Making the decision to manage your Pinterest account yourself or hire a professional service is a critical choice for any business. It's a balance of time, money, and expertise. This guide provides a comprehensive comparison to help you determine which path is best for your business in 2024.

1. Introduction: Understanding Your Options

1.1 The Growing Importance of Pinterest Marketing

Pinterest has evolved beyond a simple mood board platform to become a powerful visual search engine and e-commerce driver. In 2024, it continues to be a key platform for businesses looking to:

Drive website traffic: Pins have a long lifespan, consistently sending traffic to your blog or website long after they are published.
Boost brand awareness: Pinterest is a discovery platform where users are actively looking for new brands and products.
Increase sales: With features like Rich Pins and shoppable pins, Pinterest is a strong channel for direct sales.
Position as an industry expert: Creating and sharing educational content helps establish your brand as an authority in your niche.

1.2 Key Factors in the DIY vs. Hiring Decision

The primary factors in this decision are time, money, and expertise. A DIY approach requires a significant time investment and a steep learning curve, but can be more cost-effective if you have the internal resources. Hiring a professional saves you time and provides expert strategy, but at a higher financial cost.

1.3 How This Guide Helps You Make the Right Choice

This guide will break down the true costs and benefits of each option, helping you identify your business's specific needs and choose the path that will lead to the greatest return on investment.

2. DIY Pinterest Marketing: The Complete Picture

Managing your own Pinterest account gives you complete control, but it requires a solid understanding of the platform and a consistent commitment.

2.1 What DIY Pinterest Marketing Entails

Account setup and management: Creating a business account, optimizing your profile with keywords, and claiming your website.
Content creation and scheduling: Designing pins (static, video, and Idea Pins), writing keyword-rich descriptions, and scheduling them for consistent posting.
Community engagement: Replying to comments, engaging with other accounts, and participating in relevant group boards.
Analytics tracking and optimization: Regularly checking Pinterest Analytics to see what's working, identifying top-performing content, and making data-driven adjustments to your strategy.

2.2 Time Commitment Required for DIY

Don't underestimate the time it takes to manage a Pinterest account effectively. For a growing business, it's not a set-it-and-forget-it platform.

Weekly Time Investment: Expect to spend anywhere from 5 to 15 hours per week on Pinterest marketing, depending on your goals and content volume.
Learning Curve: It can take 2-3 months to gain a solid understanding of Pinterest SEO, the algorithm, and best practices.
Ongoing Education: The platform is always changing. You should dedicate 2-4 hours monthly to staying up-to-date on new features and trends.

2.3 Costs of DIY Pinterest Marketing

While the service itself is "free," there are significant hidden costs associated with a DIY approach.

Software/Tools: You'll likely need subscriptions to tools for scheduling (e.g., Tailwind, Buffer) and analytics, which can run from $50-$200/month.
Design Resources: You may need a graphic design tool like Canva Pro ($13/month) or access to stock photography or templates, which can add $100-$500/month in costs.
Education/Courses: To get up to speed quickly, you might invest in a comprehensive Pinterest course, which can be a one-time cost of $200-$1000.
Opportunity Cost: The most significant hidden cost is your time. Every hour you spend on Pinterest is an hour you can't spend on core business activities like serving clients or creating products.

2.4 Required Skills for Success

A successful DIY Pinterest marketer needs a diverse skill set:

Graphic design capabilities: Creating visually appealing pins that stand out in a crowded feed is essential.
SEO and keyword research knowledge: Since Pinterest is a search engine, you must be able to conduct keyword research and optimize your content to be found.
Analytics interpretation skills: You need to understand your data to know what's working and what's not.
Strategic planning ability: A good Pinterest strategy is not random; it requires a thoughtful plan to achieve your business goals.
Consistency and discipline: The Pinterest algorithm rewards consistent activity, so you must be disciplined enough to keep a regular posting schedule.

3. Professional Pinterest Services: What You Get

Hiring a professional service provides you with a dedicated expert or team to manage your Pinterest presence, allowing you to focus on running your business.

3.1 Service Offerings and Scope

Professional services can be as comprehensive or as niche as you need them to be.

