Research Topic Infographic Poster - "How can design?" Statement
The goal was exploration throughout Design Research in Fall 2024 with Professor Lisa Timman. We started from very generic topics (music, healthcare, arts, science, etc.) with mindmaps, to begin figuring out what we felt connected to.
Through this exploration, I ended up on the topic of Anxiety and Healthcare. This came about from experiences shared on social media and the experiences of friends. After the beginning stages of research, I began the narrowing process which resulted on the poster to the left - stating key pieces of information from research to defend the topic choice.
This poster results from 6 weeks of topic exploration and serves as the starting point for the problem statement.
Poster draws attention to several possible directions and details next steps to further develop the topic.
User Experience
Shown is a class exercise in where everyone drew their own depiction of the user experience for making toast. After taking a look at the different interpretations, we were tasked with pulling out similarities, differences, and general characteristics we noticed. From this, we starting looking deeper into issues from a user standpoint and how we can make improvements to the experience in the form of "How can we?" statements.
In a group setting, we went around and held discussion regarding one another's Infographic Poster Topic from Fall Semester. We used this opportunity to discuss potential case studies and issues to look more into.
This meeting also served as a segue into developing "How can we?" for our own topics.
Key Takeaways
Common theme of blocks in healthcare for women
Self-blocks for women was also common
Issues with self-managing and recognizing
Costs of treatments coinciding daily costs hindering accessibility
From the group discussion, I developed a list of "How Can We? statements shown on the left. This list is a starting point of possible ways to User center my problem statement, ranging from treatment issues to accessibility. It also helps frame ways to narrow the original topic.
Coping with an Anxiety Disorder Tips - Mayo Health
Insights
Alcohol, drugs, nicotine, and caffeine can worsen symptoms
Visualization, meditation, and yoga can be used to ease symptoms
Journaling can be an effective way to track symptoms and useful for your Provider
Diagnosis and management of Generalized Anxiety Disorder and Panic Disorder in Adults
https://www.aafp.org/pubs/afp/issues/2015/0501/p617.html
Insights
Provides two screening questionnaires for Generalized Anxiety Disorder
Gender Differences in Anxiety Disorders: Prevalence, Course of Illness, Comorbidity, and Burden of Illness
2011 Article - used to pick out differences from recent studies
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3135672/
Insights
women have been shown to have a higher prevalence but with less known information about how gender plays a part
Women are almost twice as likely to develop GAD (6.6% vs. 3.6%)
At this time, there was little research (and existing research was inconsistently conducted) regarding how race, ethnicity, and gender influence prevalence/presentation of anxiety disorders
Men are more likely to abuse substances with an anxiety disorder
Women are likely to experience an eating disorder with an anxiety disorder
Men are more likely to experience Intermittent Explosive Disorder with an anxiety disorder
European-American women had a higher prevalence of missing more work days, visit the ER more, and visit specialists during dependence/ dysfunction
Women with anxiety disorders tend to cope with agoraphobic avoidance(Isolation, avoiding public place
Over half of medical costs for people with anxiety disorders were nonpsychiatric
Men are more likely to visit a professional
speculated to men being given more appropriate resources
Women are more likely to seek treatment but more likely not to receive mental health services
Perceived Anxiety Disorder Stigma: A Predictive Analysis
https://scholarworks.waldenu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1671&context=jsbhs
Insights
Covid-19 has led to uncertainty, health concerns (oneself and family), and disruptions of daily life - leading to an increase in general anxiety.
"allostatic load"- the body's physiological response to chronic stress
Stigma leads to aversions to reaching out for treatment as well as an increase in intense anxiety symptoms
Anxiety sufferers may experience restlessness, agitation, aggression, fatigue, sleep distribution, and concentration issues
Anxiety Stigma also leads to disassociation, depression, and personality disorders
Negative views from the public and in healthcare lead to poor treatment outcomes
Mental health stigma hinders treatment in men more often
Individuals with higher education are less likely to perceive stigma
Very little research exists regarding clinical populations
Internalized stigma plays a larger part in avoiding treatment than external stigma
Anxiety Coping Strategies - Cumberland Heights
Insights
3-3-3 Method - Grounding exercise by engaging the senses and interrupting anxious thought patterns. This method is also accessible and can be done anywhere.
