Opposition to the Nazi regime
By itself this section is fairly limited and doesn’t have much scope for sustained argument so it is unlikely to expect a sustained response on this question.
Think of it like this, To what extent was opposition effective within Nazi society – Answer “It wasn’t” the end.
You could easily get a lower mark question asking you to identify or discuss different groups/types of opposition so you should include specific examples in your notes (Edelweiss pirates, army opposition, church opposition etc)
These examples could also be rolled into an extended response exploring the methods of control used by the Nazis. If you were asked to evaluate the effectiveness of Nazi control measures for example these groups could be used to illustrate that it was highly but not completely effective in stamping out opposition.
Reasons for the lack of opposition to the Nazi Regime
Given the terror and oppression by the Nazis, most people were afraid to oppose them. However, there were groups and individuals who risked their lives and freedom to stand up to the Nazis
Prior to the Nazis achieving power the streets were filled with paramilitary groups with their own ideology. Communists and the Nazi SA Stormtroopers often fought each other and both were determined to end democracy. In 1931, one group determined to maintain a democracy was called the Iron Front, a paramiltary force aligned with the Social Democratic Part (SPD). They were opposed to not just the Nazis, but also against Communists and the return of the monarchy. They often fought Nazis and place their symbolic three arrows over the swastika in defiance. They were banned when the Nazis came to power.
Source 1
Despite signing the “concordat” with the Catholic Church, Hitler oppressed religious groups. There was some opposition such as reinstalling crucifixes in schools next to the portrait of Hitler but there was little effect. The Catholic Pope, Pius XI, sent a statement condemning Hitler’s breaking of the Concordat in 1937, to be read in all Catholic Churches. The Catholic Church did manage to alt a euthanasia program for the disabled briefly. A priest, Martin Neimoller openly opposed the Nazis and set up the Confessing Church which criticised the official Reich Church. Thousands of Confessing Church leaders were arrested, beaten and sent to concentration camps, including Martin Neimoller himself, although he survived the camps.
Source 2- A quote from Martin Neimoller explaining his feelings about standing up to the Nazis.
“First they came for the socialists, and I did not speak out—because I was not a socialist.
Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out— because I was not a trade unionist.
Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out—because I was not a Jew.
Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me.”
More about this quote here
A notable group who opposed the Nazis were the young people. Far from being convinced to support Nazi ideology by the changes to school curriculum, Nazi teacher training, changed textbooks, and enforced participation in the Hitler Youth, some young people openly rebelled. They formed their own youth group with names like the Swing Kids, the Navajo, and the Edelweiss Pirates, and often brawled with Hitler Youth Members and wrote anti-Nazi graffiti. They had little success and were mostly ignored by the Nazis until WW2 when some were sent to concentration camps, and a few hanged.
Further reading about Youth opposition to Nazis
http://www.raoulwallenberg.net/saviors/others/edelweiss-pirates-story/
http://mentalfloss.com/article/73451/german-teens-who-rebelled-against-hitler
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1SX996BXOH7F3-clj2aJ7_Oe4rXmIg2LraNJngNGhc50/edit?usp=sharing
August Landmesser was a German man known for his silent defiance against the Nazi regime. A 1936 photograph captures him standing with his arms crossed while others around him give the Nazi salute. His act of resistance stemmed from love—he was married to Irma Eckler, a Jewish woman.
Initially a Nazi Party member in hopes of securing employment, Landmesser was expelled in 1935 after his engagement to Eckler. Their marriage was denied under the Nuremberg Laws, but they had a daughter, Ingrid, in 1935. A failed attempt to flee to Denmark in 1937 led to Landmesser’s arrest for “dishonoring the race.” Although acquitted in 1938, he was arrested again months later and sentenced to hard labor.
Eckler was later imprisoned and died in a concentration camp in 1942. Their daughters were placed in orphanages, but Irene narrowly escaped deportation thanks to a family acquaintance. Landmesser, released in 1941, was later drafted into a penal battalion and went missing in Croatia in 1944.
In 1949, August and Irma were officially declared dead, and in 1951, Hamburg posthumously recognized their marriage. Their daughters took their parents' surnames—Ingrid as Landmesser and Irene as Eckler.
Further Reading:
Modern History Transformed: Page 81-84
https://www.sutori.com/en/story/opposition-to-the-nazis--ZnWjWyAiWH7ZmrpU8QkjoFEJ
Use what you have learned from syllabus points 3.5 (The various methods used by the Nazi regime to exercise control, including laws, censorship, propaganda, repression, terror, cult of personality), 3.6 (Impact of the Nazi regime on life in Germany, including cultural expression, religion, workers, youth, women, minorities including Jews), and 3.7 (Opposition to the Nazi regime), to answer the following question.
Why was opposition to the Nazis ineffective?
Remember to plan using the scaffold provided on our study skills website