Comprehensive account management: This is a full-service package that includes everything from content strategy and creation to scheduling, analytics, and reporting.
Professional content creation: Many providers specialize in creating high-quality, on-brand pins that are optimized for the platform's best practices.
Advanced strategy development: Professionals have the expertise to develop a sophisticated strategy tailored to your specific business goals, whether that's increasing brand awareness, driving sales, or generating leads.
Detailed performance reporting: You will receive regular, easy-to-understand reports that show you exactly how your account is performing and what ROI you're getting.

3.2 Typical Investment for Professional Services

The cost of professional services varies widely depending on the provider and the scope of work.

Freelancers: You can expect to pay a monthly retainer of $800-$3000. The price depends on the freelancer's experience, with entry-level professionals on the lower end and seasoned experts on the higher end.
Agencies: Small- to mid-size agencies typically charge $2000-$7000/month. Agencies provide a team-based approach with a wider range of resources and expertise.
Specialized Firms: For businesses with complex needs, such as a large e-commerce store or a company running extensive ad campaigns, a specialized firm may be necessary, with retainers starting at $4000-$10,000+/month.

3.3 Expertise and Resources Provided

When you hire a professional, you're paying for more than just a service; you're paying for expertise.

Platform-specific knowledge: Professionals live and breathe Pinterest. They stay up-to-date on every algorithm change, new feature, and industry trend, saving you the time and effort of doing it yourself.
Advanced tools and software: Service providers have access to a suite of advanced, often expensive, tools for scheduling, keyword research, and analytics, which they use to optimize your account.
Industry best practices: They know what works and what doesn't. They can apply proven strategies and frameworks to your account to generate results more efficiently.
Proven strategies and frameworks: Professionals use established processes to ensure your account is optimized for long-term success, from initial setup and SEO to ongoing content management.

4. Side-by-Side Comparison: DIY vs. Professional

When you weigh the options, it's clear that the DIY and professional routes are fundamentally different in their investment, timeline, and potential for results. This side-by-side comparison provides a clear overview of the key differences.

Aspect | DIY Approach | Professional Services

-------------------------------- |-------------------------------------- |------------------------------------------

Monthly Cash Outlay | $150 – $700 | $800 – $7,000+

Time Investment | 20 – 60 hours/month | 2 – 5 hours/month

Setup Time | 3 – 6 months | 2 – 4 weeks

Tools & Software | Basic (Canva Pro, Tailwind) | Enterprise (premium analytics, schedulers)

4.2 Results Comparison

The timeline and quality of results are often the most compelling reason to choose a professional.

Traffic Growth Timeline: With a DIY approach, you can expect to see significant traffic growth within 6-12 months, as you navigate the learning curve and build your content base. A professional service, however, can often achieve the same level of growth in just 3-6 months by applying proven strategies from day one.
ROI Achievement: It can take 8-15 months for a DIY Pinterest marketer to consistently achieve a positive return on investment, after a period of trial and error. A professional service, with its strategic approach and advanced tools, can often achieve a positive ROI within 4-9 months.
Quality of Results: A professional service offers a level of consistency and scalability that is difficult to achieve with a DIY approach. They can create a high volume of quality pins, manage complex ad campaigns, and consistently optimize for peak performance, leading to more sustainable and significant growth.

4.3 Risk Assessment

Both options come with their own set of risks that should be considered.

DIY Risks:
- Learning curve mistakes: It's easy to make mistakes that can harm your account's performance, such as using the wrong keywords or violating Pinterest's content policies.
- Inconsistent results: Without the discipline of a professional, it can be hard to maintain a consistent posting schedule, leading to unpredictable results.
- Opportunity cost: The hours spent on Pinterest are hours you can't spend on core business activities that may have a higher impact on revenue.
Professional Risks:
- Agency reliability: Not all agencies are created equal. You risk hiring an unreliable or inexperienced provider who may not deliver on their promises.
- Cost investment: The financial cost of a professional service is a risk, especially for startups with limited budgets.
- Communication challenges: You may face communication issues with an agency, leading to a lack of transparency or misalignment on goals.

5. Who Should Choose DIY Pinterest Marketing

The DIY approach is not for every business, but for those who fit the profile, it can be an excellent way to get started and build a strong foundation.

