Making a Document Accessible
By Peter Berryman, MFA
Georgia Southern University
Five Steps to an Accessible Syllabus
Document Structure
Good document structure supports all types of learners by improving the organization and presentation of information. The following recommendations apply to all text-based files including HTML (Web), Word, and PowerPoint.
Using Heading Styles
You may already use headings and sub-headings, but are you creating them correctly? Most text-based applications include a Style Menu [ Figure 1] that allows you to select heading levels such as Heading 1, Heading 2, Heading 3, etc.
Figure 1: Word Styles Menu
When you apply heading styles to your text, you not only help all users understand how the content of your document is organized into sections, but you also activate a screen-reader feature that allows visually-disabled users to use a keystroke (H) to navigate from header to header and content section to content section.
Proper Document Hierarchy
Use a heading or sub-heading each time the content of your document changes. Think of headings as an outline of your document content. Heading styles should be used in descending order of importance.
Example of proper document hierarchy:
Heading 1 Style
Heading 2 Style
Heading 3 Style
Heading 3 Style
Heading 2 Style
Heading 3 Style
Heading 3 Style
Use only one Heading 1 Style for each document. Assign Heading 2 Styles to each section and Heading 3 Styles to each sub-section.
Watch: Web Headings for Screen Readers.
List Styles
List Styles
Use the list styles available in every text editor [Figure 2]. Unordered lists or bullet lists help everyone understand how information is grouped by a common theme. Ordered lists use alphanumeric characters to indicate importance or steps in a process. Using software-supported lists helps screen readers to describe to visually-impaired users how the information is grouped and organized.
Paragraphs
Break long passages of text into shorter paragraphs of five sentences or less. Paragraphs help students avoid eye fatigue, especially when reading online using small digital displays like smart phones. Think about the white space between paragraphs as opportunities for students to breathe and think quickly about what they just read. Help them “breathe” at a comfortable rate.
Typography
For all types of documents designed to be read on-screen (Word, PowerPoint, PDF), it is best to use common fonts that are easy to read and found on virtually all computers.
For Web content published to your learning management system (Web pages, announcements, discussions), the Learning Management System (LMS) administrators have already selected the type styles that work best for your online courses. Use the default font styles.
Sans-Serif or Serif Fonts?
The most legible fonts for digital displays are typically sans-serif — which are traditionally composed of the simplest geometric shapes. Serif fonts often have contrasting thick and thin strokes as well as tiny “serifs” or hooks which can be hard to see on low resolution computer screens and cell phone displays
Common Sans-Serif Fonts
For Word, PowerPoint, and other documents meant to be read on-screen, use one of the following common sans-serif fonts:
Verdana: The easiest to read on-screen with large lower-case letters.
Arial: Similar to Verdana, but a little more compressed.
Trebuchet: Has a little more design flair than Verdana or Arial. A bit smaller than Verdana or Arial. Use a slightly larger size.
Common Serif Fonts
There is no rule that says you cannot use a serif font. Some are easier to read on-screen than others. One of the best common serif fonts is Georgia, which was designed specifically for display on computer screens.
Font Size
For Word, PowerPoint, and PDF documents meant to be read on-screen, ten-point type is considered the appropriate starting point for your smallest font size. For Heading levels (H1, H2, H3…), the higher the level in the hierarchy, the larger the font.
Examples of Heading Sizes:
Heading 1: 24 points
Heading 2: 18 points
Heading 3: 14 points
Text: 10 to 12 points
Reminder: For Web (HTML) content, it may be best to use the default styles set by the LMS administrators.
Bold and Italic Font Styles
Use bold or italic font styles selectively. Too much of either creates a very “noisy” look that becomes difficult for everyone to read.
Appropriate application of bold or italic styles:
Emphasize key concepts or vocabulary terms.
For academic convention such as book and movie titles (e.g. Ferris Bueller's Day Off).
Foreign words in an English text (e.g. "The Spanish word for cat is el gato.").
Tables
A table is a grid of cells arranged in columns and rows. Tables are typically used to organize information like:
numerical data
schedules or calendars
grading criteria and rubrics
employee contact information
Table Structures
Tables are typically filled with information grouped by columns or rows, or sometimes both
How Screen Readers Read Tables
By default, screen readers read data tables in linear order, left to right and top to bottom. But what if the data should be read by column? By creating headers for each column, visually-impaired users can change the reading order to suit their preferences. For example, users could change the reading order to (1, 4, 7), (2, 5, 8), or (3,6,9).
