Minamata

Blaine: W. Eugene Smith was a popular photojournalist. My dad told me he provided a powerful picture of a Japanese mother giving her severely deformed daughter a bath. There was a chemical company in Minamata, which is located in Japan, that was dumping poisonous chemicals into the city’s water, and causing a neurological illness. Local citizens were fighting against the company because of that, and Eugene Smith was there to help them expose it. He took several photographs which were a huge help. Those photographs showed everything that was going on. 


Eugene Smith has traveled a lot, and was in Japan during the second World War taking photographs for various magazines, Flying Magazine, and then LIFE after. He was with the American forces as they were fighting Japan. He went to Saipan, Guam, Iwo-Jima, and Okinawa. The photographs Eugene Smith took from the war earned him the title of one of the greatest living photographers. Eugene experienced unpleasantness too. War is dangerous, and can damage a person physically and mentally. In 1945, during the invasion of Okinawa, Eugene Smith suffered severe injuries, which took two years, and 32 operations to recover. In 1947, he started to take pictures again, and went back to LIFE magazine. 


Andrew Levitas spends a lot of his time doing artistic things. He is into photography, painting, sculpting, and making movies. He takes turns with each one of them. He started off as a photographer, and his inspiration was Eugene Smith. He thought a lot of Eugene Smith, and could see there was so much to his work. Andrew wanted to make a film about Eugene Smith, and he could have made it a life long story about him. Eugene Smith traveled and experienced a lot in life, but Andrew also wanted to tell a story that was inspiring which is why he chose his Minamata story. 


As Andrew Levitas was getting started on putting the project together, his agent recommended that Johnny Depp play Eugene Smith. Through the photos I’ve seen of Eugene Smith, his looks do seem similar to Johnny Depp’s. Both Andrew Levitas and Johnny Depp’s agents talked on the phone and learned their clients have the same interests. Johnny Depp hates photographers who are paparazzi, but he has respect for photo artists. He had seen Smith’s work, but didn’t know all the details about him, such as who he was and what he went through in life. After Depp met with Andrew Levitas, he felt Smith’s story should be shared with a wide audience. Both Andrew Levitas and Johnny Depp collaborated together on doing the research on Smith. 


Andrew Levitas tracked down Eugene Smith’s wife Aileen, and both he and Depp met with her to get information about Smith. She gave them a lot of useful info. There is no one who I think knew Smith better than his own wife. Johnny Depp felt he owed a great debt to Aileen after everything she told him. 


In the film, Eugene Smith gets involved with Minamata after a Japanese American woman named Aileen approaches him asking for help. She was assigned to interview him for a Japanese advertisement firm. She doesn’t know much about him except he is a popular photographer. They get to know each other and then she tells him about the situation in Minamata and asks if he can help. Eugene has mixed feelings about that. His experience in Japan haunts him and because of that he is afraid to return. Aileen really insists that he help. Eugene thinks about it during the night, and decides to go along with it. 


This is how it really happened. Aileen was working for a Japanese advertising firm. It was a summer job she had taken on while taking a break from Stanford. She knew nothing about photography until she met Smith in 1970. Shortly after, Aileen dropped out of Stanford and moved into Smith’s New York loft and assisted him in putting his new book together “Let Truth Be the Prejudice.” A year later, Mr. Motomura, who was a supporter of the resistance in Minamata, came to Eugene and Aileen telling them about how the people were being killed from the pollution, and asked if they could document it. Eugene and Aileen could see how serious this was and they both agreed to do it. 


Aileen learned a lot about photography from Eugene as they were documenting Minamata. Eugene gave her a camera, and she bonded with it. She realized that photography is a part of yourself because you’re the one who is taking the photos. 


Eugene and Aileen make a great team. You see them doing a lot together. They go undercover at a hospital to meet the sick victims, and also discover classified stuff that can really help them expose the toxic company. 


