Developing and Implementing Change
"A field of academic study and professional practice that uses social and behavioral science knowledge to develop interventions that help organizations and individuals change successfully" (Anderson, 2019, p. 17)
In other words, creating change within an organization to increase success.
Anderson (2019) offers a platform in which we can see the changes in what Organization Development looked like each decade, dating back to the 1940s. We see the thought process behind what is considered the “First Generation Organization Development” (1940s-1970s) as well as the “Second Generation Organization Development” (1980s - present). Throughout time, we see a shift in what is important for an organization to adapt and change in a way that is effective toward meeting their goals.
Laboratory Training and T-Groups
Study patterns of group behavior, social problems, and the influence of leadership on a group.
Scientific methods can be used to gather data about groups and intervene in their processes
Management Practices
Alternative ways of managing.
Explicit and implicit assumptions influence managers.
Quality and Employee Involvement
Employees are involved in noticing defects and taking action to prevent or correct them.
Organizational Culture
Decipher how things are done, and the hidden meanings and assumptions that characterize how organizational members interpret and make sense of what is happening.
Change Management, Strategic Change, and Reengineering
Connecting OD practitioner work to larger, organization wide goals.
Ability to adapt to change.
Address the organization’s vision, mission, goals, and strategy.
Organizational Learning
Problem solving.
Self-reflection.
Single-loop learning: correcting mistakes as they occur.
Double-loop learning: question or modify to prevent errors the next time.
Deuteron learning: members understand how and when they learn - develop an environment in which learning can occur.
Organizational Effectiveness and Employee Engagement
Effectiveness of organization.
Employee engagement - an individual’s involvement and satisfaction with work and their enthusiasm for work.
Agility and Collaboration
Ability to develop and be flexible.
Timely, effective, and sustained changes within the organization.
Ability to sense the need for change.
Fast. Flexible. Focused.
Collaboration with others.
What are Culture and Values?
Culture and values can be seen as a person's beliefs and experiences.
These help guide an individual in their decision making.
Role of Culture, Values and Ethics in OD Practice
OD culture, values and ethics are used to help direct choices about:
What client engagements to accept
What data gathering strategies should be employed
How the feedback to a client should be managed
What interventions should be selected
How the intervention that is chosen should be designed (Anderson, 2019)..
What are Culture, Values, and Ethics Important in the OD Process?
They guide choices on how to proceed. They help when we are uncertain of what to do or when we have difference choices regarding what to do.
They offer a larger vision. They help us to meet a purpose that is greater than just one individual, and rather a community.
They focus on ways to ensure growth, development, learning, and self-evaluation.
They promote dialogue and clarity.
Ethics guide practitioners in how to implement and enact values.
Ethics involves putting these values into play to help create the change desired within an organization and doing so in the most humane manner.
(Anderson, 2019)
Common Values in OD
Participation, involvement, and empowerment.
The importance of groups and teams.
Growth, development, and learning.
Valuing the whole person.
Dialogue and collaboration.
Authenticity, openness, and trust.
(Anderson, 2019).
(Sinek, 2009)
My Interpretation of The Role Purpose Plays
When I think about an organization, the first thought that crosses my mind is "what do they do?"
It is not until after that initial thought of what do they do that I start to think about why they do what they do.
When we can identify the purpose of an organization, we are able to identify the importance of that agency and “sell” those services to others.
"What you do proves what you believe" (Sinek, 2009).
My Example of Purpose in My Organization
St. Joseph’s Addiction Treatment Center - When I first heard of this organization, my thought was “they treat people who suffer from drug and/or alcohol addiction.”
Once I started to work for St. Joseph’s – and get more familiar with the field of addiction – I began to think differently and my thinking eventually shifted to “promoting healing and recovery for individuals, families, and communities."
Allied Universal Podcast
LaDonna Powell shares the issues within the Allied Universal Organization and the impact this had on employees. (Joffe-Walt, 2018).
