Clementine Averill was born in Milford, New Hampshire, in 1815 and worked in Lowell’s Boott Cotton Mills. She wrote this letter, published in The Weekly Tribune, in response to a statement by Senator Jeremiah Clemens of Alabama, printed in many New England newspapers, in which he said “the Southern slaves are better off than the Northern operatives.”
Operatives: Another word for mill workers, who operate machines
“Three to five dollars a week”: Depending on their job in the mill, the average pay of an operative was between three to five dollars a week in 1850
Poor-house: A house maintained by a church or other authority for poor people living on public charity
Mr. Clemens, -- Sir, in some of the late papers I have read several questions which you asked concerning the New England operatives. They have been well answered perhaps, but enough has not yet been said, and I deem it proper that the operatives should answer for themselves.
1st, You wish to know what pay we have .... Hundreds of girls in these mills clear from three to five dollars a week, while others, who have not been here long, and are not used to the work, make less than two dollars ....
2d, Children are never taken from their parents and put into the mill. What an idea! No person has a right to take a child from its parents, whether they be black or white, bond or free, unless there is danger of the child’s suffering harm by remaining with its parents. Girls come here from the country of their own free will, because they can earn more money, and because they wish to see and know more of the world ....
4th, We never work more than twelve and a half hours a day; the majority would not be willing to work less, if their earnings were less, as they only intend working a few years, and they wish to make all they can while here, for they have only one object in view.
5th, When operatives are sick they select their own physician, and usually have money enough laid by to supply all their wants. If they are sick long, and have not money enough, those who have give to them freely; for let me tell you, there is warm-hearted charity here, as well as hard work and economy.
6th, I have inquired, but have not ascertained that one person ever went from a factory to a poor-house in this city.
8th, The factory girls generally marry, and their husbands are expected to care for them when old. There are some, however, who do not marry, but such often have hundreds and thousands of dollars at interest; if you do not believe it, come and examine the bank-books and railroad stocks for yourself.
9th, We have as much and as good food as we want. We usually have warm biscuit, or nice toast and pie, with good bread and butter, coffee and tea, for breakfast; for dinner, meat and potatoes, with vegetables, tomatoes, and pickles, pudding or pie, with bread, butter, coffee and tea; for supper we have nice bread or warm biscuit, with some kind of sauce, cake, pie, and tea. But these questions seem to relate merely to our animal wants. We have all that is necessary for the health and comfort of the body, if that is all; and the richest person needs no more. But is the body all? Have we no minds to improve, no hearts to purify? ... Do you think we would come here and toil early and late with no other object in view than the gratification of mere animal propensities? ...
Let us see whether the “Southern slaves are better off than the Northern operatives.” As I have said, we have all that is necessary for health and comfort. Do the slaves have more? It is in the power of every young girl who comes here to work, if she has good health and no one but herself to provide for, to acquire every accomplishment, and get as good an education as any lady in the country. Have the slaves that privilege? By giving two weeks’ notice we can leave when we please, visit our friends, attend any school, or travel for pleasure or information. ... Can the slaves leave when they please, and go where they please? are they allowed to attend school, or travel for pleasure, and sit at the same table with any gentleman or lady? Some of the operatives of this city have been teachers in institutions of learning in your own State. Why do your people send here for teachers if your slaves are better off than they? Shame on the man who would stand up in the Senate of the United States, and say that the slaves at the South are better off than the operatives of New England; such a man is not fit for any office in a free country. Are we torn from our friends and kindred, sold and driven about like cattle, chained and whipped, and not allowed to speak one word in self-defense? We can appeal to the laws for redress, while the slaves cannot. ... In closing, I must say that I pity not only the slave, but the slaveowner. I pity him for his want of principle, for his hardness of heart and wrong education. May God, in his infinite mercy, convince all pro-slavery men of the great sin of holding their fellow-men in bondage!
CLEMENTINE AVERILL.
Summarize Averill’s points regarding the differences between the lives of mill girls and enslaved people.
Given what Averill says here, what questions do you think Clemens asked?
In her closing, Averill notes, "I must say that I pity not only the slave, but the slaveowner. I pity him for his want of principle, for his hardness of heart and wrong education. May God, in his infinite mercy, convince all pro-slavery men of the great sin of holding their fellow-men in bondage!" What does she mean when she says that she pities the slaveowner? What does she hope for all “pro-slavery men”?
Compare Averill’s description of work in Lowell’s textile mills to the one that Charles Dana gives in his “Whip of Necessity” article (Document 31).
What makes Clementine Averill a convincing respondent to Mr. Clemens?