Blaine: When Guillermo del Toro was a child, he and his mother saw an animated feature called “Pinocchio.” It became an obsession for Guillermo. As a boy, Guillermo felt he could relate to the character in learning the world around him, and he said it was scary for him. As you get older you learn a lot, and some things can concern you such as having huge responsibilities or death. Guillermo wanted to make his own version of “Pinocchio.” He asked his mom if it was possible, and she believed he could do it.
In 2007, Guillermo del Toro began pre-production on his “Pinocchio,” and for 15 years he had been developing the project. I remember seeing online articles saying “Guillermo del Toro is putting together a Pinocchio film.” The project got canceled at one point by I think the first studio that owned the rights to it. Guillermo wasn’t going to quit on it. Next to “The Shape of Water,” “Pinocchio” is one of Guillermo del Toro’s most passionate and personal projects that he has been wanting to make since childhood, and he managed to keep it alive.
Guillermo del Toro knew he couldn’t direct “Pinocchio” alone. His plan was to make it a stop motion feature, which is a long process, and his co-director needed to be someone who has had experience in making stop motion features. Mark Gustafson had worked for Will Vinton’s studio for several years, and was also involved in making “Fantastic Mr. Fox.” Guillermo had contacted Mark asking if he would be interested in helping him direct “Pinocchio.” It was no question if Mark would do the job or not. His answer was yes because he knows how great of an artist Guillermo del Toro is.
Stop-motion features usually run for an hour and a half or less, but “Pinocchio” is the first to be nearly two hours long. It’s unbelievable, especially with the amount of work that has been put into this feature. Guillermo del Toro has taken stop-motion to a whole other level. Stop-motion is a physical job to do because you're not sitting in front of a computer screen like you do with 3D. Everyone has to take the time to animate the puppets frame by frame. The main character goes on a long journey, and Guillermo del Toro wanted every piece he wrote in the script to be brought to life. It also mattered to him that the audience got a good look at everything that was going on, especially the characters’ emotions.
Guillermo del Toro hired the best and most talented artists and animators to help bring his vision for “Pinocchio” to life. One of them was Merve Caydere. I know Merve because both she and I are members of Academy Gold Rising, and she worked on “Pinocchio” as a set designer. How cool is that? The set designers looked through the films Guillermo del Toro has done in the past as a reference because there is so much artistry in them from the color, to the shapes, to textures that it would help give them an idea of how they should create the world of “Pinocchio” for him. 1940s Italy was going to be another reference since that is when and where the movie takes place, and the prop makers and set designers did a lot of research on that and looked through a lot of photographs. The set designers, matte painters, and prop makers managed to pull off making a world that is so well crafted, as a Guillermo del Toro movie should be, and so life-like, and I think another reason Guillermo wanted the movie to take their time in running was so the audience could get a good look at the set work his team has done.
Several adaptations of “Pinocchio” have been made, including recently. Disney made a live action remake of their classic animated feature from 1940. A lot of film adaptations that have been made through the decades go by the story Disney told instead of the way Carlo Collodi wrote it in his book. Italy did make a feature more true to Carlo Collodi’s book in 2019. Guillermo del Toro has written an adaptation that is new, and made it his own. One scene I like that I think is well thought out is when Pinocchio is comparing himself to Jesus. They are both made of wood, but Pinocchio asks why they treat him with respect, while he gets treated as if he were Frankenstein? It’s a well thought out comparison.
There are similarities we have seen before, but Guillermo added in and re-wrote a few pieces. For example, in other adaptations Pinocchio would perform for Stromboli, a puppeteer who does a traveling show for just one night. Then Stomboli would hold Pinocchio prisoner and he had to escape. In Guillermo’s film we get to see an extended version of what life is like for Pinocchio as he goes on tour as a performer. He is not being held prisoner, it’s his choice. He wants to be famous, but the more he is on tour his interest in fame fades away.
Another example about this adaptation being different is Gepetto already having a son before Pinocchio, who was killed in a bomb explosion duirng the first World War. Carlo Collodi is the author of “Pinocchio,” and I think Guillermo named the first son, Carlos, after him.
Guillermo del Toro puts a lot into his work, and this “Pinocchio” is a true piece of artwork. It’s because Guillermo himself is a true craftsman. It matters to him that every texture, shape, and the colors you are looking at as you are watching his movie look unsurpassed.
Guillermo compares Pinocchio to Frankenstein because they both weren’t born, they were constructed and brought to life, and they are both learning the world around them. When Geppetto is putting Pinocchio together it has a “Frankenstein” feel to it, one with it happening on a dark and stormy night. You notice Pinocchio only has one ear? Well that’s because Geppetto didn’t complete him. Like Frankenstein, one half of Pinocchio is finished and the rest isn’t. The look of the character is inspired by the illustration Gris Grimly did. Guillermo really liked Grimly’s design of Pinocchio and he felt positive that the character should look like that.
