Guidance and Resources – Subfertility
Case Introduction – Subfertility
Further Case Information – Subfertility
Background Science – Subfertility
Case Conclusion – Subfertility
Formative Assessment – Subfertility
CASE Women’s Health – Subfertility
The term subfertility is used to describe unwanted delay of 2 years in achieving conception despite regular unprotected sexual intercourse. It affects 15% of the population in the UK and, as women nowadays embark on conceiving pregnancies later in their lives, the incidence of subfertility is increasing. Advancing female age negatively affects the chances of both natural conception as well as assisted conception. Most cases have relative subfertility which can be attributed to one or more factors in one or both partners, whilst a small number have absolute infertility (i.e. impossible to conceive). Experiencing difficulty in conceiving can be extremely stressful to couples and often requires support during investigations and treatments.
CASE COMPONENT
Guidance and Resources – Subfertility MED 35
In case Women’s Health – Subfertility
eBooks
1)Johns Hopkins Handbook of Obstetrics & Gynecology.
2)Gynaecology by ten teachers,20th edition
3) Hacker and Moore’s essentials of obstetrics and gynecology,6th edition.
http://www.cmft.nhs.uk/saint-marys/our-services/andrology/reference-ranges-for-semen-analysis
https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/cg156/chapter/recommendations#intrauterine-insemination
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6ebGQy9vVEc PGD Illustrated
CASE COMPONENT
Case Introduction – Subfertility MED 35
In case Women’s Health – Subfertility
Ms Emma Mathews, a 32-year-old accountant, and her husband Mr Mark Smith, a 35-year-old Marketing Manager, attended the fertility clinic with a one-year history of secondary subfertility. The couple were having regular intercourse approximately 3–4 times a week. Emma had two children from a previous marriage.
Emma had an IUCD inserted for three years earlier, following the birth of her second child, George, who was delivered by emergency caesarean section because of foetal distress. Postnatally, Emma had an episode of endometritis, which was treated with antibiotics. The coil was removed because the couple wanted to try to conceive, and also because she thought the coil was causing her painful periods.
Emma’s first child, Amy, was a normal delivery. Before Emma’s first pregnancy, she used the oral contraceptive pill. However, the pill caused her side effects and therefore she opted for the coil after George’s birth.
Emma had not had any surgery other than the caesarean section. She said that she smokes 10 cigarettes per day. She had no known allergies and her BMI was 32.
Emma attained menarche at the age of 12 years. Her cycles were always irregular, ranging from 30 to 90 days in length and that her periods were heavy and painful.
She also complained of acne and some facial hair which she needed to have laser treatment for. Her cervical smears were up-to-date and they had always been normal. She was immune to rubella. Emma had chlamydia in the past; this was treated with antibiotics. A cervical swab done by her GP was negative for chlamydia.
Mark is not the father of George and Amy and had not fathered any pregnancies previously. He reported normal libido and erectile function with no problems with intercourse. Mark had normal pubertal development and shaved 4 times a week. He exercised at the gym 6 times a week, and used tight sport body wear. He smoked 5 cigarettes a day. His brother had Cystic Fibrosis but Mark had not been genetically tested before.
On examination, Mark had a muscular build with normal secondary sexual characteristics, Tanner stage 5 sexual development, with normal adult external genitalia. Testicles were soft and 15ml in volume. The Vas Deference was palpable on both sides.
The Tanner scale (also known as the Tanner stages) is a scale of physical development in children, adolescents and adults. The scale defines physical measurements of development based on external primary and secondary sex characteristics, such as the size of the breasts, genitals, testicular volume and development of pubic hair. – Images from Wikimedia Commons
Further Information: Tanner Scale (Wikipedia)
What are your thoughts so far?
Initial consultation should include full history from both partners as well as clinical examination. Regular coital frequency of two to three times weekly is usually recommended.
Look at the highlighted words in the case – think about why these are relevant to the couple’s presentation.