Joffe-Walt's podcast interview with LaDonna connected to the other course material that has been discussed thus far.
Case Study Connections
Sinek (2009) explains that most companies discuss the what and the how. However, they often discuss the why last, or not at all. Allied Universal identified a single purpose: “to keep people, businesses, and communities safe so we can all thrive together” (Allied Universal, 2021).
Organizational Effectiveness and Employee Engagement - how effective an organization is in achieving what it intended to achieve/produce, as well as an individual’s involvement and satisfaction with work/their enthusiasm with work (Anderson, 2019). As evidenced in Joffe-Walt (2018), LaDonna decided to take over employee training. She was engaged with employees and had high hopes of changing the culture at Allied Universal.
“By humanistic we mean that individuals deserve respect, are trustworthy, and want to achieve personal growth and satisfaction. Humanistic values also include a belief in the equity and equality of people, democratic principles, and a belief in human dignity and worth” (Anderson, 2019, p. 51). The management of Allied Universal demonstrated the opposite of a humanistic approach based on the way they treated women, people of other races, and other minorities. In addition, they did not create a trusting environment and did not create respect between workers – rather they created feelings of being unsafe and less then.
Steps I Would Take as an OD Practitioner
To begin, I would want to emphasize the value of creating authenticity, openness, and trust. “Being authentic means being straightforward, genuine, honest, and truthful about one’s plans, opinions, and motivations” (Anderson, 2019, p. 58).
If the priority of Allied Universal is to keep people, businesses, and communities safe (Allied Universal, 2021) they need to establish a rapport which entails being authentic, trustworthy, and open with others about your intentions.
I would also work to emphasize the importance of valuing the whole person. “Respecting the whole person means acknowledging and recognizing diversity and the benefits that individual differences bring to an organization” (Anderson, 2019, p. 55).
“Our relationships with our employees and clients are at the core and heart of everything we do, every day” (Allied Universal, 2021). If this is the motto that Allied Universal wishes to believe, and implement, they would need to recognize the importance of valuing the whole person, and acknowledging that other people have thoughts, feelings, and are human beings and should be treated as such.
Levels and Types of Change
Levels
Change can be planned or unplanned and can occur at different levels (Anderson, 2019):
Individual
Group/Team
Intergroup
Organizational
Suprasystem (multiple organziations are implicated)
Types
First Order
Alterations or changes to existing practices
Second Order
Modifications in the frameworks themselves
Episodic
Distinct periods of change
Continuous
Idea that the organization never truly stops changing
Systems Theory and its Value
Tries to gain an understanding of how subparts within an environment relate to one another (Anderson, 2019).
Value
Offers useful explanations for human behavior in organizations while paying attention to roles and structures rather than individual characteristics (Anderson, 2019).
By understanding the system and its dynamics, the OD practitioner have a more appropriate place to start interventions for change
OD practitioners can be more deliberate about the changes being proposed and the possible negative results that can be predicted
Models of Organizational Change
Lewin's Three Phase Model of Change and Force Field Analysis
Unfreezing --> Moving --> Refreezing
Current practices need to be released to be changed, and once changed they are "refrozen" as newly adopted regular practices
There may be forces supporting the change, and some resisting the change
Nadler-Tushman Congruence Model
Emphasis on the transformational process and reflects interdependence
Points to areas that affect one another so that changes in other parts of the system can be noted/controlled
Burke-Litwin Model of Organizational Performance and Change
Specifies the variables that would be affected by a given change
Takes into account first-order and second-order change
Weisbord's Six-Box Model
Depicts the interrelationships among six of an organization's component parts (Purpose, Structure, Rewards, Relationships, Helpful Mechanisms, and Leadership)
Helps illustrate how symptons can be seen in a ystemic light
(Anderson, 2019)
Social Construct and Its Values
Social construction view argues the organization is a concept developed out of our own actions and language.