The first morning Pinocchio is alive, he is fascinated and is curious to know everything about everything that surrounds him. Reminds me of another stop motion character, Jack Skeleton when he discovers Christmas Town. I am just as amazed with the world around Pinocchio as he is because again the artists did a terrific job on creating it. Stop motion is a slow process when animating the puppets, and by the end you see characters like Pinocchio moving at a fast pace, especially when they are as energetic as him. Animators are the ones bringing life into these puppets and to do what they do is a professional and patient process. You have to make sure you get every piece of movement just right as you are animating the puppet. No mistakes, otherwise the whole shot is ruined, and you have to start all over again.
Guillermo del Toro said the thing about stop motion animation is as you are working on it it’s there right in front of you physically from the sets to the puppets.
Guillermo del Toro had “Pinocchio” shot as if it were a live action film. From the way the camera will move around, to the way things will be framed in the shot, to how they’ll be focussed on, and the way the scene will be lit. There’s a lot of warm colors to light up the scene or hit the characters and give them an outline. It’ll be caused by candle light, morning light and around sunset time. You also see a lot of blue at times. The Blue Spirit that appears really brightens up the room in Gepetto’s house.
Frank Passingham has been the cinematographer on other stop motion hits such as “Chicken Run,” and “Kubo and the Two Strings.” “Pinocchio” was something else for him to work on because this is a stop motion feature that goes more deeper into character emotions compared to the previous projects he had been involved with, and the camera has to be supportive of the mood the character is feeling in each scene as it captures them frame by frame. Like when Geppetto is sorrowing over losing his first son, the camera is capturing the pain he is feeling, even from up close to see how much pain he is in.
The puppets are not the only ones being moved frame by frame, but the camera as well. Stop motion features have had shots where the camera is moving with the characters, but the work they did on “Pinocchio” is extraordinary. The camera will move around at times to explore everything that is in front of or surrounds it, again I’m using the set work as an example, just as Pinocchio is.
Guillermo said, and I’ve heard him say this several times, the shot where Spazzatura the monkey is heading down the steps and wandering through the caranvil took 3 months to work on. The camera also moves when Gepetto and Carlo are passing through the town towards the church. The camera is moving down when it shows the citizens up above and down below. Then you see a shot where Gepetto and Carlo are passing more citizens, and the camera is slightly circling towards the right. Then the speed of it increases a bit for it wants to see the church that is in front of Carlo. The camera wants to explore the town and everyone in it, and both Geppetto and Carlo are your guides as they move through it. One of the shots I was really impressed with was at the beginning, when Carlo is on the swing and the camera is moving along with him as it focuses on his front side.
The work Guillermo del Toro does has been described as looking at a painting, and there are loads of shots in “Pinocchio” that make it look like you are looking at a frame in a museum, like the shot of Geppetto looking at the church burning. The closing shot where Pinocchio is a silhouette on a hill with a wide view in front of him, with a sun setting is one of my favorite shots in the film.
Guillermo del Toro thought the cricket should be a traveler, and instead of calling him Jiminy, the name Sebastian felt more suitable for this version of the character. Hiring Ewan McGregor to do the voice of Sebsatian helps give the character a poetic approach. No one really hears Sebastian Cricket out when he’s trying to explain something important, and he’s also trying to sing a song, but he keeps getting interrupted. The audience would like to hear what he has to sing. At the end, we hear the song we have long anticipated for from Sebastian. He has trouble having people listen to him. It’s easier for him to be listened to through his narration.
Pinocchio is like a cat with nine lives because he resurrects whenever he gets killed, and Sebastian has his own nine lives. Everytime he gets interupted he’ll be hit, stepped on and squashed, but like a cockroach you can’t kill him. He can get injured, but he finds a way to get back on his feet. He has a job to do, and that is to be Pinocchio’s guide, even though it’s tricky when he keeps slipping away from him.
Pinocchio isn’t thinking things clearly and even though he doesn’t have strings on him everyone is pulling them for their own advantages. He doesn’t take responsibility seriously because he doesn’t know what responsibility is, and he hardly has any patience.
Pinocchio is seen differently by everyone. His purpose of being brought to life was to be Geppetto’s replacement son. Count Volpe sees him as a popular performer who can make him rich. Podesta looks at him as an invincible soldier, and for Sebastain Cricket, Pinocchio is his home. He lives in the hole where Pinocchio’s heart is supposed to be, and Sebastain’s head is heart shaped.
