Instructional Goal: Students will use primary source documents to understand the different sides of the slavery debate.
By spotting bias and comparing arguments, students will understand how these different viewpoints shaped the birth of our country.
Essential Questions for Me:
Do I value "doing what is right" or "keeping the peace" more?
Why can two people have the same facts but reach different conclusions?
Vocabulary:
Abolitionist: Someone who believes slavery is a moral evil and fights to end it.
Bias: A quick judgment you make based on what you already believe, rather than looking at all the facts.
Show me you know it!
Pick a Vocabulary word and write a sentence.
Imagine the referee makes a tough call against the Ditmas home team.
Option 1 (Ditmas Fan’s Filter): "The referee is being unfair to Ditmas! That was a perfect play, and the ref ruined our chance to win because they clearly dislike our school."
Option 2 (Visiting Team Fan’s Filter): "The referee made the right call. The rules are the rules, and it’s about time they stopped Ditmas from playing so aggressively."
The "Who is Right?" Question: Looking at the Ditmas vs. Visiting team argument, who is really right? Is it possible for both people to see the same thing but disagree on what happened?
Use Visual Thinking Strategy (VTS) to analyze
Liberty Displaying the Arts and Sciences
on PAGE 9
(The "Perspective" approach):
"Based on the symbols and actions in this picture,
which side of the slavery debate do you think the artist was on?
We are going to look closely at the painting together. As you look, keep these three questions in mind. You don't need to know the "right" answer—just be ready to explain what you see!
** What is going on in this picture?
(Tell me the story of what you see.)
What do you see that makes you say that? (Point to a specific part of the painting to back up your idea.)
What more can we find?
(Look again—is there a detail you missed the first time?)
Once we finish our observations, I will share some "behind-the-scenes" history about the artist, Samuel Jennings, and why he chose to give this painting to a library in Philadelphia.
After you learn the history, ask yourself:
Did your first ideas about the painting change after hearing the background story?
How does the artist use symbols (like the books or the broken chains) to send a message about freedom?
Remember: Your goal is to act like a historian. Historians look at the evidence in a picture, think about who made it and why, and then decide what the image tells us about life at that time.
Instructions:
With your partner, choose two different speakers from the provided documents.
Use the guide below to analyze each source.
After skimming all the authors, pick two and answer the following:
Who, When, Where?
** Who is the author? (e.g., A delegate? An abolitionist?)
When/What: Context:
What was happening in the country at this time?
(e.g., The Constitutional Convention, or the rise of slave insurrections).
Where does this person live or work?
(Do you think this affects their opinion?)
What is their perspective?
**What is their main point about slavery?
**Evidence: Find one specific quote from the text that proves their point.
Why was it written?
Purpose: Why do you think the is the author saying this?
Are they trying to protect the Union,
or are they fighting for human rights?
"Word Bank":
Abolitionist (someone against slavery)
Delegate (a person sent to represent others)
Inconsistent (not matching; going against)
Insurrection (a violent uprising or rebellion)
Sentence Starters: To help students who struggle to get started, give them these sentence starters:
"The author’s point of view is that slavery is __________ because..."
"The evidence that supports this is the quote: '__________'."
"This document was written because the author wanted to __________."