Lawrence Reiner, G.I. Joe, It Turns Out, Had More Than One Father
https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/22/business/origin-of-gi-joe-toy-in-dispute.html
G.I. Joe almost certainly had two fathers.
One was Stan Weston, whose obituary in The New York Times, published online on May 11, gave him sole credit as the creative force behind the military action figure. Obituaries in other prominent publications described Mr. Weston, who was a licensing agent, in the same way.
But further reporting shows that another man, a toy inventor named Lawrence Reiner, played a significant role as Mr. Weston’s lesser-known partner in the venture, although the exact nature of his involvement is difficult to establish.
Mr. Weston’s obituary prompted Mr. Reiner’s daughter Jodi to come forward to assert her father’s role.
It is fair to say that Mr. Reiner contributed, at the least, the idea to have G.I. Joe’s arms and legs articulate, or move. “My father always gave Reiner credit for the articulation idea and never claimed otherwise,” Mr. Weston’s son Steve said by email. “He was compensated at a commensurate rate consistent with that.”
Mr. Weston got a 65 percent stake in the venture and Mr. Reiner 35 percent, according to an unsigned document provided by the Reiner family.
“My father got $35,000, and he bought a house,” Ms. Reiner said in an interview.
Steve Weston said his father’s majority share in the venture suggested his greater role. “The owner and creator gets the lion’s share,” he said. “Quite simply, the idea was my father’s.”
Mr. Reiner’s family says it was his.
The origin story is murky because of a lack of authoritative documents and because of the deaths of Mr. Weston, on May 1, 2017 and Mr. Reiner, in 2001.
According to his family’s account, Mr. Reiner took the idea for a military doll to his employer, the Ideal Toy Company, which rejected it. “My father then presented this idea to Stan to go to Hasbro with,” Ms. Reiner said. “My father was the silent partner.”
Soon after they met, Mr. Reiner sent a letter to himself that described what he had laid out to Mr. Weston. “A 10-inch boy doll to be dressed in combat outfit,” he wrote on April 12, 1963, in a letter that was provided by his family. “This doll to have movable arms and hands in order to hold a rifle and/or other combat weapons.”
Not long after, Mr. Weston seemed to give Mr. Reiner credit for far more than the movable arms and legs. In a letter written on April 24 to Mr. Reiner’s lawyer, Mr. Weston wrote, “Approximately two weeks ago, Larry and I discussed an idea that he had for a line of boy military dolls, designed to scale, including accessory military vehicles.”
Steve Weston said his father wrote the letter only as a favor to Mr. Reiner, to “cover” him with Ideal. But Ms. Reiner said her father had Ideal’s permission to present the idea to Hasbro.
Decades later, in a 2003 email to his granddaughter Jenna Winebaum, Mr. Weston said that he, not Mr. Reiner, had brought the military theme into their partnership. “I remember Larry & I taking a walk together and my telling him of my unrelenting fascination with this subject of the military,” he wrote. He told Mr. Reiner that he was looking for “the hook,” he said, and Mr. Reiner responded, “Make the soldiers movable so you can pose them in all different positions.”
Two years ago, Stan Weston sued Hasbro in federal court to terminate its copyright on G.I. Joe in 2020, at which time Mr. Weston would have been able to license it back to Hasbro or to another company. Mr. Weston and Hasbro settled the lawsuit last year for undisclosed terms. Jodi Reiner said the family was unaware of the lawsuit when it was filed and later decided not to pursue its own legal action.