Media Language
Representation
Contexts
Semiotics- Barthes
Post-Modernism- Jean Baudrillard
Representation- bell hooks' feminist theory and Paul Gilroy ethnicity and post-colonial theory
Product Context
"Formation" was released in Feb 2016, a day before Beyoncé’s Super Bowl performance.
Directed by Melina Matsoukas; critically acclaimed and award-winning.
Set against the backdrop of Hurricane Katrina and U.S. racial tensions.
Includes historical references to racism and slavery.
Media Language
Rich in intertextual references (e.g., That B.E.A.T. documentary, police brutality footage).
Contrasting elements: antebellum/slavery-era costumes vs. pop aesthetics; aggressive gestures vs. dance routines.
Raises questions: Black experience? Gender issues? Beyoncé’s personal story?
Genre
Mixes pop, R&B, hip-hop, bounce; challenges fixed genre categories.
“Bounce” genre reflects cultural and regional identity.
Representation
Representation of Individuals
Beyoncé’s image: powerful, assertive, commanding (e.g., atop police car).
Constructed persona may blend authentic identity with branding.
Values, Attitudes, Beliefs
Subverts racial norms by portraying Black power.
Gender representation is complex:
Empowerment vs. objectification (e.g., revealing costumes, dance).
Contexts
Historical Context
References Hurricane Katrina and racial tensions (e.g., Kanye West’s comment on Bush).
Encourages audience reflection on racial history and context.
Economic & Political Context
Released for maximum impact/profit before Super Bowl.
Sparks debate: Political/cultural message vs. commercial intent?
Theoretical Perspectives
Barthes (Semiotics): Use of signs like antebellum dresses to signify slavery and racial history.
Baudrillard (Postmodernism): Contrasts between symbolic imagery and real-world references.
bell hooks (Feminism): Is Beyoncé promoting feminism or commodifying it? Mixed signals: empowerment vs. patriarchal reinforcement.
Paul Gilroy (Ethnicity/Postcolonial Theory): Challenges racial hierarchies by placing a Black woman in power. May still reflect binary racial divisions (us vs. them).