Eugene started off as Aileen’s mentor, and through the time they had spent together they became lovers. Eugene Smith has three kids, and in the film he talks a lot about how he wasn’t the father he should have been, like being there for one. All he has are his cameras, his photos, his darkroom, whiskey, and a cat. Aileen is the first person to come into his life that he has developed a really close relationship with. She treats him in a way no one else does. She brings out the best in Eugene, and understands he has been through a lot. She is there to comfort him. Another way of explaining her is that she is his conscience. Every time Eugene says I can’t do this or I am not in the mood for that, she’ll give him a look that says “I won’t take no for an answer” and make him change his mind. Eugene is a good person, and with Aileen, she makes him a better one. 


Johnny Depp is known to be a kind man and it must have been easy for him to bring that into his performance. Eugene meets a handicaped kid, who is a victim of the disease, and teaches him how to take photographs. Eugene has made himself a role model to that kid. 


A lot of editors who have worked with Eugene Smith said he was a pain to work with. Johnny Depp and Bill Nighy have worked with each other several times. This is their fourth project together, only this time Bill Nighy doesn’t have tentacles or snake venom coming from his fangs. Nope, he’s just a human being in this film. Billy Nighy plays the editor in charge of LIFE magazine, Robert Hayes. Both Hayes and Smith argue with each other, but I sense that deep down there is fondness. I think Hayes can see there is more to Eugene, and wants him to do better with himself. 


I don’t know if Eugene loved to drink and smoke, but he does in the movie, just as much as Johnny Depp himself. I think the reason Eugene drinks is to help get the edge off from what he’s experienced from the War. 


I also see Eugene as someone who has trouble expressing himself at times. In one scene after both him and Aileen are done developing photos, she looks at him in a romantic way, and he pretends he is taking a picture of her. There’s a line in that scene my dad and I really like and that is “permission to take someone’s picture is like asking for a kiss.” Aileen takes that moment to steal a kiss from Eugene. I felt something special between them in that scene. I also love seeing those two hold each other. She certainly is the best thing to happen to him in a long time. 


Minami is the actress who plays Aileen, and Andrew Levitas met thousands of girls for the part before her. When Minami came in there was something about her that just clicked. She read the part, and Andrew knew she was right for the job. Minami is very artsy too. She loves to paint, and sculpt. She has taken on acting jobs since the early 2000s, mainly for television. I think “Minamata” is the first project where Minami has played a main role. The first time she learned about Minamata was in high school. She certainly did a good job with her performance by showing devotion, kindness, reasonableness and leadership. 


As soon as Eugene and Aileen arrived in Minamata, the chemical company that was causing the disease could tell they would be a problem to them. They try to bribe Eugene and explain there is nothing wrong with their chemicals, but he knows it’s all bullshit. He also refuses to kiss the ass of an ass hole. The man who tried to negotiate with Eugene, Junichi Nojima, I would say has a conscience. At first he thinks this is nothing, but as he hears out the parents of the children who are victims to his waste he starts to think “maybe what we are doing is bad.” He sees how traumatized some of the parents are. It’s a lot to take in, especially when one of them cuts his wrist in front of him. 


Director Andrew Levitas wanted the story to be expressed more from a visual point. He also didn’t want the camera to focus on the actors the whole time. We’re seeing things from Smith’s point of view. Having a background in photography, I bet Andrew Levitas knows how he’ll want things to be shot in his own film. Benoit Delhomme was asked to be the DP on this project and it was a huge honor for him to be offered this job because Eugene Smith is a role model of his. He had his own ideas for how to shoot the project, like the different types of cameras to use. Andrew worked closely with Beonit because it was important to him on how this movie was going to be shot, and they both wanted the style of the shots to look as though you are looking through a photographic lens. 


Eugene Smith’s photographs gave a lot of feeling as you were looking at them, and that is one of the reasons why Andrew Levitas hired Benoit Delhomme because he gives a feeling in what you are seeing in his shots. There’s a scene where Aileen wants to feel Eugene’s war scars on his chest, and he feels uncomfortable about it, but she knows how to push his buttons. She holds him close and shows him love. It’s a lovely shot of them.  