Name 3 things you see.
Name 3 things you hear
Name 3 parts of your body
Mindfulness
Breathing exercises - focusing on breathing to draw away from anxious thought patterns
In for 4, hold for 4, exhale for 6
Body scanning, guided meditation(Calm, headspace)
Journaling - allow for a shift in mindset and reflection of anxiety triggers/patterns
Gratitude journaling, Anxiety logs, stream-of-consciousness writing(writing anything that comes to mind for a set time)
Exercise - increases endorphins(can be light: such as yoga or stretching), relieving stress
What is Cognitive Behavioral Therapy?
https://www.apa.org/ptsd-guideline/patients-and-families/cognitive-behavioral
Insights
Based on the core principals of:
psychological problems are based on:
unhelpful ways of thinking
learned patterns of unhelpful behavior
better coping methods learned
Strategies include:
learning to recognize one's warped perceptions and reevaluating them in reality
understanding your behavior and the motivations of others
using problem-solving skills
learning to build one's confidence
Facing, rather than avoiding one's fears
using role-playing to prepare for potentially difficult situations
learning to calm oneself and relax
CBT may use a combination of these strategies, depending on the patient
CBT teaches patients to be their own therapist, putting them in control
Adverse Effects of Anti Anxiety Drugs
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/6119192/
Insights
The most common side effect of benzodiazepines is:
Oversedation
more common in juvenile and geriatric patients
common during trial period and upping a dosage
Overall, side effects are rare and are more contributed to overprescription
Here, we begin making note of subtopics that can help narrow the parent topic mentioned in the Infographic at the top of the page.
Looking into post-partum women?
How does trauma play a part in Generalized Anxiety Disorder?
Physical effects?
Effects on families?
How has Covid-19 changed treatment?
Focusing on one, two, or three symptoms?
How can a sense of community help?
Effectiveness of at-home methods?
Focusing on campaigning for awareness?
Focusing on encouraging seeking treatment
Helping women have a safe space to seek help
How does time availability play a role?
Yes or No questions:
Have you practiced or have an interest in meditation to ease symptoms?
Do you practice or have an interest in journaling?
Do you feel there is a stigma surrounding women's mental health?
Are you aware of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy?
Have you ever decided not to seek treatment?
Has Covid-19 influenced your condition?
Have you ever performed breathing exercises to ease symptoms?
Are you familiar with the 3-3-3 grounding exercise?
Do your symptoms affect your sleep patterns?
Does cost affect how you go about treatment?
Do you feel treatment is available to you?
Do you feel you have time to manage your symptoms?
Extended Response/Multiple Choice Questions:
How many days of the week do your symptoms affect your daily life?
What are 2 ways you help ease symptoms?
Has your experience with treatment been mostly positive or negative?
How long, from your first appointment, did it take to receive a diagnosis?
What are you 3 most prominent symptoms?
These will be looked into further next week
BetterHelp
Online therapy service
$65+ a week for services
One service a week, online chatting with therapist, group discussions, journaling
TalkSpace
Online therapy service
$276-436 monthly, takes insurance, different treatment plans
Live sessions only with more expensive plans
Calm
App for meditation and sleep
free to download, most content behind paywall
$14.99 a month, student and family plans available
Mindshift CBT
Anxiety management app
free to download and use
Breathwrk
Free for basic plan, $12 for premium
50 free relaxation classes
Continue working on survey questions
When complete, narrow down questions that best serve the chosen topic and are manageable for participants.
Roll out survey
Continue readings, looking into the questions that can narrow the problem statement
Wrap up narrowing the problem statement
Gather supporting information
Begin market research