Women Talking
Blaine: There are different religious communities on this Earth and Mennonites are one of them. Author Miriam Toews had learned there were Mennonite women who left the men after they drugged and abused them. It was really interesting to Miriam Toews and made her want to turn their story into a book which became “Women Talking.” The story takes place in 2010, and Mennonite women realize they have been drugged and raped by the men in their community. They get together to discuss what the best thing for them to do would be. Should they stay, should they go, or should they fight?
Frances McDormand bought the rights to the book believing it would make a great film, and producer Dede Gardner agreed with her after reading the book herself. Then it came to mind that Sarah Polley should adapt and direct it. Coincidentally, Sarah Polley herself had read the book after a friend of her’s from book club recommended it to her. A story like this gave Sarah a lot to think about because it’s about women who are making big changes for themselves. She was interested in adapting the book into a film, and learned Frances McDormand had bought the rights. She contacted Frances McDormand about the project, and well her wish already came true. Sarah Polley was the only person who was on both Frances McDormand and Dede Gardner’s mind, and so this project was meant for her.
It had been a while since Sarah Polley had made a film. The reason is because she felt she needed a break from filmmaking, and wanted to focus on her personal life. To put herself back in the game, Sarah Polley watched a lot of her favorite movies that are inspirational to her. She said it was like going back to film school. Inspiration does help get those creative juices going. She also spent a lot of time trying to think on how “Women Talking” would look as a film, and it ended up becoming something that really impressed Frances McDormand. The work Sarah Polley had put into this project was more than what Frances McDormand could have asked for.
The way the movie goes is like a stage play because a lot of the time you see the women hanging out inside a barn talking to each other. There are others who think the same. I have friends who have seen the movie and they agreed it was like watching a stage play. Even the cast felt they were acting in a stage play more than making a movie.
All the women meet up in the barn to discuss this serious issue, which reminds me of a group therapy session. They tell stories, talk about what is on their minds, comfort each other and try to figure out what is best for them. They all have experienced the same thing, but each one feels it differently.
Sarah Polley was lucky to be working with experienced actors, and newcomers who showed a lot of passion, and devotion for this project. Seeing Rooney Mara and Claire Foy together makes me think of “The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo” because they both have played the same character Lisbeth Salander in two different movies. The dialog in “Women Talking” is so well written and the way the actors said and expressed it sounded professional.
Rooney Mara I would say is the heart of the movie. You see so much peace in her, even though she has been through something terrible. She is going through an emotional state, but she shows it more through her eyes. The rest of her shows a calming energy. A lot of the women show teary eyes because this experience hurts them.
Claire Foy shows that her character has had enough, and while the other women are questioning what they should do, she is certain that this is no way to live. Claire Foy is positive about a lot of things, and she is making it clear that her children matter most to her above everything else, including her religion. She’ll protect them in any way, even if she has to get violent. It’s no more Mrs. Nice girl for her, she has evolved into a badass. Frances McDormand I always think of as the girl who you don’t want to mess with, and doesn’t take shit. Looks like she is passing that on to Claire Foy.
There are a couple of scenes where Claire Foy is really expressing what she is feeling. She is speaking out for herself and all the other women in the room. I was so impressed with Claire Foy’s performance, and she was able to keep that same level of energy through each of the 3 takes they shot for that scene. Claire Foy is such a professional, and I like how the camera is closing in on her as she is performing that scene.
Jessie Buckley’s character looks like she goes through a lot, one with being a housewife, who’s kids can get out of control half the time, and also being taken advantage of. She too looks like she has had enough of this. Towards the end of the movie, Jessie Buckly shows up at the barn beaten and bruised by her husband and her daughter has a bruised cheek. It shows that this abuse problem will not stop. Jessie Buckly has physical damage, but I don’t think she is afraid of being who she is, and finds the strength she needs to continue. Plus she is not alone. Her friends are there for her.