You’re also seeing different styles of color for the tint in certain scenes. Mainly red because the characters spend a lot of time in the darkroom developing photographs. Black and white is used for the shots that are made to look like super8 or make it look like a photograph. Eugene and Aileen’s first date is at a jazz club, and the tint of that scene is dark aquamarine. Yellow is used for the Matsumura house when Eugene and Aileen arrive. And in the early morning, the tint is blue. Eugene Smith says “I’ve never shot in color ever,” but this film has made his life look colorful in different ways.  


When the movie starts, you don’t see Eugene’s face, just his backside. Then you see a head shot of his face through a front door window, which I like. There’s a wide shot of Johnny Depp’s Eugene Smith lying down on his coach while smoking a cigarette and his studio light, which is the only light in the room, is hitting his face. I also like the silhouette headshot of Johnny Depp waiting in the other room as Aileen is getting Masako and her daughter set up in the bathtub. I also love the close up on the face of the mother and daughter. 


One of the things Andrew Levitas learned about Eugene Smith was he would take a lot of records with him on his trip. He was a big music lover. He loves jazz in the film, even talks about it with the handicapped kid he teaches photography to. At the beginning of the film, the song “I’d Love to Change the World” by Ten Years After is playing in the background. A song like that is suitable for a film like this. 


Andrew Levitas was lucky enough to have an award winning composer, Ryuichi Sakamoto, best known for “The Last Emperor,” do the score for “Minamata.” There are times the score sounds beautiful and peaceful, and other times it sounds like justice. 


Eugene spends a lot of time putting a photo gallery together of all the pictures he has taken in Minamata. He spends hours in the darkroom developing those photographs. Then the darkroom gets set on fire, and all the work Eugene devoted hours to is destroyed. He feels it’s over, and the company has won. Eugene will quit easily at times, or be unsure of himself, but everyone he knows, his editor and Aileen, pushes him to do his best and to not give up. They have faith in him, even though he might not believe in himself. The resistance appreciates Eugene for being a devoted team player. 


Eugene has been through a lot, and continues to find himself in positions where he is putting his own life at risk. Eugene gets himself beat up, and ends up in a hospital where a mysterious man gives him saved negatives from his darkroom. This man is the son of one of the victims, and both him and his mother are fond of Eugene. 


It’s almost over, and as Eugene recovers he still has one more picture to take. It’s the photo everyone will remember him best for, the mother in the tub with her severely deformed daughter. They recreated the famous shot by Eugene Smith for that scene. 


Eugene’s editor receives the photographs taken in Minamata and is getting lost as he looks at them, feeling he is there. The story is published, and the article opens the eyes of Junichi Nojima. Looks like he does care after all. The resistance succeeded, but there was still more that needed to be done. Still, the work Eugene had done had given a lot of Minamata citizens hope. The people are grateful to Eugene Smith for his help. He couldn’t have done it alone. Aileen was by his side, and helped give him the push he needed. Eugene and Aileen married in August of 1971, and spent seven years living together in Japan, until Eugene’s death in 1978. His injuries were the cause of his death. Aileen never remarried because over the years she has been going by her married name, Smith. She has spent the rest of her life continuing to support the patients and families of Minamata. She has also been making sure the Minamata story continues to get out to the public. She wrote articles and books. Aileen Smith is happy that this film helps carry out the message. 


The first studio to own the rights to “Minamata” was MGM, but because of the problem Johnny Depp was having with Amber Heard in court, they decided to pull the movie. MGM traded the film to Samuel Goldwyn Films, a studio that supports the art, and independence of film. “Minamata” was chosen to premiere at the Berlin Film Festival. Aileen Smith was there to support the film. “Minamata” became a success, and it helps introduce Eugene Smith to those who may not be familiar with him. Also gives an important history lesson about Minamata. 


My rating on “Minamata” is five out of five stars.