This approach sees change as a continuous process rather than a specific project.
Offers a useful explanation for human behavior.
Emphasizes the active role members take in creating an organization.
Helps OD practitioners see the importance of communication in creating change.
Stresses that organizational change has as its foundation a change in meaning.
(Anderson, 2019)
Consulting Models
Expert Model
Consultants are hired for specialized content knowledge in a particular field
Doctor-Patient Model
Consultants are hired when consultants possess content knowledge and clients want to be told what the solution is
Mechanic Model
Consultants are hired when the client wants the consultant to deal with all elements of the problem and to propose and implement a solution
(Anderson, 2019)
OD Consultant, Skills, and Competencies
An OD consultant plays multiple roles within a consulting engagment (facilitator, coach, teacher, researcher)
Skills and Competencies
Interpersonal Skills and Personal Characteristics
Organizational Behavior
Data Collection & Analysis
Training & Development
Business & Management Knowledge Areas
General Professional Skills
Consulting Skills
Interventions
(Anderson, 2019)
Action Research and Consulting
Action Research
"The process of using social scientific reserach practices to gather data about groups, intervene in their processes, and evaluate the results of the intervention" (Anderson, 2019, p. 117)
Action Research Process
Problem Definition and Diagnosis
Action Planning
Taking Action
Evaluation Results
Consulting Process
Entry
Contracting
Data Gathering
Diagnosis
Feedback
Intervention
Evaluation and Exit
(Anderson, 2019)
What is Design Thinking?
Design thinking (Stevens, 2021):
Is user-centric
Seeks to understand people’s needs and come up with effective solutions to meet those needs
Fosters creativity and Innovation
Overview of My Pitch to Allied Universal
Overview:
I created a FlipGrid Video of my pitch to Allied Universal. The steps I took in this process included:
Discuss what I would define as the problem with Allied Universal that I would like to address, based on information from LaDonna Powell’s interview in a 2018 podcast.
Expand on this by discussing what intervention I believe would be best for this identified problem and why.
Share what model of organizational change discussed by Anderson appears to be the most relevant to the identified problem and intervention.
Takeaways from Writing to Win: How to quickly capture readers and keep them engaged (Abrahams and Kramon, 2021)
Avoid cliches
Avoid starting slow
BLUF (Bottom Line Up Front) - get to the point
Know as much as you can about your audience
Avoid jargon and be concise
The power of one and a story
Emotion is key in communication
Write your story, then return to write your introduction
Acknowledge the difference between constructive and destructive criticism
Diagnosis
Create Process for How Client Will Participate
Consultant and Client Identify a Mutual Interpretation of the Problem
Analyze the Data - Determine which analysis to use
Deductive Analysis
Acknowledge benefits and drawbacks to different models
Determine which model to use
Inductive Analysis
Create theme headlines that explaine the content of the data
Code Data
Statistical Analysis
Review statistics
Interpret meaning of statistics - avoid bias
(Anderson, 2019)
Feedback
Address any Ethical Issues
Select and Prioritize Themes to Share with the Client
Relevant
Influenceable or Manageable
Descriptive
Selective
Sufficient and Specific
Contracting Process
Address how and when feedback will be presented to the client
Structure Meeting
Determine environment meeting will be held
Determine day for meeting, time of meeting, length of meeting
Feedback Meeting
Present information to client
Share positive data
Provide appropriate amount of detail
Share statistics that illuminate the trends
Confront the tough issues
Address any client resistance
(Anderson, 2019)
Intervention
Identify What Interventions are and Their Purpose
Understand Reasons for Intervention Failure
Create plan to prevent this
Acknowledge Considerations for Selecting an Appropriate Intervention
Determine if intervention match data and diagnosis
Idenitfy client's readiness to change
Decide where to intervene first
Determine appropriate depth of intervention
Consider sequence of activities
Identify Ethical Issues
Create plan to address ethical issues
Structure/Plan Intervention
Determine approach to change
empirical - rational approach
Normative - reeducative approach
Power - coercive approach
Create opportunity for learning
Give free choice
Provide clear and explicit outcomes
Identify different types of intervention and select most appropriate
Individual intervention
Team intervention
Whole organization intervention
(Anderson, 2019)
My Process for Developing Checklist
For my checklist, I:
Read through chapters 8 and 9 of the course textbook.
