Schmidt & Brown (2021). Evidence-Based Practice for Nurses:
Chapter 2.1: Research: What is It?
Chapter 5.1: Understanding and Defining Evidence
Garrard (2021). Health Sciences Literature Review Made Easy:
Chapter 2: Basic Concepts
The Anatomy of a Scientific Paper (p. 42 - 46)
Contrast scholarly and nonscholarly literature
Describe the sections found in research articles
Describe the scientific publishing cycle and the processes and time frames within it
Differentiate between primary and secondary sources
Explain the peer-review process
Scholarly literature
Literature, including journals, journal articles, and sometimes other sources such as books and theses, that go through a peer review or rigorous editorial review process
In general, if an article was peer reviewed, it is considered scholarly
Nonscholarly literature
Abundant and easily found online
Nonscholarly works include those found in blogs, newspapers, news sites, and general website content
Sources, such as Medscape, Healthline, or Mayo Clinic, are not peer reviewed in the way journal articles are
Box 5.1 can be helpful to evaluate information from the web
Abstract
= The first section of a research article that provides an overview of the study
Introduction
= Part of a research article that states the problem and purpose
Problem statement
Identifies the problem in a broad and general way
Purpose statement
Describes what was examined in the study
Review of Literature
= An unbiased, comprehensive, synthesized description of relevant previously published studies
Theoretical framework
= The structure of a study that links the theory concepts to the study variables; a section of a research article that describes the theory used
Methods
= Major portion of a research article that describes the study design, sample, and data collection
Results
= Component of a research article that reports the methods used to analyze data and characteristics of the sample
Discussion
= Portion of a research article where interpretation of the results and how the findings extend the body of knowledge are discussed
List of References
= Publication information for each article cited in a research report
Acknowledgments and/or Funding Source
Description of how the research study was funded
The names of granting agencies or foundations and the names of individuals who assisted in the research or review
If the research was funded by the National Institute of Health (NIH), then the paper should be available in PubMed Central, a publicly available bibliographic database developed and managed by the National Library of Medicine, which is part of the NIH
= A model describing how research becomes disseminated in publications
Manuscript
= A scholarly paper prior to its publication
Journal
= A collection of scholarly articles published together in an issue
Peer Review
When experts and editors rigorously evaluate a manuscript submitted for publication
Database
= A collection of records for scholarly and nonscholarly sources organized in a searchable interface
Bibliographic record
A record organizing and presenting citation information, abstracts, and descriptive terms such as keywords and subject headings for a published source
Subject headings
= Formal descriptive terms used by databases, including CINAHL, to describe the content of a source
How long does it take for research to become practice? Possibly 17 years!
Primary Sources
In the sciences and health sciences, original data or reports of results from original research presented by the people who conducted the research
Example
Physical and mental effects of bathing: A randomized intervention study (see above for the article)
Secondary Sources
Commentaries, summaries, reviews, or interpretations of primary sources; often written by those not involved in the original work
Example
1. How are Research Papers Organized? (19:46)
2. How Do I Read Research Papers Efficiently? (11:44)
3. How are Research Papers Published? (31:32)