Guiding question: Why is material selection crucial to designers of products?
Material selection is one of the most critical stages in the design process. Choosing the wrong material can lead to product failure, excessive manufacturing costs, poor user experience, or unnecessary environmental harm. Designers must evaluate materials through a balanced assessment of their physical, chemical, and mechanical properties, alongside their aesthetic appeal, economic cost, regional availability, and ecological footprint
Designers categorize and select materials based on three main performance classifications: physical, chemical, and mechanical properties.
Physical properties are measurable attributes of a material that can be observed without altering its fundamental chemical composition.
Density (ρ): Mass per unit volume. Critical when designing products where weight reduction is vital.
Thermal Conductivity & Expansion: How well a material conducts heat, and how much it expands or contracts when temperature changes.
Electrical Conductivity & Resistivity: The capacity to allow or resist the flow of an electric current.
Melting Point: The temperature at which a solid transitions into a liquid, dictating suitable manufacturing processes like casting or thermoforming.
In the structural frame of the LTA Pathfinder Airship, designers specified titanium hubs and carbon fibre composite tubes because of their extremely low density paired with high structural stiffness, maximizing flight and fuel efficiency.
Similarly, the MOM Infant Incubator utilizes clear polycarbonate sheets for its canopy due to its high optical transparency and thermal insulation properties
LTA Pathfinder Airship (IEEE spectrum)
Infant incubator
Prototype mycellium based food packaging
Chemical properties describe how a material interacts, reacts, or degrades when exposed to other chemical substances or environmental elements.
Corrosion Resistance: The ability to withstand chemical degradation caused by oxidation, moisture, or acids.
Reactivity: Food Safety: Ensuring materials do not leach harmful chemicals or react when in contact with food, skin, or biological tissues.
Hygroscopy: The degree to which a material absorbs moisture from its surrounding environment.
Flammability: How easily a material ignites and sustains combustion.
Fast-food containers developed from mycelium (fungus root structures) must undergo testing for hygroscopic capabilities to ensure moisture from hot food does not compromise the container's structural stability or contaminate the meal
Mechanical properties describe how a material behaves when subjected to external physical forces or loads.
Tensile & Compressive Strength: The maximum resistance to pulling (stretching) or pushing (crushing) forces before failure.
Stiffness & Young’s Modulus: The measure of a material's resistance to elastic deformation under stress.
Toughness: The capacity to absorb mechanical energy and deform plastically before fracturing.
Hardness & Malleability: Hardness resists surface indentation or scratching, while malleability allows a material to be hammered or rolled into thin sheets without cracking.
Ductility & Elasticity: Ductility allows a material to be drawn out into long wires, whereas elasticity enables it to return to its original shape after a load is removed
Rong May Glass Bridge (VN express)
Aesthetic characteristics dictate how users perceive a product through their senses, heavily influencing emotional engagement, perceived quality, and brand identity.
Texture: The tactile surface feel (e.g., rough, smooth, warm, soft-touch).
Form & Shape: The three-dimensional silhouette and contour of the component.
Colour & Optical Finish: Transparency, opacity, gloss, or matte appearance.
Industry Example: In wearable exoskeleton-style clothing such as the Arc’teryx MO/GO Trousers, the structural leg frame must have an exceptionally smooth surface texture to minimize joint friction, prevent fabric snagging, and enhance overall user comfort and safety.
Finishes are applied to protect raw material surfaces, extend product lifespan, and enhance visual appeal:
Anodizing: An electrochemical process that thickens the natural oxide layer on metals like aluminium, adding vibrant colour while increasing corrosion resistance.
Electro-plating & Galvanizing: Coating a base metal with a thin layer of another metal (e.g., zinc or chrome) for corrosion protection and decorative shine.
Powder-Coating & Sealants: Applying protective polymer powders or organic waxes/oils to seal porous materials like timber or cast metals.
Arc’teryx MO/GO Trousers (Arcteryx)
2021 Evergreen shipping disaster - Suez Canal
Beyond technical and visual parameters, real-world product design requires balancing financial viability, supply chain logistics, and environmental responsibility
A. Cost & Availability Constraints
Raw Material & Processing Costs: High-performance materials (such as titanium or carbon fibre) incur substantial raw material and specialized tooling expenses, which must be offset by the product's retail value.
Resource Availability & Supply Chains: Designers prioritize standardized, locally sourced components to minimize shipping lead times, transport emissions, and geopolitical supply risks.
Biodegradable Materials & Biomaterials: Derived from biological sources (e.g., wood fibres, mycelium, bamboo), these materials naturally break down at the end of life without leaving toxic residues.
Cradle-to-Cradle Philosophy: Selecting fully recyclable or compostable materials allows products to be safely re-absorbed into biological or industrial loops, effectively designing out waste.
Take-Back Legislation & Recycling: Using highly recyclable metals (such as aluminium) or single-polymer structures makes end-of-life disassembly and material recovery economically viable.
Designers cannot rely on assumptions; they must justify material choices through rigorous, evidence-based research.
Empirical Material Testing: Conducting lab tests for tensile load, impact resistance, and moisture absorption.
User Trials & Prototyping: Evaluating physical mock-ups with end-users to gather qualitative feedback on grip, weight distribution, and tactile comfort.
Material Selection Charts & Datasheets: Comparing Young's Modulus vs. density or yield strength across standardized material databases.
Academic Literature & Industry Standards: Reviewing published research, ISO safety regulations, and environmental impact matrices
User testing and observation
Design thinking process - DP Design Technology Guide (International Baccaluriette)
Material selection is not just a theoretical concept; it is an essential component evaluated directly in your Internal Assessment (Design Project)
Criterion B: Defining the Project (Design Specifications)
When creating your Design Specifications, you must include Manufacture Requirements that explicitly state the necessary material properties (e.g., tensile strength, food-safety reactivity, density, or water resistance) justified by your research.
Criterion C: Ideation and Modelling (Strand C.ii – Evaluating Ideas)
In Strand C.ii, you are required to evaluate your redesign ideas against the design specifications through testing and user feedback.
You must test low- and medium-fidelity physical/digital models to evaluate whether your proposed materials satisfy functional and aesthetic requirements. Feedback on tactile feel, durability, or weight distribution directly justifies whether a chosen material is viable or needs iteration.
Criterion D: Designing a Solution
When producing formal technical drawings and a Bill of Materials (BOM) for a third-party manufacturer, you must specify exact material choices, dimensions, and finishes (e.g., anodized 6061 aluminium, food-grade silicone)
When documenting your material selection in your IA report, ensure you address:
Physical/Mechanical Properties: Why does this material perform better under required forces (e.g., stiffness vs. flexibility) than alternatives
User Experience & Aesthetics: How do texture, colour, or surface finish improve user comfort or visual appeal
Sustainability & End-of-Life: Is the material recyclable, biodegradable, or sourced responsibly to align with circular economy principles
Context & Feasibility: Are the cost, regional availability, and manufacturing compatibility appropriate for your target prototype