Blaine: This was the last movie my dad, Blaine Harrington III, highly recommended to me before his death, and I wrote this review for him.
“All Quiet on the Western Front” is an anti-war story that shows the German side of things during the first World War. Erich Maria Remarque was a veteran on the German side, and after the war was over, he became a novelist. One of his first novels was “All Quiet on the Western Front” and it was based on his experiences during the war. It was published in 1928, just before the second World War had begun. By 1933, Nazis banned “All Quiet on the Western Front” and destroyed a lot of copies. The Nazis didn’t get all of them though. Other copies of Remarque’s novel went global. A year earlier, Erich Maria Remarque left Germany for Switzerland. The country was going to hell because of the Nazis. They were killing Jews, arresting people who thought differently from them, burning books, and they killed his sister by beheading her. Of course he was unaware of her death, until after the war was over. In 1947, Erich Maria Remarque moved to the United States, but he was only there for a year, and then decided to move back to Switzerland.
The story starts off with a German boy on the battlefield, and you can tell he really doesn’t want to be there judging by how frightened he looks. New recruits are being selected and four friends are really looking forward to going off to war, but they don’t know what war is like. They think it’s going to be awesome, but it’ll end up being the biggest regret of their lives. “All Quiet on the Western Front” I would say was not just a way of Erich Maria Remarque expressing how he felt during the war, but he was also sending out a message that war is bad. Not everyone agreed with that message in Germany though.
Nazis destroyed several copies of Remarque’s novel, but there was no stopping a story like that from getting out to the public. It was already adapted into a movie made in America 3 years before Nazis made it illegal in Germany. The movie won two Academy Awards for Best Picture and Best Director.
Edward Berger first read “All Quiet on the Western Front” when he was a teenager, and it was a story he became obsessed with. It’s one of his favorite novels of all time. Edward got a call from his producer friend Malte Grunert asking if he was interested in adapting another version of “All Quiet on the Western Front,” and Edward Berger was all for it. A screenplay had already been written by Lesley Paterson and Ian Stokell, and Edward felt it needed more work. For one, he wanted it to be in the German language. Edward wrote the movie in the way he wanted to make it.
There have been foreign films that have been adapted into American versions, but now it’s become the other way around.
Felix Kammerer is a professional German actor who has been acting on stage and Edward Berger has had his eyes on him for a while. The lead character of “All Quiet on the Western Front,” Paul Baumer, Edward had written for Felix. Paul is a good kid, who deserves better in life than being out fighting for the wrong reason. He was happy in the beginning, but now he is scared to death. After being out at war for just one day, it has already become a nightmare for him, with bombs going off and dead bodies all around. One of those bodies is his friend. One by one, he’ll see each one of his friends die right before his eyes. Edward hates everything he is experiencing, and what he is forced to do, such as taking the life of another. He has no choice. If he tries to run, his own side will kill him. War has become a lot of things other than exciting. It’s horrible, unfair, terrifying, dangerous,.....it’s not fun at all.
What is unfair is the general is sitting by, making himself comfortable, stuffing himself, while the soldiers are doing all the work, risking their own lives, and starving. There is someone who does care for those men and that is Matthias Erzberger played by Daniel Bruhl. Matthias Erzberger existed, and he negotiated to surrender in order for the war to end and spare the lives of the German soldiers. A few years after the war had ended, Matthias was assassinated.
Half of the movie shows the battlefield, and you see German soldiers trying to avoid being shot at, blown up, set on fire, and squashed by a tank. Edward and his friends don’t look like they are up for being out there. They are fighting, but I see them trying to survive more.
My dad was a big fan of the cinematography this movie had to show. As soon as the film starts, you are already seeing great shots. A view shot of mountains, an overhead of foxes sleeping, an ant view of trees, and then you see an overhead of several dead German soldiers in the mud. There are times you’ll see peaceful views, and a lot of other times you’ll see views that are disastrous. The camera is slowly coming down as it enters the battlefield. Then an explosion happens and it cuts to trenches where German soldiers are shooting at the enemy while protecting themselves from the enemy’s fire. The camera goes in, there’s a lot of smoke, and soldiers running around. The camera comes to a stopping point when it notices a frightened soldier. Then he gets pulled away, and the camera follows him as he is entering the battlefield. The camera is keeping focus on the soldier as he runs through the battlefield. Then it cuts to another shot where he is 10 feet away, but he is coming in closer. He ducks to protect himself, and the camera is at a low angle. The soldier is frightened for there is death surrounding him. He is so afraid that he can hardly aim his gun. He gets up, and after he attacks things go black.
Edward Berger wanted to give this movie everything, and he managed to find a great group of talented artists, from costume designers, to makeup artists, prop guys, set designers and so on, to help him transform this popular novel into a unique piece of work. Everyone who was involved with making “All Quiet on the Western Front” said it was a tricky movie to make. A lot of people say that in making movies. They are trying out new ways of creating something and shooting it. Being an artist you are always faced with challenges, but you know you are going to pull it off because you have the talent to do it. Everyone has set up everything making it look like the real thing, so it can look good on camera. The camera will capture the work they have done in several different ways. Up close, on top, a distance, on the side, and down below. It wants to see it all. They worked hard to recreate an historical moment, and it deserves to be captured in the best way. Yes, it is disastrous, but it is also strong.
Most of the shots in “All Quiet on the Western Front” wouldn’t be complete without visual effects. You are adding in things, such as tanks, blood, and explosions, and removing body parts because they were blown away. Some shots also required the matte painting technique to add in or recreate the area the way you want it to be seen. When shooting a movie, you can’t put a tank over a human being because that would be very dangerous, and you would end up like that soldier who got squashed during that scene. That’s why they added them digitally.
This is Felix Kammerer's first time in front of a camera, and it loves him. Felix shows a great amount of drama on his face. There are times he’s just staring away into space with a miserable look on his face because he is unhappy with what he has experienced. That’s what war does to you. He also shows fear and devastation. His character has seen too much, and it never stops. There’s always something going on, and it never ceases to surprise him of what he is witnessing right in front of his eyes. This is hell.
I noticed that the camera likes to focus on Felix Kammerer’s backside a few times, and each shot has a different style to it.
The war is coming to an end as negotiations have been made, and Germany surrenders. The soldiers are very pleased it is over. The general however is pissed that Germany has lost the war. He won’t stand for it. He is being stubborn by forcing the soldiers to attack the French. He only cares about what he thinks, instead of what is best for the soldiers. They’ve been through enough, especially Paul. He has a mother who will want nothing more than to have her son back safe and sound. Paul, and the other soldiers were close to going home, and many of them have lost their lives because of that damn general. They attacked the French, and Edward got stabbed through the chest. He used all his strength to make it up to the light before things went black for him.
The last shot of the film shows Paul’s corpse. It is lying up against a trench wall, and his face is covered in mud. The way that shot looks is like a dramatic painting. It’s really sad. A boy who deserved better in life went off just to lose his life.
My rating on “All Quiet on the Western Front” is four and a half out of five.