The history is important to try to establish important factors that may be affecting a couple’s chance of conceiving. First line investigations will add information and the combination of history and investigations should address the following:
1. Ovulation: is the woman ovulating? If anovulation, why?
2. Ovarian reserve: Good, satisfactory, poor, diminished?
3. Tubes and transport: is there a problem with the tubes?
4. Sperm: are sperms present in the ejaculate? If not present or reduced number, why?
What other main factors may influence Emma’s and Marks’s chance to conceive?
· Female age - extremely important with a significant reduction as women age
· Uterine function- endometrial problems, fibroid, polyps
· Duration of trying - couples who have a short duration of infertility are more likely to conceive both with or without treatment
· Lifestyle factors - e.g. obesity, excessive alcohol intake and smoking
· Medical history – you should also ensure that a patient’s medical condition is optimised for pregnancy e.g. good diabetic control. An infertility consultation is an important time for pre-conception counselling
· Previous pregnancy
What are the initial investigations?
The GP had performed initial hormone investigations to check Emma’s ovulatory function and ovarian reserveand her results were as follows:
· Day 3 FSH: 7.9 iu/l
· LH: 16.2 iu/l
· Serial progesterone levels on cycle day 21, 28, 35 and 42: 6, 7, 6 and 5nmol/l, respectively
· Negative pregnancy test
· AMH 86.6 pmol/l
The initial semen analysis arranged by the GP showed:
· PH 7.21
· Volume: 2.0 ml
· Count: 7 million/ml
· Progressive motility: 13%
· Normal forms: 5%.
Which of these factors influences spermatogenesis?
· Smoking
· Body-building drugs
· Male obesity
· Alcohol
· Smoking
Correct answer.
· Body-building drugs
.Correct answer.
· Male obesity
.Correct answer.
· Alcohol
.Correct answer.
What do you think of the results of Mark’s sperm sample?
Compare his results above with the World Health Organisation (WHO) reference values which are cited in the following NICE clinical guideline:
Semen analysis - Fertility problems: assessment and treatment [CG156]
At the fertility clinic the consultant advised the couple on adjustments to their lifestyle including quitting smoking cigarettes and cannabis as well as a reduction in Mark’s alcohol consumption. He advised Emma on targeted exercise in the aim of weight reduction and asked her to take Folic Acid and Vitamin D supplements.
The consultant suggested carrying out further investigations to find out the cause of Emma’s anovulation. He also explained to Mark that a repeat semen analysis was indicated as his first sample was oligospermic (low count), according to NICE guidelines.
Semen analysis – Fertility problems: assessment and treatment [CG156]
CASE COMPONENT
Further Case Information – Subfertility Med 35
In case Women’s Health – Subfertility
Emma reduced her BMI to 28 and her additional tests results were:
· Serum prolactin: 110 mIU/l
· TSH: 1.9 mIU/l
· Sex hormone-binding globulin: 23.0 nmol/l
· Testosterone: 1.7 nmol/l
The consultant reassured Emma that these results are normal.
Pelvic ultrasound demonstrated enlarged ovaries, each containing about 14 antral follicles. The uterus appeared of normal shape; however there was a small sub-mucosal fibroid and a second intra-mural fibroid. According to the revised Rotterdam Consensus Criteria of 2003, diagnosis of PCOS was made.
Polycystic ovary syndrome: what it means for your long-term health – RCOG
Transvaginal ultrasound scan of polycystic ovary – Note the follicles around the periphery of the ovary – classical feature of PCOS. Image by Schomynv on Wikimedia Commons
Polycystic Ovary Syndrome (PCOS)
Mark stopped smoking, stopped smoking cannabis and reduced his alcohol intake to approximately 5 units per week. A repeat of Mark’s semen analysis in 3 months showed
· PH: 7.23
· Volume: 3.2 ml
· Count: 28 million per ml
· Progressive motility: 28%
· Normal forms: 7%.
It was explained to the couple the semen analysis results showed remarkable improvement.
