Nightmare Alley
a Guillermo del Toro film
(Spoiler Alert)
Blaine: In 1946 there was a novel written by William Lindsay Gresham called “Nightmare Alley.” It grabbed the attention of a lot of studios, and a year after the novel was published, a film adaptation was released. In the early 90s, the world was being introduced to a young talented filmmaker named Guillermo del Toro. Guillermo’s first feature, “Cronos,” was a huge success, and really helped start off his career as a filmmaker. After “Cronos” was completed, one of it’s actors, Ron Perlman, wanted to talk to Guillermo about making another adaptation of “Nightmare Alley.” Guillermo del Toro had never heard of the book, nor had he ever seen the 1947 movie. Ron Perlman showed Guillermo the film at his house, and Guillermo really got into it. What Ron Perlman wanted to do was make an adaption in the form the way author William Lindsay Gresham wrote it, which was something more dark. The movies back in the 40s weren’t as revealing, dark, or strong as the ones you see today. Ron Perlman could see great talent in Guillermo del Toro, and he felt if anyone could do a darker version of “Nightmare Alley” it could be him. Guillermo del Toro was all for it, but it was going to have to wait for he had a long list of projects he wanted to work on.
As time went on, and through each film he made, Guillermo del Toro was becoming very popular, and making a name for himself. After finishing “The Shape of Water,” Guillermo del Toro felt it was time to make “Nightmare Alley.” Guillermo and his co-writer Kim Morgan added more to their screenplay compared to the 1947 version, such as going deeper into the story, and adding more details to it. One of the things about Guillermo del Toro is he is a very detailed man in a lot of ways. The way he describes his way of seeing movies, the way he directs, the way he writes, the way he crafts something using his artistic ability.
There are things you see in Guillermo del Toro’s movies that aren’t human. They’ll either be a mutant vampire creature, a fish person, kajuu, giant bugs, fairies, monsters, a faun,.....creatures from the sci-fi, fantasy, and horror department. “Nightmare Alley” is the first movie he has made with just human characters. Guillermo del Toro is a big moviegoer, and he keeps a close eye out for actors he wants to work with, who feel suitable for a character in his movie. For this project, Guillermo put together a group of A list actors.
Guillermo del Toro thought the lead character, Stan the conman, should be played by Bradley Cooper. Cooper’s interest in the project was to work with Guillermo, and he was even more excited about the project after Guillermo told him about the other actors he had in mind for the project. The movie starts off with Stan in an old house, putting a dead body in a big hole on the floor. Stan is not just burying a body, but cremating it as well because after he puts the body in the hole, he sets the place on fire. He goes on the road, and finds himself at a carnival where he meets a lot of interesting people who he can relate to in ways. Stan is a conman, and these people put on a show to make their audience believe in things, such as talking to spirits, when really it’s just an act. They are the type of people he belongs with, and some of them teach him lessons on improving his skills in tricking people. Everyone who works at the carnival has to be observant of the audience if they are to put on a show.
Willem Dafoe is one of those actors who you see in everything. His character, Clement, owns the carnival and welcomes Stan into it. Clement’s main attraction is a weirdo who bites off chicken heads, and the way I see it, he’s his pet. He also collects dead things in jars, which reminds me of another Guillermo del Toro film, “The Devil’s Backbone.”
There’s one person in particular that Stan gets close to, Pete, played by David Strathairn. Pete would act as though he was contacting the dead, but he doesn’t perform anymore. He spends his time drinking and helping his wife, Zeena, with her fortune telling show. Pete drinks, but he’ll never reveal the secrets of a trick. No matter how drunk he is, he will never spill his and everyone else’s secrets. He’s even protective of this book that he carries around. Inside that book will teach you how to trick an audience into believing you can communicate with the dead. Stan feels a technique like that is unique. After Pete passes away, Stan steals his secrets so he can use them for his own show.
Toni Collette, plays Zeena Krumbein the fortune teller. Zeena is not the type who wants to trick people for their money. She rather give them an earn for their money. She’s a good person, and cares for others. She doesn’t want to disappoint her audience. She can read people easily, which helps with her fortune telling performance. I feel she does have the power to be a fortune teller. Later on in the film when she is visiting Stan, she can sense he is going down a dark path. She tries to warn Stan, but he chooses not to listen.
Rooney Mara, I’m a big fan of her work, and not only is it good to see her in something new, but seeing her in a movie done by an artistic and passionate director like Guillermo del Toro. She plays Molly, Stan’s love interest. Molly’s act is pretending as if she can handle bolts of electricity. Stan tries to seduce her, and she finds him charming. Stan asks Molly to run away with him, but she needs time to think about it. Molly does want to move on, but still it would be strange adapting to a new life after spending so many years with the show. After she sees how Stan handles the authorities, she feels positive about leaving the show to move on in life. She feels she’s in good hands with Stan.
Stan is putting on a show, and one of the audience members, who’s a psychologist, wants to challenge him. Her name is Lilith Ritter, and both her and Stan show an interest for one another, and decide to do business together. Cate Blanchett is a professional actor who has worked with tons of great directors, Martin Scorsesse, Davide Finch, Peter Jackson, Alejandro G. Inarrittu, and now Guillermo del Toro.