5.1 Ideal Candidates for DIY

Startups with limited budget: If your budget is tight and you have a founder or team member with the time and interest to learn Pinterest marketing, DIY is a viable option.
Bloggers and content creators: For those whose business is centered on creating content, learning Pinterest marketing is a core skill that can significantly increase their audience and traffic.
Businesses with an in-house marketing team: If you already have a team, you can task them with managing Pinterest. This is a good way to test the platform's viability before committing to a professional service.
Those with previous Pinterest experience: If you have a background in social media or digital marketing, you may have the foundational knowledge to manage your own account effectively.

5.2 Success Factors for DIY

To succeed with a DIY approach, you need to meet several key criteria.

Minimum 10 hours weekly availability: This is the baseline time commitment required to create content, schedule pins, engage with the community, and analyze results.
Basic design skills or willingness to learn: You need to be able to create visually compelling pins that capture users' attention.
Long-term perspective (6-12 month commitment): Pinterest is a long game. You won't see significant results overnight. You must be willing to commit to consistent effort over several months.
Access to necessary tools and resources: You'll need to invest in software for scheduling, design, and analytics to make your efforts more efficient.

5.3 DIY Success Stories

Many businesses have found success with a DIY approach.

Small ecommerce stores have achieved 100% growth in sales by consistently pinning new product photos and using keyword-rich descriptions.
Bloggers have generated 50,000+ monthly visitors to their websites by creating a solid Pinterest strategy and staying disciplined with their content schedule.
Local businesses have successfully used Pinterest to build a strong community presence and drive traffic to their physical locations.

6. Who Should Hire Professional Services

For businesses ready to scale their Pinterest marketing and see faster, more impactful results, hiring a professional service is the best path forward.

6.1 Ideal Candidates for Professional Help

Established businesses with a marketing budget: If you have the financial resources, investing in a professional service provides a strong return and frees up your internal team's time.
Ecommerce stores with product catalogs: Professionals are experts at managing shopping feeds, optimizing product pins, and running sophisticated ad campaigns to drive direct sales.
Companies lacking internal resources: If your team is already stretched thin and doesn't have the time or expertise to manage Pinterest, outsourcing is the most logical choice.
Businesses needing fast results: If you have an aggressive growth target or a new product launch, a professional can deliver results on an accelerated timeline.

6.2 When Professional Services Make Sense

Limited internal bandwidth: If your team is at capacity and you want to scale your Pinterest efforts without hiring a new employee, a professional service is the perfect solution.
Need for specialized expertise: Pinterest is a complex platform. If you want to run advanced ad campaigns or create a sophisticated SEO strategy, hiring an expert is a wise investment.
Desire for accelerated growth: A professional can quickly implement a proven strategy that bypasses the trial-and-error period, leading to faster and more significant results.
Complex sales funnel integration: If your business has a complex sales funnel or a high volume of products, a professional can ensure your Pinterest strategy seamlessly integrates with your other marketing efforts.

6.3 Professional Service Success Stories

The results from a professional service can be game-changing for a business.

300% ROI within 6 months for e-commerce brands by leveraging sophisticated ad campaigns and rich pin optimization.
5x traffic increase for content publishers who focused on a high-volume pinning strategy managed by an expert.
A 40% reduction in customer acquisition cost for a service-based business by targeting highly-qualified leads on Pinterest.

A hybrid Pinterest marketing approach combines the best elements of both DIY and professional services, allowing businesses to leverage expert knowledge without the full cost of a monthly retainer. This model empowers an in-house team to handle daily tasks while outsourcing high-level strategy, content creation, or specific specialized services to a professional.

7. Hybrid Approach: The Best of Both Worlds

A hybrid model is an ideal solution for businesses that have some internal capacity but need expert guidance to maximize their results and accelerate growth. This approach offers a powerful mix of cost-effectiveness and specialized expertise. <br>

7.1 Partial Management Options

Instead of hiring a full-service agency, you can select specific services to outsource based on your team's skill gaps and bandwidth.

