“Charlie Says” focusses on the three Mansion girls’ point of view. Guinevere Turner did a lot of research to develop her screenplay. A lot of the stuff the Manson Family does in “Charlie Says” is as weird as you would see in any other cult. But it’s not all about the cult, it’s also about these three girls opening their eyes with the help of Karlene Faith. The actors that were hired were aware of what the Manson murders were, but they didn’t know all the details. Guinevere Turner’s script was like a history book.
Matt Smith (Doctor Who & The Crown) played the lead in a musical version of “American Psycho”, which was based on Mary Harran and Guinevere Turner’s film. Mary and Matt were both at the Primetime Emmy Awards, and Mary went up to Matt to introduce herself. One of the things Mary mentioned during her conversation with Matt Smith was the Mansion Family project she was developing with Guinevere Turner. A few weeks later, Mary heard from Matt Smith saying he was interested in auditioning for the part of Charles Manson. It was a challenge for Matt Smith to play someone he doesn’t fully understand because Manson never spoke normal. Matt thought Charles Manson was a really annoying guy after seeing some footage of him. Mary loved the idea of Matt Smith playing Charles Manson, and Matt blew her away when he auditioned for the part.
The performances in “Charlie Says” are so convincing. They make me believe they are these people. Like Matt Smith does an excellent Charles Manson. Acting all weird and talking like Charlie. And then you have all the actresses, Hannah Murray (Game of Thrones), Sosie Bacon, Mariannne Rendon, Merrit Wever, Grace Van Dien and Kayli Carter.
Hannah Murray wanted to be apart of “Charlie Says” because it was being made by women, and the story was a female driven film. Hannah also found it fascinating to learn things about the Manson girls she never knew. Hannah got to know Leslie van Houten by reading Karlene Faith’s book. Karlene knew Leslie very well. Hannah felt she knew who Leslie was while reading the book. Hannah’s parents were freaked out that she was auditioning for a movie about the Mansion Family. From the looks of it in “Charlie Says”, Leslie was confused. It’s like deep down she knew everything at the ranch, and Charles Manson was no good, but her conscience wasn’t speaking loud enough for her to hear. She couldn’t stand up for herself, or say what was on her mind. When you see the girls in the prison, Leslie is open minded to what Karlene has to say.
Whenever Charlie wasn’t around, Patricia Krenwinkel would be his messenger, to remind the others, like Leslie, what Charlie always says. Patricia acts like she is wise, but she doesn’t know everything she believes in, that Charlie told his followers, is false. Karlene would ask questions to the girls that would make them think. Karlene’s words really got to Patricia. Patricia was realizing Karlene is right about everything. Patricia didn’t want it to be true when the girls realized all the stuff they did was for nothing, but there was no escape from the truth. At the end of “Charlie Says” it shows Patricia looking at a picture of Charles Manson in her cell, and she feels like an idiot for listening to a lunatic.
Susan Atkins’s life was already rough before Charles Manson came into it. Susan’s mom died from cancer, and that was really hard on her. She also dropped out of high school, and became a stripper. There’s a scene where Charlie tackles Susan, and takes his anger out on her after this record producer turns down Charlie. Susan felt it was no problem the way Charlie treated her, but I don’t think it would be any different from the way things were before meeting Charlie. Both Leslie, and Patricia have regret in the end. Susan, she finds religion.
Sharon Tate is in a couple of scenes. Apparently Charles Manson wasn’t really after Sharon Tate, he was after the guy who owned the house before her. But when Charlie was told the guy moved away he settled for Sharon Tate instead. What an ass hole. The death scenes in “Charlie Says” are brutal and they are made to look that way because that’s how it was in real life. It doesn’t show Sharon Tate being stabbed to death, but it does show her begging for both her, and her unborn son’s life. Then her cheek gets slit, and then it cuts to something else.
Karlene Faith feels like an amazing person to me because she didn’t give up on these girls, and she was able to succeed in making them sane again. Although that didn’t help Leslie, Patricia and Susan get out of prison. Charles Manson filled the girls’ heads with nonsense, and Karlene had it sucked out. Everyone thought the Manson girls would remain insane forever, but Karlene proved them wrong, and she knew she could do it. But Karlene also realized that if she opens the girls’ eyes then they’ll realize they were fools to take orders from a maniac, and that they have ruined their own lives. Merritt Wever is a very skilled actress, and she put a lot into her performance as Karlene. The girls are upset with themselves for what they have done, but Karlene was there for them, and I think Karlene was an icon to the girls.
The ranch the Manson Family stayed at burnt down, so they couldn’t shoot “Charlie Says” there. They were going to shoot the film at a neighboring ranch until the owners found out Mary and her team were doing a project about Charles Manson. The owners threw Mary, and the crew off the property. So Mary had to find another location and it was perfect.
Making “Charlie Says” happened fast. The whole ensemble was cast from February to April of 2018. Then they shot the movie during the Summer. And then it was all done just in time for the 2018 Venice Film Festival. “Charlie Says” didn’t have a distributor at that time. After it’s premiere at the Venice Film Festival, IFC bought the rights and “Charlie Says” was released in select theaters on May of 2019. “Charlie Says” is about lunatics, but a lot was put into it. I would say it’s a good drama. It’s also interesting, and my rating on it is four and a half out of five stars.