL requirements.
Referring to ASHRAE Standard 62-2001 62.1, the area outdoor air rate for an office space is 0.06 cfm/ft2 [4].
The renewal rate for Lumnia Building is estimated at 0.06 cfm/ft2 x 130% = 0.078 cfm/ft2. This calculation assumes a default occupant density of 5 persons per 1,000 ft2 and the absence of smoking-permitted spaces. The zone air distribution effectiveness and system ventilation efficiency were not considered in this estimation [4].
The ventilation system is assumed to operate using natural ventilation, which is commonly used in Portugal [6].
[Fulfills A03.1 and A06.1]
The ventilation system in all common areas receives regular maintenance, including filter cleaning, annually or whenever there are activities such as fit-out works which could compromise the health and well-being of the occupants. Maintenance is carried out by professional companies that comply with the legislative standards for this activity. Though the standards are not specified, we assume that the following standards were referenced by the management of Lumnia Building [3]:
EN15239 - Inspection of ventilation systems.
EN12599 - Test procedures and measurement methods for air conditioning and ventilation installations.
EN12097 & EN15780 - Accessibility and cleanliness of the system.
EN12237 & EN1507 - Measurement of airflow rates and ductwork leakage.
Similarly, we will assume that the filters used for the ventilation system complies with the WELL v2 standard - MERV13 or higher, based on an average outdoor PM2.5 threshold of around 23 µg/m3.
An example of a ventilation system air filter that meets this application would be AAF's Astro-Pleat MERV 13 Standard Pleated High Capacity AC Filter [8]. The filter utilizes electrostatically charged, 100% synthetic media to achieve high particulate removal efficiency. The filter media can also remove pollen dust for circulate indoor air, an important feature during Spring season to alleviate allergies and sinus irritation considering Lumnia Building's surrounding green spaces.
[Fulfills A12.1 and A13.1]
As required by WELL, indoor air quality issues should be monitored and effectively addressed, when necessary. Additionally, building managers and occupants should be kept informed about indoor air quality levels.
Lumnia Building conducts mandatory auditing of Indoor Air Quality (IAQ) annually, or whenever necessary. All audits of IAQ or system maintenance are then, shared internally through emails or news letters to all tenants. Pertinent information are also visualized in the building's directories, which we assume should minimally feature the temperature, humidity and carbon dioxide concentration per 10,000 ft2 of regularly occupied spaces, as required under Part 3 of Feature 18 [5].
[Fulfills A08.2]
Source: Lumnia Well Feature Guide
Source: Lumnia Well Feature Guide
Lumnia Building has recessed mats installed at entrances to capture particulates from occupant shoes. We assume the entrance mat to be a combination of carpet and rubber to offer scraping and wiping function, while also providing anti-slip properties. The mat would likely be commercial grade considering the potentially high foot traffic into the building.
A suitable entrance mat product would be the 3M Nomad Carpet Matting Aqua Series 85 [7]. This textile entrance mat has advanced water removal and retention properties, stopping up to 80% of dirt and moisture at the door. It is also highly suitable for high traffic applications (1500 to 5000 crossings per day).
Revolving entrance doors are also used at the main entrance to slow the movement of air from outdoors to indoors. Additionally, we assume that the remaining entrances have air seals to prevent outdoor air from entering when the doors are closed.
[Fulfills A09.1]
No information was found regarding the construction phase of the Lumnia Building. As the mitigation of construction pollution is a precondition, we assume that the Lumnia Building would have achieved A04.1 of the WELL v2 requirement for Air.
Referring to pictures of Lumnia Building's exterior, you would also notice that there are no operable windows installed for occupants' use. Hence, Lumnia Building likely received 0 points for both A07.1 and A07.2.
For more information on the critique and recommendations, please click here.
Source:
[1] https://standard.wellcertified.com/air
[2] https://lumnia-building.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/Well-Feature-Guide_MS.pdf
[3] https://www.rehva.eu/rehva-journal/chapter/ductwork-airtightness-requirements-in-portugal
[5] https://standard.wellcertified.com/air/air-quality-monitoring-and-feedback
[6] https://www.aivc.org/sites/default/files/members_area/medias/pdf/Conf/2004/2004047_Corvacho.pdf
[7] https://www.3m.com.sg/3M/en_SG/p/d/b00013659/
[9] https://m.malaysiakini.com/advertorial/599322
[10] https://espacodearquitetura.com/projetos/exeo-office-campus-edificio-lumnia/