Strategy development only: You can hire a professional for a one-time service to create a comprehensive Pinterest marketing plan, including keyword research, board structure, and content strategy. Your internal team can then execute this plan.
Content creation outsourcing: If your team struggles with graphic design or video production, you can hire a freelance designer or agency to create a steady stream of high-quality, on-brand pins while you handle the scheduling and analytics.
Advertising management: Pinterest advertising is complex. Outsourcing ad campaign management to a professional ensures your ad spend is optimized for maximum ROI, while your team focuses on organic content.
Analytics and reporting: If interpreting data is not your team's strength, you can outsource a monthly analytics service. A professional will provide a detailed report with actionable insights and strategic recommendations.

7.2 Training and Consultation Services

Beyond execution, a hybrid model can involve professional training and consultation to upskill your internal team.

One-time strategy sessions: A one-on-one session with a Pinterest expert can provide a clear roadmap and answer specific questions, giving your team a solid foundation to work from.
Team training programs: Some professionals offer comprehensive training programs to teach your in-house team the skills they need to manage the account effectively. This includes everything from pin design to SEO and analytics.
Monthly consulting packages: This involves a regular monthly call where a Pinterest expert reviews your performance, answers questions, and provides ongoing strategic guidance.
Audit and optimization services: You can hire a professional to conduct a quarterly or bi-annual audit of your account, identifying areas for improvement and providing a plan for optimization.

7.3 Implementing a Hybrid Model

A successful hybrid model requires a clear division of labor and strong communication between your internal team and the external provider.

Internal team handles daily management: Your in-house team is responsible for the day-to-day tasks, such as scheduling pins, community engagement, and basic reporting.
Agency provides strategy and oversight: The professional partner is responsible for the big picture. They create the strategy, oversee its implementation, and ensure your efforts are aligned with your business goals.
Quarterly professional optimizations: Schedule regular check-ins and audits with your professional partner to review performance and make high-level adjustments to the strategy.
Special projects outsourcing: When a special project arises, such as a major ad campaign or a product launch, you can outsource it to the professional partner to ensure it is handled with expert precision.

8. Making the Decision: Key Considerations

Choosing the right approach requires a realistic assessment of your budget, your team's skills, and your business goals.

8.1 Budget Assessment

Available monthly investment: How much can you realistically afford to spend each month? A DIY approach may be "free" of service fees, but it has significant hidden costs.
Expected ROI timeline: How quickly do you need to see a return on your investment? If you need faster results, the higher cost of a professional service may be justified.
Opportunity cost calculations: What is your time worth? The hours you or your team spend on DIY Pinterest marketing could be spent on other revenue-generating activities.

8.2 Skill Gap Analysis

Current team capabilities: Does your team have the necessary skills in graphic design, SEO, and analytics?
Training time requirements: If not, are you willing to invest the time and money required to train them?
Hiring vs. outsourcing cost: Would it be more cost-effective to hire a full-time Pinterest specialist or to outsource the work to a professional service?

8.3 Business Goals Alignment

Short-term vs. long-term objectives: Are you focused on a quick boost in traffic, or are you building a long-term, sustainable marketing channel?
Growth pace requirements: Do you need accelerated growth to hit a business milestone, or are you comfortable with a slower, more organic pace?
Risk tolerance level: Are you willing to risk a period of trial and error with a DIY approach, or do you need the certainty that comes with an expert-led strategy?

Check out our related articles:

9. Implementation Roadmap

Once you've made your decision, a clear implementation roadmap is essential for a smooth and effective launch.

9.1 DIY Implementation Plan

Month 1-2: Learning and setup: Focus on creating a professional business account, conducting in-depth keyword research, and setting up your initial boards. During this time, you should also be learning the basics of pin design and the Pinterest algorithm.
Month 3-4: Strategy implementation: Begin consistently creating and scheduling a high volume of new pins. This is the period for testing different content types and strategies to see what resonates with your audience.
Month 5-6: Optimization and scaling: Start to analyze your performance data. Based on your analytics, you can begin to optimize your content, improve your SEO, and scale what is working.

