peer Reviewer Resources

KEY DOCUMENTS

PREPSS Peer Reviewer Guidelines 2025.docx

PREPSS Peer Reviewer Guidelines

View this document for guidelines on the role of a peer reviewer, as well as guidance on how to conduct a peer review.

PREPSS Peer Review Form 2025

Peer Review Form for PREPSS Peer Reviewers

PREPSS peer reviewers should use this form when conducting peer reviews.

Example PREPSS Peer Review.docx

Example Peer Review

Example of a good PREPSS peer review.

ADDITIONAL RESOURCES

How to Write an Effective Journal Peer Review Using a Staged Writing Approach

This best practices paper presents peer review as a three-step process.

Peer Review: The Nuts and Bolts

This guide from Voice of Young Science is written by early career researchers and helps demystify the process of peer review and general expectations for peer reviewers.

Peer Review Guidance: How Do You Write a Good Review?

Dr. Thomas Wesley Allen provides an overview of the peer review process and describes in detail the general and specific tasks required of peer reviewers

COPE Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers

Peer Review guidelines from the Committee for Publication Ethics

Reviewing Manuscripts: A Systematic Approach

This article provides guidance on a systematic approach to performing peer-review.

Reviewing Manuscripts: A Primer for Novice and Seasoned Reviewers

Article developed to provide an overview of the peer-review process at Annals of Behavioral Medicine and describe the general and specific elements that should be included in a high-quality review for the journal.

Tools used to assess the quality of peer review reports

This paper offers 24 tools to assess the quality of a peer review report.

Report abuse