In this opinionated article, Melanie discusses the 2025 Grammy awards and whether they were fair and accurate.
The 2025 Grammy Awards were nothing short of controversial. From Beyoncé securing her 35th Grammy to Sabrina Carpenter winning her first, the night was filled with wins and disappointments. According to the official Grammy website, Beyoncé won Album of the Year, Kendrick Lamar’s “Not Like Us” took home both Record and Song of the Year, and Chappell Roan was named Best New Artist. Meanwhile, Short n’ Sweet won Best Pop Vocal Album, and Best Pop Solo Performance went to Sabrina Carpenter’s “Espresso”.
One of the night’s biggest talking points was Kendrick Lamar’s five Grammy wins, with "Not Like Us” dominating the competition. However, this victory does not feel entirely justified. Take “Espresso” by Sabrina Carpenter, for example. According to Spotify, “Espresso” has over 1.9 billion streams, significantly surpassing "Not Like Us”, which has only one billion. Given these numbers, one could argue that “Espresso” was more deserving of Record of the Year. While “Not Like Us” was a impressive cultural moment, “Expresso” was the song of the entire summer, and deserved more recognition.
The Album of the Year category was another major source of debate. Nominees included The Tortured Poets Department by Taylor Swift, BRAT by Charli XCX, Hit Me Hard and Soft by Billie Eilish, Short n’ Sweet by Sabrina Carpenter, The Rise and Fall of a Midwest Princess by Chappell Roan, and Cowboy Carter by Beyoncé. Ultimately, the award went to Beyoncé’s Cowboy Carter, a decision that many fans and critics found unfair. Statistically, The Tortured Poets Department amassed over 2.7 billion streams on Spotify, while Hit Me Hard and Soft racked up 4.8 billion, both significantly outperforming Cowboy Carter, which sits at just 1.7 billion.
Beyoncé’s extensive Grammy history continues to raise questions. With 35 wins to her name, her latest album, Cowboy Carter, leaned heavily into pop influences yet still won both Album of the Year and Best Country Album. This decision sparked backlash, as many felt it robbed country artists like Chris Stapleton and Lainey Wilson, as well as pop performers like Taylor Swift and Billie Eilish. Moreover, Beyoncé’s nomination for Best Country Song felt particularly misplaced, as Cowboy Carter was not widely embraced by the country music community. Given these factors, many argue she was undeserving of three Grammy wins this year, due to the more hybrid “pop country” genre of the album. According to CBS News, another standout track this year was “Die With a Smile” by Bruno Mars and Lady Gaga, which gathered 1.8 billion streams. Many believe it rightfully deserved Best Pop Duo. While some awards, such as Best Pop Vocal Album and Best New Artist, seemed fair, others felt outdated and unreflective of popular opinion.
The Grammys have once again left audiences questioning their credibility. When looking at streaming numbers alone, it is clear that some awards should have gone differently. “Not Like Us” and Cowboy Carter simply did not match the popularity of other nominees, raising concerns about industry biases and insider connections. With streaming platforms offering transparent metrics on music consumption, the Grammys should adjust their selection process to better reflect public engagement, rather than votes by Recording Academy members.