To check the patency of Emma’s fallopian tubes, the consultant explained to Emma that, in her case, Laparoscopy and Dye Test would be preferred to Hysterosalpingogram (HSG) or HysteroContrastSonosalpingogram (HyCoSy) as she is at an increased risk of adhesions and tubal pathologies because of the previous history of chlamydia and caesarean section. Additionally, further treatment, such as adhesiolysis, can be performed at the same time.
Tubal and uterine factors in infertility
Emma underwent a laparoscopy and dye test which confirmed that both tubes were patent to dye and her pelvis looked essentially normal, apart from enlarged ovaries in keeping with her diagnosis of PCOS. There was no evidence of endometriosis. A hysteroscopy was performed at the same procedure; the sub-mucous fibroid was resected and no intra-uterine adhesions were detected.
Endometriosis
Which of the following factors may affect tubal function?
· Pelvic surgery
· Endometriosis
· Infection: chlamydia, gonorrhoea, pelvic inflammatory disease
· Pelvic surgery
.Correct answer.
· Endometriosis
.Correct answer.
· Infection: chlamydia, gonorrhoea, pelvic inflammatory disease
.Correct answer.
The consultant explained to the couple that, since anovulation is now the main problem, ovulation induction with clomiphene citrate was an appropriate first step. It was arranged for Emma to take Clomiphene for 5 days from day 2–6 of the cycle. The first cycle was monitored with ultrasound to monitor follicle development and reduce the risk of multiple pregnancies. Mid-luteal (day 21) progesterone levels were carried out, but showed a low level of progesterone. Therefore the dose was increased to 100 mg resulting in ovulation and subsequent cycles did not require monitoring.
CASE COMPONENT
Background Science – Subfertility MED 35
In case Women’s Health – Subfertility
The menstrual cycle explained
Spermatogenesis
General factors affecting fertility
Age and fertility
Women’s fertility significantly declines in late thirties and in their forties. The fecudability of women at the age of 35–39 years (the chance of conceiving spontaneously) is half of that at the age 19–26 years. Whilst up to 80% of couples achieve a pregnancy within one year of trying when the female is younger than 35 years, this cumulative conception rate drops to 60% at 1 year and 85% at 2 years in women older than 35 years. Only 50% of women aged above 40 will be able to achieve conception.
As fertility declines with age, the risk of miscarriage and fetal chromosomal abnormalities, such as Down’s syndrome, increase. Due to socioeconomic changes in modern days, childbearing is delayed leading to marked reduction in couple’s ability to achieve pregnancies. In addition, advancing female age is also associated with a similar worsening trend in the outcome of assisted conception treatment.
Fertility and Miscarriage Rates as a Function of Maternal Age – Adapated from Heffner 2004. Advanced maternal age–how old is too old? N Engl J Med 2004; 351:1927-1929November 4, 2004
Pre-conception advice
Causes of infertility
Unexplained subfertility
Possible causes:
The tests explained earlier have diagnostic limitations. Semen analysis for example does not test for DNA damage in the sperm or acrosome reaction problems. Tubal testing in the form of HSG, HyCoSy or Laparoscopy does not ascertain the tubal motility and ciliary function. It is also not possible with standard testing to establish the quality of sperm binding to the zona pellucida. Hence, a number of explanations have been postulated in cases of unexplained infertility.
1. Subtle abnormalities in oocyte and or sperm function – Leading to reduced oocyte fertilisation and embryo cleavage rates in these cases. Therefore, if poor or failed fertilisation is encountered after IVF, it is wise to resort to Intracytoplasmic Sperm Injection (ICSI) in subsequent cycles.
2. Defective endometrial receptivity – This can cause unexplained subfertility or recurrent early pregnancy losses. There is vast research interest in this area e.g. the value of endometrial scratching to the endometrium to improve the implantation rate.
3. Subclinical endometriosis – This can affect tubal function, oocyte quality, sperm function, fertilisation, embryo quality, endometrial receptivity, implantation and placentation.
4. Nutritional factors – Zinc and magnesium deficiencies in women are thought to cause subfertility. Zinc, selenium and vitamin E supplementation oppose the oxidative stress, enhancing the sperm DNA repair which improves sperm quality.
