District: Uptown - Partial Control
Owner: Ian Fitzgerald Taylor
HDLC Staff: Jesse Stephenson
Rating: Contributing
Applicant: Ian Fitzgerald Taylor
Description: Demolition of more 25% of the primary façade on a Contributing rated, two-story, two-family residential building.
Previous ARC Recommendations & Commission Actions:
03/01/23: Defer action on this application until the next Commission meeting so that you may attend, as per your request.
Staff Recommendations:
Based on FEMA Survey research 6028 Benjamin was constructed from 1925-35 in the period of significance. However, the building does not show up on Fire Insurance Maps until 1951. At that time, the dashed line at the front of the building denotes a two story portion condition. The building has retained its form, massing, and details through preservation. The encapsulation of the front porches and the alteration of the entry sequence would greatly impact the integrity of the well maintained block face. Staff does not believe the alteration of the front elevation to be appropriate.
Staff Recommendation: Denial of the request Demolition of more than 25% of the primary façade.
Existing Elevation: 764.4 SQFT
Demolition: 46.2 SQFT
Encapsulation: 448.9 SQFT
Total Demolition: 495.1 (64.8%)
1909 Fire Insurance, Revised 1951