When you see Sebastian around the Blue Spirit and the rabbits, his blue colors blend with theirs. A lot of work had to be done with Sebastian. They made a puppet of him that is the same size as the other character puppets, but it had to be keyed in some of the time. They also made tiny sizes of Sebastian for whenever you see a full frame of the other characters that surround him. There are a couple of overhead shots of Sebastian looking down at the characters below from the ceiling, and my guess is for those shots Sebastian and the other puppets were the same size but what you see below him is made to look like a forced perspective, an illusion to make an object appear farther away. That or they keyed him in.
Father Geppetto is a very emotional character. You can tell by the look you see in his eyes. In the beginning you see him as a man with a lot of heart, but then he gets heartbroken after his son Carlo gets killed when a bomb hits. He’s torn apart, and wants nothing more than to have his son back. He creates Pinocchio hoping he can have a son again, but Pinocchio is a lot to handle. Geppetto was seen as a respectable man, but Pinocchio is making him look like Dr. Frankenstein. Geppetto is a little embarrassed by Pinocchio, and doesn’t know what to think of him. Then he realizes his wish was to be a father again, and a father’s job is to love his son, even if he is made of wood.
When this project started pre-production, Guillermo del Toro had Tom Waits in mind to do the voice of Geppetto, but then he decided to go with David Bradley, an actor who has worked with Guillermo on his series “The Strain,” and his “Arcadia” series, instead.
The first shot of the movie is a pinecone fading in, and I asked myself what is its purpose? Then Carlos found the perfect pinecone, Geppeto planted it, it grew into a tree, he cut it down and turned it into Pinocchio.
Guillermo del Toro loves mythical creatures. Pinocchio’s blue fairy is a spirit that I would describe as a mermaid with wings. Guillermo del Toro’s “Hellboy II: The Golden Army” had a grim reaper in it, and it had several eyeballs on its wings. He gave his Blue Spirit that same thing. She also wears a mask which makes her look mysterious because you don’t know what’s behind it. Pinocchio has more encounters with the Blue Spirit’s sister, Death. Every time Pinocchio dies he ends up going down to the land of the dead waiting to be resurrected. Death wears the same mask, and has wings with eyeballs on them, but she has a different body compared to her sister’s. She has horns, which have eyeballs on them too. She has the body of a lion, with snakes for a tail. Death’s body doesn’t glow like Blue Spirit’s because her sister is light and she is dark.
Animated features are always going through changes as they are being developed. In 2008, they shared some early concept drawings of “Pinocchio.” Pinocchio looked as he does now, but Geppetto went through a lot of alterations, along with the main villain. He was big, wide, more pirate-like, and had a long beard. He definitely looked like a Stromboli. Then Guillermo del Toro decided to go with a new look after the puppet designers had already made the puppet of the first design. Good news for them was the time they spent making that puppet didn’t go to waste. He was used as an extra, and Count Volpe took his place as the main villain. Guilllermo’s version doesn’t have a fox and cat that lure Pinocchio away from school and take him to Stromboli, but the way I see Count Volpe is a combination of Stromboli and John the fox. Co-director Mark Gustafson described Volpe’s looks as devilish, but I see a fox quality to it, one with him being a redhead, wearing an orange coat, and the shape of his head is pointy and the way both sides of his hair stick up are as if they are fox ears. You can tell Pinocchio is lying because his nose grows, and he doesn’t realize Volpe is lying to him, but his nose is long enough to show he is a liar.
I’ve heard actors say they would play anything including a mop or a donkey in order to be involved with a project that feels unique or work with a great artist like Guillermo del Toro. Cate Blanchett had worked with Guillermo on “Nightmare Alley,” and as they were wrapping up that project she had an urge to do another project with him. “Pinocchio” was already in the works and they cast the actors to do the voices of the characters. All that was left was a monkey. Cate Blanchett didn’t care what the part was, she would do anything just to work with Guillermo again. The monkey doesn’t have any dialog. It’s not like the talking animals, the fox and cat, you saw in the other versions. Cate Blanchett was basically making monkey noises as they were recording her voice, but there were a few scenes that had dialog she could read. Spazzatura is Count Volpe’s assistant and sidekick. I think of him as the cat to Volpe’s fox. He puppeteers the extras when Pinocchio is performing. Spazzatura will have those puppets talk to Pinocchio from time to time and it’s Cate Blanchett doing the voices of each one of those puppets.
Again, Pinocchio is seen differently by everyone. For Spazzatura and Candlewick, they see Pinocchio as a weirdo. Spazzatura discovered Pinocchio and informed Count Volpe about him, and then he seemed jealous of Pinocchio. Pinocchio can bring out the best in some with his kindness, and they grow fond of him because of that.