5. Undiagnosed or untreated coeliac disease – One percent of general population have coeliac disease whereas its prevalence is 4–8% in sub-fertile women. Women with coeliac disease should advised to have gluten free diet.
6. Immunological factors – Antiphospholipid, antinuclear, antithyroid, antisperm antibodies and natural killer cells have been suggested as causes of immune related infertility.
7. Poor ovarian reserve may give a clinical picture similar to that of unexplained subfertility
CASE COMPONENT
Case Conclusion – Subfertility MED 35
In case Women’s Health – Subfertility
Having tried Clomiphene for six months without conceiving, Emma and Mark were followed up in the fertility clinic. As they had not conceived, they were advised that the next step would be assisted conception treatment in the form of intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI). They were keen to proceed and, after a full explanation of what was involved, signed the HFEA consent forms.
After ovarian stimulation, 18 eggs were retrieved and Emma had one embryo transferred on Day 5, with the 4 surplus embryos cryopreserved for future replacement. 10 days after the embryo transfer, Emma presented to the Gynaecology Emergency Unit, complaining of severe lower abdominal pain and vomiting which have been worsening gradually for the last 2 days.
On examination she was afebrile but distressed and dyspnoeic. The abdomen was grossly distended and extremely tender. An abdominal ultrasound showed grossly enlarged cystic ovaries, tense ascites and mild pleural effusion. The BHCG was 110. A diagnosis of severe ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome (OHSS) was made. She was admitted to the ward for close monitoring and management. She stayed on oral fluids, had thromboprophylaxisand required paracentesis to alleviate her symptoms. She recovered well and was discharged home 6 days later.
Emma and Mark had a successful pregnancy and their daughter Sophie was delivered in good condition at 39 weeks gestation by caesarean section due to breech presentation.
Having gone through this journey, Emma decided after the birth of Sophie to donate eggs on an altruistic basis to women who need donor egg IVF. Emma and Mark went through counselling for implications of gamete donation in the UK and were advised to familiarise themselves with HFEA regulations on donation as detailed in the Code of Practice.
CASE COMPONENT
Formative Assessment – Subfertility
Which of the following can cause hyperprolactinaemia?
· Tramadol
.
Tramadol is an opiate.
· Verapamil
.
Verapamil is a calcium channel blocker.
· Thioxanthenes
.
Correct answer.
Thioxanthenes are dopamine receptor antagonists.
A 22-year-old female presents with secondary amenorrhea, short stature, BMI of 31, a history of miscarriage 18 months ago and a recent diagnosis of hypertension.
What is the suspected diagnosis?
· Premature ovarian failure
.
· Klinefleter's syndrome
.
· Turner syndrome
.
Correct answer.
Common features of the condition are short stature, gonadal dysgenesis, obesity and hypertension. Some Turner’s cases may conceive spontaneously and have miscarriages as streak ovaries may have limited ovulation function in early reproductive age. Confirmation of diagnosis requires karyotyping.
· Endometriosis
.
· Polycystic ovarian syndrome
A 36-year-old woman presents with sudden secondary amenorrhea, preceded by regular menstrual cycles until 4 months ago. She has a BMI of 23. FSH is 31. Estradiol levels are low, prolactin is normal. Her sister had a similar problem when she was 34 years old.
What are your thoughts?
· Pregnancy
.
· Hypogonadtrophic hypogonadism
.
· Hypergonadotrophic hypogonadism
.
· Hyperprolactinaemia
.
· Premature ovarian failure
.
Correct answer.
There is persistent estrogen deficiency and markedly high FSH levels. In women younger than 40 years, 1% of women will have POF.
A couple present with a 3-year history of primary subfertility. The female has a BMI of 37 with oligomenorrhea and cycle lengths of 35 to 55 days. Hysterosalpingogram showed patent tubes on both sides. Serum progesterone on day 21 is 2 ng/mL. The semen analysis is normal.
What is the most appropriate next step?
· Clomiphene
.
Should not have been checked.
· Laparoscopic ovarian drilling
.
