Student Complaints and Grievances

Mount Carmel College of Nursing has a formal process for addressing and resolving student complaints emerging from alleged violations of College policies, procedures, or established practices on the part of a College faculty member, staff member, or department.

Submitting Complaints

Individuals may submit complaints using the online reporting form (also available by copying and pasting: https://mccn.guardianconduct.com/incident-reporting/ into your internet browser).  Complaints may be filed directly with the Director of Compliance and Community Affairs by contacting 614-234-2341 or emailing compliance@mccn.edu.

To file a formal grievance with the Higher Learning Commission and/or the Ohio Department of Education, please refer to https://www.mccn.edu/about/compliance/state-authorization/sara-student-complaints.

This policy addresses student complaints and grievances not otherwise covered by another College policy or procedure. Guidance and procedures for complaints covered by other policies are described and listed below:

• General College Policies & Code of Conduct  

  • Student Code of Conduct Reporting Form

• Accommodations for Students with Disabilities

• Academic Appeal: Grades or Evaluations of Academic Performance

• Sexual Harassment or Gender Discrimination/Title IX

  • Title IX Reporting Form

External Agencies to Report Complaints & Grievances

The Ohio Department of Higher Education

• The Ohio Department of Higher Education (ODHE) is responsible for responding to formal complaints against public, independent non-profit, and proprietary institutions of higher education in Ohio. While the Ohio Department of Higher Education has limited authority over colleges and universities, and cannot offer legal advice or initiate civil court cases, ODHE staff will review submitted complaints and work with student complainants and institutions. Information can be found on its website. Student Complaint Information | The Ohio Department of Higher Education 

The Higher Learning Commission (HLC)

• The Higher Learning Commission (HLC) is an independent body responsible for the accreditation of programs offered by Mount Carmel College of Nursing. The HLC receives complaints from students or other parties. When a complaint raises issues regarding an institution’s ability to meet accreditation criteria, the HLC will forward a copy of the complaint to the institution and request a formal response. Instructions for filing a complaint with the Commission are available on its website. https://www.hlcommission.org/Student-Resources/complaints.html

​Office of Civil Rights

• The Office for Civil Rights enforces several Federal civil rights laws that prohibit discrimination in programs or activities that receive federal financial assistance from the Department of Education. It is the mission of the Office for Civil Rights is to ensure equal access to education and to promote educational excellence throughout the nation through vigorous enforcement of civil rights. Discrimination on the basis of race, color, and national origin is prohibited by Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.  This includes discrimination based on a person’s limited English proficiency or English learner status; and actual or perceived shared ancestry or ethnic characteristics, including membership in a religion that may be perceived to exhibit such characteristics (such as Hindu, Jewish, Muslim, and Sikh individuals). https://www2.ed.gov/about/offices/list/ocr/docs/howto.html

​State Authorization Reciprocity Agreement (SARA)

• If you are a student in an online program and you have concerns and/or complaints, please contact your program advisor first.

  • Online RN to BSN Completion Program: Dr. Courtney McGuire (cmcguire@mccn.edu)

  • Master of Science:

    1. 1. • FNP: Dr. Jessica Kimmett (jkimmett@mccn.edu)

          • PMHNP: Dr. Kay Dixon-Bell (kdixon-bell@mccn.edu)

          • AGNP: Dr. Michelle Weaver (mweaver@mccn.edu)

  • Doctor of Nursing Practice (DNP) Program: Dr. Joan Brammer (jbrammer@mccn.edu) 

• If a student located in a State Authorization Reciprocity Agreement (SARA) state has a complaint about an institution operating under SARA, the complaints must first go through the institution’s procedure (noted above) for resolution of the concern. If a student is not satisfied with the outcome of the institutional process, the complaint may be brought to the SARA portal agency in the institution’s home state – refer to the SARA Student Complaint Process. States that are members of SARA can be found on the NC-SARA Website.

California

Bureau for Private Postsecondary Education
Telephone: (916) 263-1897
Online Dispute Resolution Request

Texas

Mount Carmel College of Nursing (MCCN) is not regulated in Texas under Chapter 132 of the Texas Education Code

Internal Informal Resolution

Before an official complaint or grievance is initiated, every effort should be made by the individual(s) to resolve the issue directly. Students should follow appropriate Chain of Command procedures outlined in a course syllabus. Complaints that fall outside of the classroom setting can be directed to the appropriate College Leadership. This good faith effort to resolve a problem is encouraged by the Office of Compliance and Community Affairs prior to directing the complainant to submit a formal Complaint Form.

Internal Formal Resolution Process

1. Complaint is filed using the form listed above.

2. Student Complaint Form is received by the Director of Compliance and Community Affairs who conducts a preliminary review of the complaint. The Director may consult with other appropriate departments, including Colleague Relations within Mount Carmel Health System, to determine the next appropriate steps. If the complaint is against the Director of Compliance and Community Affairs, it is reviewed by the President.

3. An investigation will be conducted and a written final determination will be sent to the student who filed the initial complaint via MCCN email. Please note that the completion of the investigation may take up to 14 academic days, depending on the complexity of the issues involved.

4. If students need assistance in completing the General Complaint Form, they are encouraged to reach out to a member of the College faculty or staff (including, but not limited to the Academic Advisor or Student Success Coordinator).  

5. The College reserves the right to take immediate interim actions as necessary and appropriate to protect the safety and well-being of the campus and community.

Internal Appeals

Students have the right to appeal the outcome of a decision by filing a written appeal to the Dean of Nursing and Allied Health, or designee, within fourteen (14) academic days of receipt of written notice of the determination.

An appeal must be filed online (https://mccn.guardianconduct.com/incident-reporting/)

Appeals may be filed under the following circumstances. It is the responsibility of the student, in writing, to prove one or more of the following occurred for an appeal to be accepted:

• Procedural error that resulted in significant harm to the student. Deviations from the designated procedures will not be a basis for accepting an appeal unless the deviations are material, substantial, and/or significant harm or bias resulted;

• The Investigator or initial decision maker had a conflict of interest, bias or prejudice that prevented a fair and impartial decision;

• Substantial new evidence/information that was unavailable at the time of the decision and which reasonably could have affected the decision is now available;

• Dissatisfaction with a decision may not be the sole reason for the appeal.

The appellate body, or designee, will decide the appeal based upon a review of the supporting documents, which must be submitted by the student appealing the decision. The appeal officer may consider additional relevant information from any individual or office related to the incident and then decide the appeal based upon the enhanced record. The decision of the appeal officer is final. The appeal officer may:

• • • Uphold the original decision;

    • Modify the decision;

    • Refer the case to the original decision maker or refer the case to a new decision maker for a new decision.

Record Keeping

The College will keep a record of complaints (and the resolutions) submitted for Formal Resolution, as required by law and regulation. This record is kept on file with Compliance and Community Affairs.