Table Headers for Microsoft Word and PowerPoint
Microsoft and PowerPoint have limited, but still useful, features for assigning headers to data cells at the top of each column. The primary shortcoming is the inability of Word and PowerPoint to set the first cell of each row as a header. However, because table data is read row by row and left to right, students will be able to sufficiently understand how information is organized by rows.
With a table selected, under the Table Design tab, check [ ] Header Row
Right-click on the table and choose Table Properties. If you check [ ] Allow row to break across pages, also check [ ] Repeat as header row at the top of each page, [Figure 4]. When tables break across two pages, it is very helpful to have the header row at the top of each table section.
Don’t forget to create labels for the data cells at the top of each column. Labels should describe the types of content in the column. You may also change the visual presentation of the header cells to help all users recognize that the labels are not part of the data set
Other Table Markup
Alternative Text
Microsoft Word and PowerPoint suggest creating alternative text for tables. Use Table Properties > Alt Text and enter a summary of how data is organized in the Description field. Alternative text is really only necessary if the table structure is quite complex – in which case you may want to see if you can simplify the table structure first.
Captions
Some accessibility checkers for Web (HTML) pages will recommend table captions.
Images and Text Equivalents
Photos, illustrations, graphics, charts, maps, and other types of images present significant obstacles for learners who cannot see the images. Text equivalents are written summaries needed by learners to understand the pertinent information embedded within the images.
There are two types of text equivalents:
Alternative Text: Alternative Text is added directly to images placed in digital files as metadata – meaning that the text equivalent can only be perceived by screen readers and read aloud to learners with visual impairments. Otherwise, alternative text is hidden from all other learners. Alternative Text is meant to be short and concise. Otherwise, use long descriptions.
Long Descriptions: When images require text equivalents of more than one sentence, the best option is to publish a written description in the same context (on the same page) as the image. Long Descriptions can be used to help all learners understand the meanings of complex images.
Alternative Text
Alternative Text (ALT Text) is best used for simple images requiring descriptions no longer than one sentence – maybe two – since it only needs to provide information pertinent to what learners need to know. This can change depending on context.
For example, if you illustrate a written description of a historical event using an image such as “Washington Crossing the Delaware “ by Emanuel Leutze [Figure 1], users with visual impairments only need to know what the image represents, “General George Washington crosses the Delaware River”. In this context, the type of image (painting), name of artist, or year are not necessary because the information is not needed by learners for any purpose in the course – unless you wish to provide the appropriate attribution.
Figure 1: Washington Crossing the Delaware, painting by Emanuel Leutze, 1851.
However, if you specifically chose this painting [Figure 1] to illustrate the conditions under which Washington crossed the Delaware River, you might provide more descriptive Alternative Text such as, “General George Washington and the Continental Army struggling against wind and ice to cross the Delaware River, December 25, 1976”.
Alert! Figures and image captions help all users understand how text relates to image, but image captions do not replace alternative text.
Tips for Writing Effective Alternate Text
Effective alternative text should:
Be accurate and equivalent in presenting the same content and function of the image.
Be succinct. Content and function (if present) should be described as succinctly as is appropriate – typically no more than a few words.
Not be redundant or provide the same information presented in context with the image.
Not include phrases such as “image of…” or “graphic of…” since screen readers will announce the presence of an image.
-- Tips for writing effective alternative text provided by WebAIM.org.
Alternative Text for Images in Word and PowerPoint Documents
Follow these instructions for adding Alternative Text:
Place an image in a Word document.
Right-click on the image and choose Format Picture.
Select Size & Properties tab in the Format Picture menu.
Enter the Alternative Text in the Description field
The Title field is not used for equivalent text.
Long Description
There's good reason for the saying, “an image is worth a thousand words! “ Some types of images such as charts, graphs, and maps may require much Longer Descriptions than one or two sentences because of the amount and complexity of the information they convey visually.
Long Descriptions are typically provided in the same context the image is published – on the same page. To write effective Long Descriptions, limit yourself to the pertinent information by asking yourself, “What do students need to know? Do they need to know just the names of the parts, or do they need to know how the eye is constructed? “
Note: If you do not wish to make Long Descriptions of images available to all users, create alternate documents with full descriptions of complex images in advance of your course and release them selectively as needed.
What About Decorative Images
Images used for decoration only do not require text equivalents since they have no meaning. However, because students may still wonder if the alternative text is missing or forgotten, consider adding a short description such as “decoration”.