Subject: RE: Some rudimentary answers to Owen's rhetorical questions in the press today.
Date: Fri, 14 Jun 2013 05:11:37 +0000
Dear Christopher,
Many thanks for your e-mail.
As Peter describes, below, the best way that you can contribute to the Glenn Inquiry is by making your contribution to the Inquiry Panel. If you would like to do so, please register your interest on our website so that we can keep in touch and let you know how to make your submission.
Kind regards,
Jess
Hello Jess,
Many thanks for your email.
I have previously corresponded with Ruth Herbert, who assured me that Dr Dutton's work and the links I sent her were to be included for the commissions consideration. I can only guess by this correspondences that this did not occur and this deliberate omission, as you can read, has been my opinion from the email exchange with Peter.
Since I have written extensively in a blog format, reformatting all this again in to a submission is quite a commitment of time, which I may undertake, if I have time ion the near future.
What I would like you to do is record the following opinion for Owens consideration until I send the reformatted material.
To recap;
The purpose of the Glenn Inquiry is:
"If New Zealand was leading the world in addressing Child Abuse and Domestic Violence, what would that look like?".
The commission then called for experiential input from all involved. It established a Panel comprised of similarly minded individual experts, from the recommendations of its chair. It ignored any contrary opinion and expert publications that did not fit with its viewpoint. It became a vehicle to perpetrate the accepted thinking very quickly and mired itself in minutia and detail that will go on for years with no discernible outcome. Asking people who are victims of a faulty system to describe the faulty system is a methodology incapable of delivering any perspective and alternate solutions.
If this situation is likened, as it has been many times by experts in the field, to a scenario where support services of the 13 or so government agencies TODAY that are involved in this issue are the AMBULANCE AT THE BOTTOM OF A CLIFF and the unfortunate abused cases are the ones being pushed over the edge, forming an Enquiry on the basis that Ruth has advised Owen to do as stated above, is analogous to walking around the flattened and traumatised bodies lying on the ground below the cliff asking them the following questions;
1) "What was your experience of being pushed?"
2) "What was your experience of falling?"
3) "Was it the fall or the sudden stop that did the damage?"
4) "What devices could we now build for you to make the next jump less injurious ? A trampoline ? An air bag ? A soft polystyrene ball filled pool to land in ? What would that device look like ?"
The question postulation of your commission has been formulated to be completely blind the commission to the reality that faulty science in the from of the Interventional System we have adapted into our Care of Children Act, Family Court Procedures, Support Services and overall attitudes has been shown to be unscientific, tautological, and data impervious. Not to mention violating patient ethics and abusing individual human rights in the process. To quote many International Experts such as Dr Dutton, this the reason that people are being pushed over the cliff edge in the first place. Add Child Poverty, Addictions and the usual mix of behaviours of people under stress and we have a big picture.
DuttonandCorvo.pdf
CORVO-K.-DUTTON-D.G-CHEN-W.Y.-2008-TOWARDS-EVIDENCE-BASED-PRACTICE-WITH-DOMESTIC-VIOLENCE-PERPETRATORS.pdf
Government Policy is about big pictures and the whole DV Abuse Industry is the story of an out of control , hijacked way of thinking that is blinding our society to making any real progress.
Delaying tactics like Ruth's concept of yet more pointless research, as well as the recommendations of people like Jan Prior and a whole group of similar viewed Gender Politicised Activists and we have the story of Minimisation, Denial, and Blame generated to defend the Duluth System home grown right here in our backyard.
Owens genuine concern and attempt to trust people who seemed to have the answers, from my perspective, has been betrayed and I hope he reflects on this scenario he just went through and compares it to the similar frustration the Minister of Social Welfare, who undoubtedly also experiences the same frustrations, as she is advised basically by the same group of people.
https://sites.google.com/site/nzchinatravels/owen-glenn/remove-duluth-campaign
I sent the above to Owen Last year in an attempt to suggest a position for his commission that would bring Political Pressure, based on sound science.
It is my submission that Owen uses his common sense and many resources to OUT the faulty thinking, Processes and the "DV Industry" in this country and expose it for what it is. He just had a Gun Held at his head for not agreeing with the Industry way of thinking, this should be a huge red flag for him and hopefully the beginning of his "Political awakening" to be able to truly act in a positive response. This abuse problem is in reality a heavily Politicised Problem and wont be resolved until the Politics is resolved.
Delegating resources and "trusting so called experts" as described by Peter as his current arms length involvement with the Commission, will continue to deliver him with stinging reprisals each time he moves in the direction of the science and away form the current Politicised Attitudes. I believe he has the courage and conviction to see past this all however, it's in his nature and I appeal to this innate sense of natural justice that I recognise in him to act.
Owen, you have to break an egg to make an Omelette.
I conclude with this NZ Herald Article that appeared last week. It questions the who concept of Gender Based Abuse ( Blaming Males mostly ) thinking, and gives a far larger perspective.
http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=10890674
yours sincerely
Christopher Smith
https://sites.google.com/site/nzchinatravels/an-even-more-unfortunate-experiment
https://sites.google.com/site/nzchinatravels/owen-glenn