Guillermo del Toro had big actors like John Turturro and Tim Blake Nelson, who he had worked with on “Nightmare Alley,” have small parts. It’s not always about having a star, it’s about having an actor who feels right for the part. John Turturro has a lot of character in him, and even though you don’t see much of his character, which is the town’s doctor, still you love hearing his voice through it. Tim Blake Nelson does the voice of all four of the black rabbits who gamble with each other in the underground. The black rabbits are from Carlo Collodi’s book and they would show up when Pinocchio refuses to take medicine that will make him feel better. They didn’t gamble, that's for sure. Guillermo del Toro has given his design of the rabbits a more Day of the Dead look.
The songs you listen to in “Pinocchio” were co-written by Guillermo. Alexandre Desplat was Guillermo del Toro’s composer on “The Shape of Water” and now he has done the music for another project Guillermo has been very passionate about.
There’s a lot you could learn from watching movies, not just the artistry, but also they teach things about history, cultures, places you are unfamiliar with. It’s dark times, and Pinocchio couldn’t have been brought to life at a better one. Guillermo had his “Pinocchio'' take place in Italy when it was under the dictation of Benito Mussolini, and he was one of Hilter’s collaborators.
Ron Perlman has been with Guillermo del Toro since the beginning of his career. They’ve done 7 projects together, and “Pinocchio” makes 8. Ron Perlman does the voice of Pedesta, and when you first see him he’s a blacksmith who seems like a friendly guy. Years later, he’s a different person who is more serious, and is serving under Mussolini. Pinocchio is recruited by Podesta and takes him to a training camp with other young boys. Again, Pinocchio is like a cat who has 9 lives, and because he resurrects a lot, Podesta feels he can be the perfect soldier of the bad kind. The training camp is like the carnival where young boys can do bad things, but instead of turning into donkeys they are being trained to be soldiers.
War takes away a lot. The good, but also the bad, and Podesta and Count Volpe get what they deserve.
Pinocchio survived a bomb explosion and that was a strong shot to see for me. I mean Pinoccho goes flying into the air at full speed and then hits a rocky hill.
A giant fish monster out at sea isn’t dangerous enough unless there’s bombs out there too, but in a way it becomes a solution to killing that thing and Pinocchio turns that monster into sushi.
This version of “Pinocchio” is a lot of things, and another thing is it’s very strong. Pinocchio doesn’t become a real boy in the end as he always has in other adaptations. No, he stays the way he started off, as a piece of pinewood. The reason Pinocchio became a real boy was because he did a good deed in saving his father’s life, and Pinocchio in this film did the same and sacrificed everything to save Gepetto, including his immortal life. Guillermo del Toro said the reason he chose to have Pinocchio stay the same is because the point of it is to be loved as you are, and Gepetto accepts that now. Pinocchio may not change on the outside, but he has on the inside. He has matured a lot, knows better and he won’t go wandering off anymore. His place is with Gepetto and he sticks by him until his death.
Death told Pinocchio that those around him he loves and cares for would die. The movie ends with Gepetto, Sebastian and Spazzatura dying one by one, leaving Pinocchio alone in the world. It’s sad to see, but judging by the smile on Pinocchio’s face, he is going to make the best of things for himself. He looks like he is going to explore. Sebastian said so himself. There’s more to explore in the world and I can see Pinocchio hiking up mountains, exploring other towns, and countries, meeting new people. Sebastian also said that the world will embrace him. There is bad, but there is also good out there, and Pinocchio can tell the difference now. He’ll never be alone as long as he finds those who are good.
For years, people have been hearing about Guillermo del Toro making his own “Pinocchio” adaptation, and now that it has been made and is out, we all get to see what a masterpiece it is. When I saw “Pinocchio,” it was a lot more than what I could have asked for.
One of the greatest experiences I’ve had in my life was meeting Guillermo del Toro in person. I went to a special screening for “Pinocchio” at the Samuel Goldwyn Theater, and he was there for a Q&A. I approached Guillermo and let him know what an amazing man he is as a role model and a true artist. He really appreciated that, and we had a nice conversation with each other. I told him I knew I was going to like “Pinocchio” because it’s done by a great artist like him. He has shown us what he is capable of through the work he has done in the past and he has so much in him that you have faith in what he has planned next. Guillermo found my name to be fascinating. When I told him my name is “Blaine Harrington IV,” his response was “What a fucking name!” It’s an experience I will never let go of. I was also at the 95th Academy Award when “Pinocchio” won the Oscar for Best Animated Feature. I was a seatfiller. The journey I’ve had with this movie is unbelievable and personal after experiencing something as exciting as this.
My rating on Guillermo del Toro’s “Pinocchio” is five out of five stars.