Throughout early 1859, radical abolitionist John Brown raised money from other abolitionists and ordered weapons — pikes and guns — to be used in his war against slavery. He was planning to raid the federal arsenal, a place for making and storing guns and ammunition, in Harpers Ferry, VA. His goal was to establish an independent stronghold of formerly enslaved people in the mountains of Maryland and Virginia from which they would fight to liberate all enslaved people. He gained financial and moral support from several Boston abolitionists.
On Sunday, October 16, 1859, Brown called his men together. Following a prayer, he outlined his battle plans and led them in the raid. Sixteen people were killed. John Brown was captured and jailed. He was put on trial for conspiring with enslaved people to rebel and treason against the state of Virginia. Brown was found guilty and executed on December 2, 1859. A contemporary newspaper account foretold a grim future. "The Harpers Ferry invasion has advanced the cause of disunion more than any other event that has happened since the formation of the Government."
Reverend Eden B. Foster, the minister of Lowell’s John Street Congregational Church, was active in the city’s antislavery circles. In response to John Brown’s unsuccessful raid on Harpers Ferry, Rev. Foster felt torn. He regarded Brown’s raid as not only a mistake, but a crime. A month after the raid, Rev. Foster preached this sermon at his Lowell church.
Dissolution: The act or process of dissolving: such as a separation into component parts
Infallible: Incapable of error: unerring
Benedict Arnold: An American Revolutionary War general and traitor who deserted the Continental Army for the British Army. His name has entered the lexicon as a synonym for someone who has betrayed their country.
… If the Republican party, as a party, or if any considerable portion of the honest men of the party, justify John Brown, the door is opened for the incursion of whites into the Slave States to incite slave rebellion. The Slave States will not endure that principle for an hour. Dissolution of the Union and civil war will come, with infallible and fatal certainty, if the North adopt that platform. I have always maintained that we had not the slightest right to interference, in the Slave States, by force and arms. Argument, love, and persuasion are all the weapons that we, as individuals, can employ. Congressional discussion and enactment, and peaceful legislation, are all the weapons we can employ as States. … I am living under the same constitution with the Slave States. I have accepted that constitution. … That constitution does not allow me to incite slave rebellion. The moment I do it I am a traitor to the government of my country as much as Benedict Arnold was. … I hold to the just right of revolution, if there be just cause. But when I head a revolution, it will be one of constitutions, of general principles, of universal authorities and laws; not an attack on Harper's Ferry (sic), nor an assassination of unarmed Southerners. …
What are Foster’s concerns about justifying John Brown’s actions?
How does Foster understand the role of the Constitution in slavery?
What other “weapons” does Foster suggest as alternatives to those used by Brown in his raid?
When, if ever, is political violence justified?