Should not have been checked.
· Gonadotrophins
.
Should not have been checked.
· Metformin
.
Wrong answer.Should not have been checked.
· Dietary and weight loss advice
.
Weight loss and reducing BMI to less than 30 improves both ovulation and fertility. If the woman fails to ovulate after weight loss, consider treatment with clomiphene citrate. Clomiphene is an anti-oestrogen which encourages FSH secretion by the pituitary and hence ovulatory cycles.
Should have been checked.
A 26-year-old female presents with amenorrhea for 12 months after stopping the contraceptive pill. She had regular withdrawal bleeds whilst she was on the pill. Her BMI is 33.
What is the most likely diagnosis?
· Hypogonadotrophic hypogonadism
.
· Hyperprolactinaemia
.
· Polycystic ovarian syndrome
.
Correct answer.
20% of women have PCOS. Raised BMI potentiates the underlying insulin resistance in PCOS. Hormone testing in PCOS often reveals altered FSH:LH ratio and hyperandrogenaemia. Those hormones on would be low in hypogonadotrophic e.g. anorexia and hypogonadotrophic hypogonadism.
· Anorexia nervosa
.
· Premature ovarian failure
In cases of endometriosis, what is the most appropriate form of tubal patency testing?
· MRI scan to diagnose endometriosis
.
· Diagnostic laparoscopy
.
Correct answer.
As well as checking the tubal patency, a laparoscopy would also allow the treatment of pelvic endometriosis and endometrioma.
· There is no need to test the tubes
.
· HSG
.
· HyCoSy scan
A 31-year-old male presents with his partner with a 2 year history of subfertility. The Semen analysis result are:
- volume = 3.2 ml
- total sperm count = 16 million
- sperm concentration = 8 million/ml
- pH >7.2
- overall motility = 19%
- normal forms = 1%
- vitality = 19%
Which of the following describes these results?
· Asthenospermia
.
Asthenospermia refers to low motility.
· Oligozoospermia
.
Oligozoospermia refers to a reduced number of sperm.
· Oligoasthenoteratozoospermia
.
Correct answer.
· Teratozoospermia
.
Teratozoospermia refers to a reduction in the number of sperm that look morphologically normal.
A couple present with primary subfertility. The male is 34-years-old. He had a history of mumps when he was 14 years old. His semen analysis on two occasions showed azoospermia. FSH and LH levels are high and the serum testosterone concentration is low. He has a normal karyotype.
What is the most likely explanation?
· Hypogonadotrophic hypogonadism
.
Wrong answer.Should not have been checked.
· Cystic Fibrosis
.
Should not have been checked.
· Primary testicular failure
.
Mumps is associated with orchitis after puberty and can cause irreversible testicular damage.
Should have been checked.
· Sperm motility defect
.
Should not have been checked.
· Anabolic steroid use
.
Should not have been checked.
Where primary testicular failure is believed to be the cause of a couple being unable to conceive what is the most appropriate management from the following?
· Advice to stop smoking and drinking, and repeat semen analysis
.
Wrong answer.
Stopping smoking and drinking would not treat the azoospermia in such cases.
Should not have been checked.
· Donor insemination
.
Should have been checked.
· Antioxidant treatment
.
Should not have been checked.
· Testicular sperm aspiration + IVF/ICSI
.
Should not have been checked.
· hCG treatment for 3 months for the male partner
.
A couple present with a 12-month history of primary subfertility. The female is 36-years-old with regular cycles. The fallopian tubes are both patent. Ovulation was confirmed with progesterone testing in two cycles. The semen analysis is normal.
What would you recommend next?
· Proceed with IVF
.
This is unexplained infertility, and since the female age is above 35 it is recommended not to delay assisted conception treatment.
Should have been checked.
· Clomifene citrate for 3 months
.
Wrong answer.Should not have been checked.
· To continue to try to concieve naturally for another 12 months
.
Should not have been checked.
· Stimulated IUI
.
Should not have been checked.
· Unstimulated IUI
.
Should not have been checked.