I recently had a chance to get the park-and-position adjusted Wins Above Replacement numbers more or less updated for the first 13 seasons of ATH history, which will be very helpful in Hall of Fame voting this season. That, combined with a metric that I have named the "Importance Score" which combines WAR per season and individual awards (including rings) are the most efficient ways that I have found to evaluate a player's HOF candidacy. For reference, all five members of the ATH Hall of Fame have double digit scores with the average total checking in at 16.1 points. Here's a look at this year's ballot:
Hitters
Graham Brock: not fully evaluated, but averaged 2.4 WAR in seasons with calculated totals
Taylor Butler: not fully evaluated, but averaged 3.8 WAR in seasons with calculated totals
Einar Castillo: not fully evaluated, but averaged 4.1 WAR in seasons with calculated totals
Darrell Charles: not fully evaluated, but averaged 1.7 WAR in seasons with calculated totals
Lance Fitzgerald: not fully evaluated, but averaged 1.9 WAR in seasons with calculated totals
Carl Locke: 1.8 Importance Score
Brian Loiselle: 2.3 Importance Score
Louie Matsui: 0.7 Importance Score
Neifi Ortiz: not fully evaluated, but averaged 1.3 WAR in seasons with calculated totals
Mark Robinson: not fully evaluated, but averaged 3.1 WAR in seasons with calculated totals
Tim Suppan: not fully evaluated, but averaged 1.6 WAR in seasons with calculated totals
Pitchers
Lee Buchanan: not fully evaluated, but averaged 2.7 WAR in seasons with calculated totals
Victor DaSilva: 11.9 Importance Score (also 15th All-Time in WAR)
Gioskar Gloub: 3.7 Importance Score
Hiroki Li: 20.9 Importance Score is good for 2nd All-Time (also 13th All-Time in WAR)
Carter Pickford: 5.4 Importance Score, was a pre-merger beast
My Votes: Li, DaSilva, Golub