9.2 Professional Service Onboarding

Week 1-2: Account audit and strategy: The professional service provider will conduct a thorough audit of your existing account and a comprehensive competitor analysis. They will then present you with a detailed strategy and implementation plan.
Week 3-4: Implementation begins: The provider will begin implementing the core strategy, which includes profile optimization, board creation, and a high-volume pinning schedule.
Month 2-3: Optimization phase: The provider will begin to analyze performance data and optimize your strategy for improved results, often including the launch of initial ad campaigns.

9.3 Hybrid Approach Timeline

Month 1: Professional audit and training: You hire a professional for a one-time audit and strategy session. They provide your team with a clear roadmap and train them on the basics.
Month 2-3: Managed implementation: Your internal team starts to implement the strategy with support from the professional partner. You can hire them for ongoing consulting or a partial management service, such as content creation.
Month 4+: Internal team takeover with support: Your team now has the skills and confidence to manage the account independently. The professional partner can remain on a minimal retainer for quarterly check-ins or special projects, providing a safety net of expertise when you need it.

Successfully measuring the ROI of your Pinterest marketing efforts is crucial for justifying your investment, whether you're doing it yourself or hiring a professional. It involves more than just looking at surface-level metrics; you need to connect your activities on the platform to tangible business outcomes. By using a combination of key performance indicators (KPIs) and specific calculation methods, you can gain a clear understanding of your success and determine when it's time to adjust your strategy.

10. Measuring Success and ROI

10.1 Key Performance Indicators

KPIs are the specific metrics that tell you how your Pinterest strategy is performing. It's important to track a mix of engagement, traffic, and sales metrics to get a complete picture.

Monthly viewers and engagement: These are top-of-funnel metrics that indicate brand awareness. Monthly viewers show how many unique people are seeing your pins, while engagement (saves, clicks, comments) tells you how much your content resonates with your audience.
Website traffic and conversions: These are crucial for understanding how Pinterest is driving business. Pinterest Analytics and Google Analytics can be used together to track outbound clicks from pins to your website and monitor what users do once they get there, such as signing up for a newsletter or downloading a lead magnet.
Sales and revenue attribution: This is the ultimate measure of ROI for e-commerce businesses. By using the Pinterest Tag and Conversion API, you can directly attribute sales and revenue to specific pins and ad campaigns, providing a clear picture of what's working.
Customer acquisition cost (CAC): For paid Pinterest campaigns, measuring the cost to acquire a new customer is a key metric. A lower CAC indicates a more efficient and profitable marketing channel.

10.2 ROI Calculation Methods

Calculating ROI goes beyond just raw numbers. You need to assign a monetary value to your Pinterest activities to truly understand their impact.

Traffic value calculations: To quantify the value of your traffic, you can assign a dollar amount to each website visitor based on your average conversion rate and customer lifetime value. For example, if you know that one out of every 100 Pinterest visitors makes a purchase of $50, you can calculate that each visitor is worth $0.50 in revenue.
Conversion rate improvements: A professional or a well-executed DIY strategy can improve your conversion rate from Pinterest traffic. A small percentage increase can lead to a significant boost in sales and revenue, which can be directly attributed as a return on your time or financial investment.
Time savings quantification: For businesses considering a professional service, it's essential to quantify the time they will save. By assigning an hourly rate to the time your team would spend on Pinterest marketing, you can calculate the monetary value of the time freed up to focus on other core business activities.
Opportunity cost analysis: This method looks at what you are losing out on by not having a fully optimized Pinterest presence. For instance, if you're not capturing a share of a high-traffic keyword, that's a missed opportunity that can be quantified in potential lost sales.

10.3 When to Re-evaluate Your Approach

Pinterest is a dynamic platform, and what works today may not work tomorrow. It's essential to regularly re-evaluate your strategy to ensure you're on the right track.

After 6 months of implementation: This is a good timeframe to collect enough data to make informed decisions. By this point, you should have a clear idea of what's working and whether you're on track to meet your goals.
Significant business changes: If you're launching a new product line, expanding into a new market, or undergoing a rebrand, you'll need to re-evaluate your Pinterest strategy to align with these new objectives.
Platform algorithm updates: Pinterest regularly updates its algorithm to improve the user experience. Staying on top of these changes is crucial, as they can significantly impact your performance. A professional service will handle this for you, while DIY marketers must actively seek out this information.
Performance plateaus: If your metrics (traffic, engagement, etc.) have stalled for several months, it's a clear sign that your current strategy is no longer effective and a re-evaluation is needed.