While doing so, I took notes of the different steps I was able to identify through my reading.
After reading, I went online to a checklist template.
I selected a template that included some color and “pop,” however was not too distracting (in my opinion).
I revisited my notes, looking at the different steps I had written down.
I eliminated the duplicates, however kept note of what order they presented in the reading.
I then used arrows to structure the steps in an order that made sense to me and that I believe would be useful in the OD process.
Once I had my steps in order in my notes, I began to fill in the online template with my steps.
Once I had my steps within the template, I added my name at the bottom as the author, the title of this course, and the reference for our course textbook. I saved my checklist as a PDF file.
As the Practitioner
For the case of Logan Elementary School, the principal, Nancy, wanted to make improvements such as:
Improving relationships among faculty and staff
Build consistency in approach among teachers at each grade level
Improve the relationship between the school and the community (Anderson, 2019).
I put myself in the shoes of the practitioner who was asked to interview staff, faculty members, and parents over one weeks’ time.
The goal of this was to better understand the issues facing the school.
From there, I was able to collect, analyze, sort, interpret, select, and prioritize the data obtained.
After this, I worked to structure a meeting with Nancy to review the data as well as discuss what themes were observed through these interviews.
What I Found
Through my diagnosis I discovered:
100% of the feedback from grades 2 thru 4 were concerns
100% of the feedback from grade 5 pertaining directly to Nancy was positive
For the teachers of unknown grades, 80% of the feedback was concerns
For staff, 33% of the feedback was concerns
For parents, 100% of the feedback directly related to Nancy was positive
The following are the main concerns that I identified and prioritized, based on the feedback from teachers, staff, and parents at Logan Elementary School:
Perceived favoritism/lack of support (30% of the concerns)
Faculty meeting (34% of the concerns)
Budget cuts and their impact (19%)
Feedback for Nancy
Schedule a meeting with Nancy for Monday afternoon at 1:00 PM.
Length of meeting: 2 hours
Location: reserved office space at the Logan High School
Provide Nancy with positive remarks that came from the interviewees regarding what is going well within the school.
Discuss with Nancy the common themes within the data and provide addition feedback regarding each concern. These concerns will include:
Perceived favoritism/lack of support (30% of concerns)
Faculty meetings (34% of concerns)
Budget cuts and their impact (19% of concerns)
Process information with Nancy
Determine next steps
Conclude meeting
Abrahams, M. & Kramon, G. (Hosts). (2021, January 11). Writing to win: How to quickly capture readers and keep them engaged. [Audio podcast episode]. In Think Fast Talk Smart. https://www.gsb.stanford.edu/insights/writing-win-how-quickly-capture-readers-keep-them-engaged
Allied Universal. (2021). There for you. https://www.aus.com./
Anderson, D. (2019). Organization development: The process of leading organizational change. (5th ed.). Sage.
Joffe-Walt, H. (Host). (2018, May 25). LaDonna. (No. 647) [Audio podcast episode]. In This American Life. NPR. Original: https://www.thisamericanlife.org/647/ladonna
Sinek, S. (2009, September). How great leaders inspire action. [Video]. TED Conferences. https://www.ted.com/talks/simon_sinek_how_great_leaders_inspire_action/up-next?language=en#t-335084
Stevens, E. (2021, May 17). What is design thinking? A comprehensive beginner’s guide. CareerFoundry. https://careerfoundry.com/en/blog/ux-design/what-is-design-thinking-everything-you-need-to-know-to-get-started/