Chapter 12: Cross-Cultural Exchanges on the Silk Roads

 

 

Vocabulary

 

 

Focus Question #1

            Compare the goods, diseases, and religions on the sea trade routes with those of the Silk Roads.

 

            The Silk Roads and the sea trade routes primarily carried high quality silk and spices west towards the Roman Empire, while on the return trip glassware, jewelry, artwork, perfumes, bronze goods, textiles, pottery, iron tools, wine, and many other manufactured items were brought. The diseases that were suffered were pretty universal— the measles, small pox, and outbreaks of bubonic plague all showed up in all places between these two centers of trade. Buddhist and Hindu merchants took their items west, while Christians generally came east from the Roman Empire with their items.

            The Silk Roads and the sea trade routes were both a part of a very large, very complex, long distance organized trade system between the Han Dynasty and the Roman Empire. The Silk Roads allowed for safe passage over land, while the sea trade routes, after mariners understood the monsoon system, offered reliable sea navigating.

            Although being used primarily for trade, the Silk Roads offered a unique opportunity to missionaries, as well as travelers, and merchants. This unique opportunity was tat they could carry their “beliefs, values, and religious convictions to distant lands”. The three major religions at the time— Buddhism, Christianity, and Hinduism— were all carried along the Silk Road and all three obtained new followers through the process.

            Also travelling the Silk Road however, were epidemic diseases. Some of the most devastating of these diseases were the measles, small pox, and the bubonic plague. Later on these diseases caused massive population decline in China and the regions surrounding the Mediterranean.

 

 

 

Focus Question #2

            Compare the changes and collapses of the Han Dynasty in China with the Roman Empire.

 

            The Han Empire and the Roman Empire differed in many aspects, such as religion, the Han Empire had Confucianism, Buddhism and Hinduism while the Roman Empire had Christianity, Judaism and other Greek cults, and forms of government, the Han Empire was a largely centralized state while the Roman Empire was much more decentralized and democratic. The collapses of the two, however, were similar in many ways, both had economic problems, nomadic invaders, and in the end, the size of their empires were too large to maintain.

            The Han Empire modeled itself after the short lived Qin Empire, and was based largely on Confucianism at first, and later on Buddhism and Hinduism were diffused to the Han people. The Roman Empire is different in the fact that as a state there was never one dominant religion; there was Judaism, Christianity, Roman Mythology, and cults such as Mithraism and the Cult of Ibis— but each had their most prevalent phase, and in the end, Christianity was left standing. A specific example of religious conflict in the Roman Empire is the Jewish Uprising that was squelched by the large military power of the empire. Therefore, religious conflict in both the Han Empire and the Roman Empire played roles in their collapses.

            Another factor contributing to the collapse of the Han Empire and Roman Empire were social conflicts. In the Roman Empire, the class conflict between the Plebeians (lower class) and Patricians (upper class) played a part in the empire’s collapse. And in the Han Empire, the Yellow Turban Uprising, thus dubbed because the rebels wore yellow turbans representing they were peasants, was also overrun by the Han Empire’s military power. However, it still served as a decentralizing factor of the state.

            Two more similarities in the falls of both state powers were their economic problems and land reform policies. Both the Han Empire and the Roman Empire faced economic problems from maintaining their large militaries over the extended periods of time that the states were around. The second similarity is the land reform policies. Emperor Wang Mang proposed the agricultural reform in the Han Empire, which eventually led to such small farms that they were not economically viable. The Land Reform in the Roman Empire was proposed by the Gracchi Brothers and was similar to the Wang Mangs proposal. Both of these ideas cost each respective empire a lot of money.

            One very important difference to the collapses of these two empires however, was how they ended. The Han Dynasty came to a gradual end, decentralizing slowly over time. While the Roman Empire was cut off at the head at one time, transforming its government into a ghost— this was done by the Germanic peoples who invaded the Roman Empire.