Each group will present their arguments in a structured classroom debate (3–5 minutes per group). After all groups present, there will be a short rebuttal or open discussion round.

Submission Requirements

• Submit your slide digitally (Google Slides, Canva, PowerPoint) or in print.

• Debate may be live or recorded, depending on class setup.

Purpose:

To assess your understanding of stakeholder roles in materials development and demonstrate argumentation, collaboration, and presentation skills.

Rubrics for Debate + Slide

Grading Scale:

• 45–50: Outstanding
  Exceptional preparation, reasoning, and presentation; all criteria met at a high level.

• 37–44: Proficient
  Solid understanding and delivery; some areas for improvement but overall effective.

• 30–36: Developing
  Basic engagement with the topic; needs improvement in clarity, support, or teamwork.

• Below 30: Needs Improvement
  Major areas of weakness in reasoning, structure, participation, or visual presentation.