11. Tools and Resources for Both Approaches

Regardless of whether you choose a DIY, professional, or hybrid approach, having the right tools and educational resources is essential for success.

11.1 Essential DIY Tools

Canva for design ($12-30/month): An intuitive graphic design tool that allows you to easily create professional-looking pins using a vast library of templates, fonts, and stock images.
Tailwind for scheduling ($15-100/month): A powerful scheduling tool that helps you maintain a consistent pinning schedule and provides valuable analytics and community-building features.
Pinterest Analytics (free): Pinterest's native analytics tool is an absolute must-use. It provides a wealth of data on pin and board performance, audience insights, and website traffic.
Google Analytics integration: Connecting your website to Google Analytics allows you to track traffic from Pinterest and understand user behavior once they arrive on your site.

11.2 Professional-Grade Tools

Professional services and agencies invest in more advanced, often more expensive, tools to maximize their efficiency and results.

Enterprise scheduling platforms: Tools like Sprout Social or Hootsuite allow agencies to manage multiple client accounts from a single dashboard and offer more advanced features than basic schedulers.
Advanced analytics suites: Platforms like SEMrush or AgencyAnalytics offer more in-depth data, including competitor analysis, keyword tracking, and comprehensive reporting.
Competitor analysis tools: Tools that allow professionals to monitor what your competitors are doing on Pinterest, including their top-performing pins, boards, and keywords.
AI-powered optimization software: This new generation of tools uses AI to automate pin creation, optimize descriptions for SEO, and suggest the best times to post for maximum engagement.

11.3 Educational Resources

Continuous learning is key to staying on top of Pinterest trends and algorithm updates.

Pinterest Business Academy: A free resource from Pinterest that offers a wide range of courses on everything from account setup to running successful ad campaigns.
Industry blogs and courses: Following leading Pinterest marketing blogs and investing in professional courses can help you stay current on best practices and new strategies.
Webinars and conferences: Attending webinars and conferences allows you to learn from industry experts and network with other Pinterest marketers.
Community forums and groups: Joining forums or Facebook groups can provide a support system where you can ask questions and learn from the collective experience of other marketers.

12. Conclusion: Making the Right Choice

Choosing the right approach for your Pinterest marketing is a strategic decision that should be based on a careful assessment of your resources, goals, and risk tolerance.

12.1 Decision-Making Checklist

Budget assessment completed: Do you have a clear understanding of what you can spend and what the costs (both direct and hidden) are for each option?
Skill gap analysis performed: Have you identified what skills your team has and what they would need to learn to be successful?
Business goals aligned: Are your Pinterest goals clearly defined and aligned with your overall business objectives?
Implementation plan ready: Do you have a roadmap for how you will get started, whether it's a DIY, professional, or hybrid approach?

12.2 Next Steps Based on Your Decision

DIY: Your next step is to prioritize education and invest in the essential tools. Focus on learning the platform inside and out before you start implementing a full-scale strategy.
Professional: Your next step is to begin the vendor selection process. Use your questions and checklist to find a reputable freelancer or agency that can deliver on your goals.
Hybrid: Your next step is to define your service scope. Decide what your internal team will handle and what services you'll outsource to a professional.

12.3 Final Recommendation

Startups: Begin with the DIY approach. Your priority is to establish a presence and prove the viability of Pinterest as a channel. As you grow and generate revenue, you can scale to a hybrid model to accelerate your results.
Growing businesses: A hybrid approach is often the most cost-effective solution. It allows you to leverage expert strategy and advanced tools while maintaining day-to-day control and keeping your costs manageable.
Established companies: Professional services are the most logical choice. With a clear budget and an emphasis on accelerated growth, outsourcing your Pinterest marketing allows you to achieve maximum ROI with minimal internal time investment.
All businesses: Regardless of your choice, remember that Pinterest marketing requires regular evaluation and adjustment. The key to long-term success is to stay agile and adapt your strategy to the ever-changing platform and your business's evolving needs.

Page updated

Google Sites

Report abuse