I feel Cate Blanchett is a powerful presence in “Nightmare Alley.” Cate Blanchett shows a straight look on her face a lot because she likes to focus on people as she reads them. Reminds me of what Cate Blanchett said in “Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull,” “I want to know what’s inside your head.” Lilith will interview people so she can read through more pages as she is reading them. Lilith knows people that Stan wants to mess around with. She gives him the information about them so he can continue playing his mind game. Her character is dark, mysterious and seductive.
Richard Jenkins was in “The Shape of Water,” and I don’t think there’s a director he loves working with more than Guillermo del Toro. In “Nightmare Alley,” Richard Jeakins plays someone who believes Stan is a fake, and wants to use a lie detector test on him. Thanks to Lilith, Stan has information on this guy so he can play a game with him.
Ron Perlman, I already explained was in Guillermo del Toro’s first film, and it’s because of him Guillermo made this adaption of “Nightmare Alley.” Those two have a history together. After “Cronos,” Ron Perlman would act in other movies Guillermo made, such as “Blade 2,” he played Hellboy twice, and a dealer of monster parts in “Pacific Rim.” Ron Perlman plays Molly’s guardian. He was good friends with her father, and after he died, Perlman promised he look after Molly.
This is the third project in a row that cinematographer Dan Laustsen has done with Guillermo del Toro. Guillermo works closely with everyone who is helping make his film, including the cinematographer. I think Guillermo is very helpful with the cinematographer in giving him an artistic environment for the camera to explore in. Guillermo will also put things in front of the camera, and help the cinematographer make it look interesting to look at. Example would be putting a rabbit in a hallway. Guillermo must have had to pull it out of a hat to do that. Guillermo del Toro is bringing his world to life, and he wants it to be shot in a way as though you are looking at a painting he did himself. The way I see it.
The first adaption of “Nightmare Alley” was in black and white, and Guillermo del Toro’s version has color. Although, his adaptation comes with a black and white version.
“Nightmare Alley” has a great ensemble, but three of the actors, Bradley Cooper, Cate Blanchett, and Rooney Mara, I would say were shot better than the others. The reasons are because of the way they are posed, lit up, focussed on, silhouetted. The first time we see Cate Blanchett, she’s the only member of the audience being hit by the spotlight, because the camera wants us to know who our attention should be on.
Rooney Mara wears a lot of red in “Nightmare Alley,” which helps her become the highlight in certain shots she is in. For example, the first time we see her, Bradley Cooper is wandering around the show, and Rooney catches his eye, along with ours. Whenever we see shots showing a room full of people, our eyes will be focussed on Rooney Mara because she’s the only one wearing red, which is completely different from everyone else’s outfits.
There’s one shot where it’s a close up on a watch Rooney Mara is holding. It’s a narrow depth of field shot, meaning the camera is focusing on an object while the background is blurry. The camera slowly backs away from the watch, and everything around it is clearing up.
There’s also the shot where Rooney Mara is in the telephone booth and the camera is focussing on her from the inside, then slowly closes in on her face as her eyes get teary.
Everything has to look good and prepared when the camera starts rolling. The camera likes to wander, and get a good look at everything around it. There’s one shot where the camera is backing up as it is focussing on a spider woman. It then moves to the side because it’s now interested in seeing what Rooney Mara is up to. The camera manages to get a closer look at Rooney Mara’s performance by hovering above the audience.
There’s a shot focussing on Bradley Cooper’s backside as he is eating, but the main focus is what’s in front of him. Toni Collette is being seen from a distance, hanging laundry to dry. Then Ron Perlman and another guy are going to her to give her of the bad news.
I also like the way the actors will move through Guillermo del Toro’s direction. For example, Cate Blanchett helps Bradley Cooper light up his cigarette with a match, then after she blows it out, and uses that match to point to where she wants him to sit down. Another example would be when Bradley Cooper is snooping around Cate Blanchett’s office. He looks through her tapes, and uses his lighter to help him see the names. I like how the camera closes in on Bradley Cooper’s hands, as they are moving to the side.
What Stan is doing with Grindle, the lie detector guy, is making him believe he can bring forth the spirit of his deceased with. Molly looks like her, and Stan feels she should play her spirit. Molly is all about doing tricks but this is too much and too personal. She doesn’t have the heart to tamper with someone else’s emotions. Molly gives it away, and Grindle figures out that Stan played him. To cover his ass, Stan bashes Grindle’s head and kills him.
When Molly left the carnival for Stan, she felt it was the best decision she had ever made, but now she realizes it was a terrible mistake. She leaves Stan, and I believe goes back to the carnival.
The saying is “sooner or later, someone is going to stab you in the back,” or in Stan’s case a piece of his ear gets shot off. Cate Blanchett conned Stan. Another way of saying it she used him. She’s a very clever woman, and knows how to lure someone into her trap. Stan tries to kill her and then makes a run for it. He is now a wanted man.
It’s just what Zeena predicted. She knew Stan was heading towards a dark path. He went from conman, to criminal, to mad man/homeless man. He had everything, and now he has nothing. People who do wrong don’t usually get a happy ending. A friend of mine said he is to be the next chicken man.
My rating on “Nightmare Alley” is five out of five stars