Ben Whishaw’s character is the only man in the whole village accepted into this female group. The difference between him and all the other men is he has heart. He didn’t start off Mennonite. He came from outside and then was accepted in their communitie. He takes notes for these women as if he is a court reporter. Ben Whishaw and Rooney Mara are close to each other, and he seems like the man she is meant to be with, but this is a forbidden love. Mennonite women aren’t allowed to read or write, but Ben Whishaw teaches Rooney Mara how to.
Frances McDormand is always a powerful presence with the looks she gives on her face, to the strong spirit she has within her. Her character is the only one who believes that all should be forgiven when really it is unforgivable. I think her character is not pleased with what has happened, and knows how wrong it was for the men to do what they did, but she devotes herself to her religion and feels positive about it.
Sarah Polley didn’t want to show visual examples of the men abusing women because she doesn’t enjoy watching those types of scenes. The women’s attitudes and emotions say it all. One of the things cinematography does is help express how characters feel and Luc Montpellier, the DP on this project, thought the style should be less saturated, and have a gothic inspired color palette. The barn is full of women and the camera likes to capture them in different ways, in groups, or singles, high and low, side to side.
There are shots of the characters looking out from the barn door at the field of crops right in front of them. There are shots of the children frolicking through the crops. There are shots where the camera will swerve up. The camera also likes to close in from high and low views. One of the girls jumps out of the barn and lands on a stack of hay for fun. For a second, the women believed she was taking her own life and the camera was moving forward as the women rushed to the door. I also like the low angle shot during that scene that is focussing on the women inside the barn from the outside. There’s one shot closing in on Claire Foy holding her daughter as the sun sets right in front of her. Another shot I like is the close up of a mother and daughter holding hands. They are both wearing matching dresses which makes a great surrounding for those hands. That shot was used as the film’s poster.
There’s a scene where Ben Whishaw is teaching Rooney Mara how to find your way. He puts her hand up to face the sky as he is giving directions on how to use it as a compass. I like how the camera focuses on the hand. The lamp is giving the hand a yellow highlight, and there’s a nice night sky with stars in the background.
The composer of “Women Talking” is Hildur Gudnadottir, the same woman who composed the music for “Joker,” and “Mary Magdalene.” Hildur Gudnadottir’s schedule was busy when this offer came her way. There was no other composer Sarah Polley wanted for this project other than Hildur Gudnadottir. Well she got the composer she wanted, and Hildur Gudnadottir wrote a nice guitar theme for the project.
Another piece of music that was added in was “Daydream Believer” by The Monkees. The book mentions a song being played, but the editor of the project felt “Daydream Believer” was more suitable. He added in the music without asking Sarah first, and when he showed it to her she didn’t know what to think. Sarah asked for two other people’s opinions, and they both thought it was a great choice.
The decision is coming to a conclusion, and all the women can agree it is best for them to leave. They’ve been questioning what they should do, but deep down they probably knew the answer all along. They sing in the barn, and the whole village hears them. Their singing is almost like announcing the 13th Amendment. It shows things are going to change for the best. All the women are putting things together as they get ready to leave. They also have a rule that no male child 12 and over shall come. Thing is Claire Foy’s son is at that age, and as I said before her children come first. Claire Foy forces her son to go, and I bet she’ll do her best to make sure she raises her son to become a gentleman. She also takes an axe with her incase she needs it for self defense. Don’t mess with her.
The only woman who doesn’t participate is Frances McDormand. She has her own way of seeing things, and sticks with what she believes. Ben Whinshaw must stay behind, even though he is an acceptable man, but rules are rules. He understands though, and wants what is best for those women. He supports them whether he is with them or in spirit.
As the women leave, there’s this shot that hovers above the fields as it focuses on them from the side, and then the camera points up to look at the sky.
I saw a special screening of “Women Talking” at the Goldwyn Theater, and after the movie was over there was a Q&A, with screenwriter and director Sarah Polley, Producer Dede Gardner, Composer Hildur Guonadottir, and some of the cast members, Rooney Mara, Claire Foy and Ben Whinshaw. What a mind blowing experience that was for me.
My rating on “Women Talking” is five out of five.